4 ms·
> This was 7.5 billion worth of collateral in extremely safe treasury bonds. > this is the 10 billion number that "went from tax payers to goldman" that everyo
by anamax 18y ago
> This was 7.5 billion worth of collateral in extremely safe treasury bonds.
> this is the 10 billion number that "went from tax payers to goldman" that everyone keeps saying
Goldman Sachs was owed $10B. 7.5B was available in pledged securities. Goldman got $10B in cash because of govt flow-through via AIG.
> So to be prudent, they bought CDS protection that would pay 2.5 billion in the event of default.
Shouldn't the insurer be paying off, if solvent, and not the US govt? And, if the insurer is not solvent, why shouldn't Goldman take the hit?
> What is the problem here?
The claim is that Goldman is not taking a hit from their transactions with AIG while other parties are. The above documents that Goldman is, in fact, not taking a hit from their transactions with AIG.
The only remaining question is whether other parties are taking a hit for their transactions with AIG. If they are, the question is Goldman Sachs is being treated differently.
- op12 18y ago> Goldman Sachs was owed $10B. 7.5B was available in pledged securities. Goldman got $10B in cash because of govt flow-through via AIG. If someone has pledged the majority of what is owed to me in collateral, it is wrong for people to imply that the 10 billion flowing through the government was just some windfall flowthrough. They got what they were owed, and the taxpayers got their 7.5 billion in collateral back. If the taxpayers did not pay the 10 billion, then they wouldn't have gotten 7.5 billion worth in treasuries returned to them--Goldman would have had the right to keep it, and this is the whole point of having collateral pledged to them in the first place. > Shouldn't the insurer be paying off, if solvent, and not the US govt? And, if the insurer is not solvent, why shouldn't Goldman take the hit? Are you talking about the CDS insurer? The insurance only needs to be paid if AIG defaults. If AIG defaults then the US govt doesn't have to pay anything, the insurer does. Since AIG was bailed out, no credit event was triggered and the CDS insurance becomes worthless. The upside is of course they actually get their money. In either case, whether AIG was allowed to fail or not, they would have been made whole. Goldman was not treated differently in this case. Many other banks were treated the exact same way. Yes, Goldman was paid out in their insurance. So is any individual who took out insurance with AIG--they will actually get paid what is owed to them as well now.
- gills 18y agoIf what you say is true, and Goldman hedged their hedge by purchasing CDS on AIG and/or outright shorting them, it should be trivial for a prosecutor to show that they entered a contract with AIG knowing fully that it could never be satisfied (who knows, there may even be a side letter to be found somewhere to that effect...) -- making the contract void and requiring a clawback of any payment made through AIG by Treasury.
- op12 18y agoHow does purchasing CDS insurance on a counterparty imply that they knew full well it could never be satisfied? If I purchase hurricane insurance on my home do I know full well a hurricane is going to destroy my house? It was a precautionary measure for an amount that was the difference between what they were owed and how much collateral was pledged. It indicates nothing of the sort that they knew full well the world was going to blow up and AIG would default And what I say is true, there are many many public disclosures on exactly what their positions were.
- anamax 18y ago> If someone has pledged the majority of what is owed to me in collateral, it is wrong for people to imply that the 10 billion flowing through the government was just some windfall flowthrough. I didn't say that it was a windfall. I said that Goldman was made whole by the US govt via AIG. If other folks are losing money in similar circumstances, it's fair to ask why Goldman is being treated differently. And, even if everyone is being made whole, the question remains - why should the US make them whole? Why shouldn't they lose money for taking bad counter-party risks? They were planning to keep the money that they made for assuming said risks, so why shouldn't they take the hit when things work out badly? If I buy something that turns out to be worth less than I expected, I take the loss. Why not Goldman and other banks? > They got what they were owed, and the taxpayers got their 7.5 billion in collateral back. If the taxpayers did not pay the 10 billion I'll pay $7.5B for $10B. > In either case, whether AIG was allowed to fail or not, they would have been made whole. Maybe, maybe not, but in any event, not by the US govt.
- 18y ago