5 ms·
Just out of curiousity, if they didn't release the code given the GPL2 license, could they be sued in private courts to release it?
by dmix 14y ago
Just out of curiousity, if they didn't release the code given the GPL2 license, could they be sued in private courts to release it?
- jmonegro 14y agoProbably more preventing them from selling it rather than forcing them to release it.
- doe88 14y agoI'm not a specialist at all of these questions but I would say that kernel modifications are not worth taking such a big risk. And if they wanted to avoid publishing the code of some parts of their kernel implementation maybe they could instead make a kernel module and in this case I believe it is accepted of not releasing the source code of the module. But in any case as mentionned in other comments I believe the interesting code is more high level, or server side.
- icebraining 14y agoThey could be sued, but only by copyright holders of Linux source code.
- nnnnni 14y ago...and wouldn't that be anyone who has ever submitted a patch that has been accepted by Linus?
- hkmurakami 14y agoConsidering legal costs (which, while I imagine are lower than patent litigation, must be formidable for random Joe), I'd imagine that some 'entity' would have to do this on the behalf of said contributor(s).
- mistercow 14y agoThat entity would probably be the Linux Foundation in this case.
- DannyBee 14y agoIn theory, yes, but at least in the US, you'd also have to register the copyright. Plus a random patch runs the risk of getting a decision that it was de-minimis, etc.
- mistercow 14y ago>you'd also have to register the copyright But you can do that after the infringement has taken place, as long as you do so within some period of time (60 days I think?) after you become aware of the infringement.
- DannyBee 14y agoYes, you can do it after infringement, but it is a pre-requisite to actually filing a lawsuit (unless you want that lawsuit dismissed immediately :P)
- huhtenberg 14y agoSomeone like this guy - http://gpl-violations.org http://gpl-violations.org
- belorn 14y agoRecipients of copies can still claim false product/advertisement. In EU law, if the consumer can claim that the expected product was one with source code included (thanks to GPL notifications), certain laws gets into effect. First, the consumer has the right for compensation (normally the price of the product). Second, the company will be forced to stop claiming that the product is under GPL. This then leads to either willing infringement (ie, removing the GPL notification once its been there), or continue misleading the consumer (Very large fines). So far, I have not heard of any case like that. The closest was a case regarding contract law, which is tangent.