4 ms·
I recently had a discussion here about Nazis rounding up people for concentration camps and why the right to bear arms does not help much. IMO the first amendm
by lifeisstillgood 14y ago
I recently had a discussion here about Nazis rounding up people for concentration camps and why the right to bear arms does not help much. IMO the first amendment is a better defence than the second.
In the end that's what journalism is for - telling us when and where democracy and our rule of law is failing. Doing so clearly, authoritatively and with impact.
Wikileaks is in that definition journalism - as was watergate. We will all be much much poorer if we cannot ensure the survival of that journalism.
I think the secret lies in the fact I cannot tell between a blog post about a conspiracy nut in a parking garage and a blog post about the deputy director of the FBI in a parking garage.
Ben Bradlee could. We need editors if we are going to keep journalism.
- nwzpaperman 14y agoThe problem you are talking about isn't editor vs. no editor, it's accountability.
- lifeisstillgood 14y agoDo you mean how do we ensure government is conducted transparently, openly and accountably to the people under that government? Yeah, the reaction to wiki leaks clearly shows the greatest democracy on earth is down with transparent accountability
- nwzpaperman 14y agoGovernment transparency is a distinct issue. What I was speaking to is the low barrier to opening a blog under a pseudonym, posting something and sharing it without any long-term disincentive to be accurate or truthful. Wikileaks is not the end-all, it is a stepping stone. Extremely damaging or valuable secrets or only known to a very limited group, so anonymous information isn't really anonymous in that sense. Wikileaks is just another gatekeeper, it isn't a distribution network. Assange and his brand have an audience, but that's all it is when you break it down critically.
- nwzpaperman 14y agoHerbert Spencer: http://www.econlib.org/library/LFBooks/Spencer/spnMvS9.html http://www.econlib.org/library/LFBooks/Spencer/spnMvS9.html "Yet that societies are not artificially put together, is a truth so manifest, that it seems wonderful men should ever have overlooked it. Perhaps nothing more clearly shows the small value of historical studies, as they have been commonly pursued. You need but to look at the changes going on around, or observe social organization in its leading traits, to see that these are neither supernatural, nor are determined by the wills of individual men, as by implication the older historians teach; but are consequent on general natural causes." Democracy is an effect, not a cause. Don't conflate the two or project values on to me to which I have not espoused.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]