6 ms·
Seriously? Ubuntu has the best font rendering of any operating system that I've used. Mac OS X is perfectly good, but it doesn't tend to feel as nice as Ubuntu
by chrismorgan 14y ago
Seriously? Ubuntu has the best font rendering of any operating system that I've used.
Mac OS X is perfectly good, but it doesn't tend to feel as nice as Ubuntu. Especially when you get to things like Indic scripts.
Windows' font rendering (I can only speak for up to Windows 7) is still quite nasty, especially at larger font sizes. The lack of vertical antialiasing ruins it for these cases.
- ekr 14y agoThe article is about an upgrade to the Freetype library, more specifically to the CFF rasterizer. It has nothing to do with TrueType fonts (most of them, probably). I've been using Arch Linux as my only OS for more than 5 years, and the only certain applications have given me font-related trouble. Firefox somehow doesn't select the correct alternative (even though fontconfig works fine).
- gjulianm 14y agoAlthough I haven't tried 13.04 yet, Qt apps on Ubuntu weren't that great on font rendering. There's room for improvement there. Also, take into account that Linux is not Ubuntu. It's a growing trend to identify Linux with Ubuntu, as if other distributions (or even other desktop environments in the same Ubuntu distro) weren't to take into account. Have you seen KDE font rendering? Open a Chromium browser, navigate to some pages, it's awful.
- kijin 14y agoEven among the Ubuntu variants, font rendering is only smooth in GTK-based desktop environments, i.e. GNOME/Unity and XFCE. Last time I checked, fonts looked awful in Kubuntu, especially if you opened either Firefox or LibreOffice. Lubuntu likewise looks like it received none of the font rendering improvements that Ubuntu has had by default for ages. Of course, "awful" is subjective so you might prefer the way KDE and LXDE render fonts. But it doesn't change the fact that they're different.
- blinkingled 14y agoYou can make the fonts looks equally good in Kubuntu by doing this - http://askubuntu.com/questions/130758/how-to-configure-kubuntu-fonts-to-look-line-ones-used-in-unity-ubuntu-12-04 http://askubuntu.com/questions/130758/how-to-configure-kubun... and changing the Desktop Effect -> Scaling Method to Crisp.
- kijin 14y agoDoes it also affect Firefox and LibreOffice?
- blinkingled 14y agoYes, just make sure to use the gtk-oxygen theme with the right font for GTK+ apps.
- kps 14y ago>Also, take into account that Linux is not Ubuntu. And that FreeType is not Linux only.
- gjulianm 14y agoAlthough I haven't tried 13.04 yet, Qt apps on Ubuntu weren't that great on font rendering. There's room for improvement there. Also, take into account that Linux is not Ubuntu. It's a growing trend to identify Linux with Ubuntu, as if other distributions (or even other desktop environments in the same Ubuntu distro) weren't to take into account. Have you seen KDE font rendering? Open a Chromium browser, navigate to some pages, it's awful.
- drivebyacct2 14y agoAgreed. I made this in the past: http://i.imgur.com/4dGbR.png http://i.imgur.com/4dGbR.png (Ubuntu) http://i.imgur.com/mfyjw.png http://i.imgur.com/mfyjw.png (OS X) http://i.imgur.com/BqOdg.png http://i.imgur.com/BqOdg.png (Windows 7)
- acdha 14y agoInteresting: in terms of visual quality, I would rank those in order of decreasing preference as OS X, Windows 7, Ubuntu.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- rlanday 14y agoIs Windows even using the same font? I think Windows prioritizes making the text look sharp over getting all the character strokes in the right place. OS X and Ubuntu look very similar except for the line spacing, and the lowercase ‘a’, which looks kind of strange/vertically compressed on Ubuntu.
- drivebyacct2 14y agoThey should all be using Verdana, as per HN's CSS. I have the font installed in each OS so it should be a fair fight unless I screwed something different up.
- velodrome 14y agoThe font in the Ubuntu image is not Verdana. Ubuntu does not install Microsoft fonts by default. It will fallback to Ubuntu's default font.
- drivebyacct2 14y agoI always have msttcorefonts installed which includes Verdana. It's part of the script that is the first thing I run on a new install... (Like, a half hour ago, I checked that Verdana was installed and then recreated the screenshot from the original post and it's identical as far as I can tell.
- frou_dh 14y agoThis debate is pointless because people almost always give the nod to what they're personally most accustomed to, perhaps also labelling the others as garbage for good measure.
- Legion 14y agoUbuntu's patches for the various font rendering technologies are my #1 must-have software on Linux. Any distro I use is either a Ubuntu or something that has these patches an easy install away. (Arch has them in the AUR, for example)
- drivebyacct2 14y agoThis has, honestly, been a blind spot of mine and something that has kept me in Ubuntu rather than Arch or Debian. Can you elaborate on what the patches are called and how to replicate Ubuntu's rendering in Arch? Thanks so much.
- abrowne 14y agohttps://wiki.archlinux.org/index.php/Font_Configuration#Ubuntu https://wiki.archlinux.org/index.php/Font_Configuration#Ubun...
- drivebyacct2 14y agoNow I really feel clueless for not knowing better to check the Arch Wiki. Thanks.
- wfunction 14y ago> Windows' font rendering (I can only speak for up to Windows 7) is still quite nasty, especially at larger font sizes. The lack of vertical antialiasing ruins it for these cases. Weird, I would consider that Windows has the best font rendering. Do you have any example photos you'd like to show? A comment below [1] has some pictures, do you really find Windows's rendering to be bad? 1: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5644228 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5644228
- shardling 14y agoI remember reading that people get very used/comfortable to Mac vs. Windows style of font rendering, and tend to perceive the other as inferior.
- stephen_g 14y agoI used to like Windows' font rendering (when they introduced ClearType), but after having to Mac OS X about five years ago and using an iPhone and iPad for a couple of years I'm so used to Apple's font rendering that Windows looks really ugly to me... Quite subjective though. Perhaps it's partially due to the fact that Mac laptops and iDevices have higher quality displays than typical Windows machines?
- wisty 14y agoYes, this classic flame war. There used to be a Windows vs OSX font rendering flame war every week on HN, in the good old days. OSX uses antialiasing, which means the fonts have a nice shape, but they are fuzzy, blurry, and to some users headache-inducing. Windows reshapes the fonts so they fit perfectly in the pixel grid, but the shape is not what will be printed, and it looks ugly to some users. Because people like what they are used to, and because Apple vs Microsoft is already a flame war, no-one can really agree.
- dmxt 14y agoWhat kind of font rendering does Ubuntu uses? I'm on Arch and freetype-infinality rendering is incredibe eye candy.