4 ms·
Keep in mind, from the judgement, section II Legal Standard: In determining facial plausibility, whether a complaint states a plausible claim is a “context-spe
by tempestn 14y ago
Keep in mind, from the judgement, section II Legal Standard:
In determining facial plausibility, whether a complaint states a plausible claim is a “context-specific task that requires the reviewing court to draw on its
judicial experience and common sense.” Id.
at 679. Allegations of material fact are taken as
true and construed in the light most favorable to the non-moving party.
http://3taps.com/images/pics/430_138734862-Judge-rules-in-favor-of-Craigslist-on-motion-to-dismiss-in-case-vs-3taps-Padmapper-Lovely.pdf http://3taps.com/images/pics/430_138734862-Judge-rules-in-fa...
So essentially these findings are made while reading all facts in the best possible light for craigslist. So it's not necessarily saying, for example, that the compilation is copyrightable - just that it is conceivable that it could be.
- DannyBee 14y agoI agree in theory, but at least my complaints are basically "even if what craigslist said is completely right, they still should have lost on the law", which is in line with the judgement standard :)