4 ms·
The trend reflects a generation of Millennials—ranging in age from 18 to 34—who grew up texting and using smartphones and social media This is somewhat tangent
by slg 14y ago
The trend reflects a generation of Millennials—ranging in age from 18 to 34—who grew up texting and using smartphones and social media
This is somewhat tangential, but I think grouping this entire generation together and attributing their behavior to social networks, texting, and/or the Internet doesn't make any sense. 34 year olds likely weren't able to join Facebook until their late twenties and 18 year olds likely don't even remember a world without widespread Internet use. Those experiences are wildly different and will therefore affect people in wildly different ways.
- greenyoda 14y agoAlso, the article talks about behavior seen in "recent college grads", which hardly includes 34 year olds.
- uiri 14y agoIt could be that the journalist made a typo and intended to write 18 to 24 year olds.
- pjscott 14y agoIndeed it doesn't, and the whole basis of this story is very anecdotal and shaky. But that's just it -- it's a story, not a factual report about what's actually happening in the world. A disturbing amount of journalism is storytelling, and the facts are just the raw material from which the story is crafted. In this case, the story is a retread of a tired old classic: "Kids these days are doing some pretty crazy stuff!"
- bicknergseng 14y agoNew article idea: Millennials to journalists: anecdotes are not accurate representations of large groups of people.
- jonnathanson 14y agoThe entire concept of "Millenials" has always struck me as somewhat of a square peg in a round hole. As you have identified, so freaking much changed over the last 34 years. So much. Almost every aspect of modern life is dramatically different in ways we now take for granted, and it changed in major steps throughout those 34 years. To think the lower and upper bounds of the 18-34 demographic have all that much in common is pretty silly. That being said, generations are broad demographic sets -- not behavioral cohorts. They are highly heterogeneous sets, and always have been. In some cases, speaking of the "Millenial" demographic makes sense, especially in broad, economic terms (i.e., when talking about the size of the demographic vis-a-vis the future of the US labor market). But trying to treat the demographic as a homogeneous set, or in broad behavioral terms, is where things get dicey really quickly. Some generalities apply, but only in specific contexts.