4 ms·
A random note for those who might wonder what "N" and "S" mean on another planet. Take your right hand out. Stick your thumb up. Curl your fingers around. Y
by btilly 14y ago
A random note for those who might wonder what "N" and "S" mean on another planet.
Take your right hand out. Stick your thumb up. Curl your fingers around. Your thumb represents a planet's N pole, and your fingers point in the direction that the planet is spinning. (The Earth moves from W to E, and the result is that it looks like the Sun rises in the E. Sit down a globe and a flashlight if this comment makes no sense.)
For any spinning thing we can do the same exercise. Just wrap your fingers of your right hand around in the direction of the spin, stick your thumb up, and that is the North pole of that spin.
Now for the fun fact. Most of the stuff in the Solar System rotates roughly the same way. It doesn't matter whether you take the rotation of the Earth, the rotation of the Moon, the orbit of the Moon around the Earth, the orbit of the Earth around the Sun, the orbit of Saturn around the Sun, the rotation of Saturn, the orbits of Saturn's moons around Saturn - the north poles of all of these are reasonably well aligned.
They are not exactly aligned. For instance the Earth's rotational axis is tilted 23.5 degrees from the axis of its orbit around the Sun. (Hence our seasons.) And not everything follows the rule. Uranus is the best-known exception. But most of it lines up fairly well.
The only actual use that I've ever found for this fact is being able to explain to my son why the Moon rises later every night, but I've always thought that it was pretty cool.
EDIT: glurgh below corrected my understanding. It happens that for most of the planets, North corresponds to the right hand rule as I described. But that's not actually the way it is defined and Venus in particular does not work that way.
- cefarix 14y agoGood ol' cross-product and angular momentum!
- btilly 14y agoExactly. The right hand rule. And it isn't coincidence that stuff tends to spin the same way. Because when you don't then tidal forces try to pull you back into alignment. Of course, being basically frictionless tops, the main effect is that the rotation precesses. (The Earth's rotation takes about 26,000 years to precess.) However there is a tiny tidal friction component that slowly tends to bring things into alignment, and which is trying to lock all spins to each other. And the operative word here is "slowly". If the Moon had been thrown off, spinning the opposite way from the Earth, it would have remerged. Instead the Earth's rotation is being transferred into throwing the Moon into a higher orbit at about 4 cm/year. (For comparison, this is a bit under twice the rate that the North American Plate is moving.) The main consequence here on Earth is that the UTC system that we all use is going to have to add leap seconds more and more often over time, and in a few thousand years either we'll need to reconsider either the length of the second, or our tying the measurement of time to astronomy. (My vote would be to remove the astronomical definition. Humans seem to be OK living with time zones that do not match the sky. Having to move those time zones every few centuries does not seem like that big a deal. There won't be an observable issue in a normal human lifespan from this until after longer than human civilization has existed so far. Astronomers are in charge of UTC right now, and they would hate the change. But when you consider how much it would cost astronomy to cope compared with the real costs of software bugs that tend show up when they insert leap seconds in UTC, right now the tail is very much wagging the dog.
- glurgh 14y ago> reconsider either the length of the second This one is done - the definition of the second is not based on astronomical observations. "Since 1967, the second has been defined to be: the duration of 9,192,631,770 periods of the radiation corresponding to the transition between the two hyperfine levels of the ground state of the caesium 133 atom" The accuracy of this kind of measurement is so high it's also used (along with the speed of light) as the basis for defining the meter. Earth-time is a complicated and messy business but the base unit, the second, is pretty much nailed down and independent.
- btilly 14y agoI was stating logical possibilities, not feasible ones. You are right in how we define the second. It was chosen so that on average the number of seconds from midnight to midnight is 606024 = 86,400. At this point a ton of stuff depends on it - the only change that I think likely is to something that we can measure even more precisely than the current standard. But we have set up UTC such that the first second of every year starts close to midnight for the Royal Observatory at Greenwich, London. This sometimes requires having minutes with 59 or 61 seconds (usually 61). These weird minutes have real costs. For instance the June 30, 2012 leap second crashed Linux machines around the world, taking down quite a few websites. And the costs are only projected to increase as we have more programs that make assumptions about UTC, and the slowing day requires more leap seconds to be added. Therefore logically we have 3 choices. Change the meaning of a second (not feasible), continue putting up with leap seconds (costly, and serves no purpose unless you're an astronomer), or give up the UTC peg to an astronomical fact. Unfortunately astronomers control UTC right now, don't want to give it up, and don't care how much their leap seconds cost everyone else. But this can't last forever. Given the way that things work, I don't think that it will change until there is some disaster that is too big to ignore. For instance a leap second bug causes some critical control software to fail, leading to a industrial accident, which brings the attention of politicians and the general public to this ridiculous situations. (Or crashes critical aviation software. Or something else on that scale.) If the current situation maintains, it is just a question of time until something on that scale happens. But until that happens, I don't think that astronomers will understand the costs that they are imposing on the rest of the world. My thinking is that since it is obvious that we'll lose the astronomical peg eventually, we should lose it now. Before someone dies.
- not_that_noob 14y agoTo add to your fun fact: the reason that most of the planets spin in the same direction is that the solar system formed from a single giant rotating disc of rocks and debris. I have found that to be endlessly fascinating - that the reason the planets dance together in harmony is because of their common and violent birthing process.
- btilly 14y agoAnd the stuff that happened to randomly go against the flow generally gets pulled into lockstep with the rest by tidal forces. But not entirely - the amount of axial tilt turns out to be a chaotic system. About 20 years ago I ran across an estimate that if the Earth did not have the Moon, then every so often we would randomly wind up with a sufficient tilt to be extremely difficult for life. Therefore our Moon may have been critical for sustaining life as we know it. See http://www.nytimes.com/1993/03/02/science/moon-may-save-earth-from-chaotic-tilting-of-other-planets.html?pagewanted=all&src=pm http://www.nytimes.com/1993/03/02/science/moon-may-save-eart... for confirmation of that tidbit.
- ra 14y agoTo add to that, the reason that the tilt is so important for life on Earth, is because the tilt causes the seasons. The seasonal variation of warmth from the sun leads to differences in atmospheric and surface temperatures. The atmosphere warms faster than the oceans, creating a temperature gradient. This is the primarily mechanism that energises the water cycle. i.e. evaporation, cloud formation, rain, rivers etc.
- pasbesoin 14y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Right_hand_rule#Direction_associated_with_a_rotation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Right_hand_rule#Direction_asso... -- P.S. See you've now mentioned it in your response to another comment. That and this comment apparently passed in space without aggregating (into a combined rotation).
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- glurgh 14y agoThis is only for minor bodies, not planets. The poles of planets are pretty much defined to be 'pointed the same way as the Earth's'. The north pole of Venus is roughly aligned with the north pole of the Earth despite the fact that Venus's rotation is retrograde. See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poles_of_astronomical_bodies http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poles_of_astronomical_bodies
- btilly 14y agoThank you for the correction. I tend to pick up fun trivia, but I'm not an expert, and always appreciate when someone corrects mistakes in my understanding.
- glurgh 14y agoI didn't know either! Makes sense geometrically but I wondered is it really the case that when you read something like 'image of the North pole of Venus', it's really the opposite pole. It looks like astronomers rely on the 'convenient' convention until they can't and then fall back to the mathematical one.
- btilly 14y agoYou made me curious. According to http://imagine.gsfc.nasa.gov/docs/ask_astro/answers/980225a.html http://imagine.gsfc.nasa.gov/docs/ask_astro/answers/980225a.... there is no real connection between the direction of rotation within the Solar System and the Sun's orbit around the Milky Way. And again the Milky Way's rotation has little to do with its motion in the local group. However across the Milky Way there are again a whole lot of things roughly moving in the same direction.
- glurgh 14y agoIt looks like the Galactic Coordinate System (which, sensibly but to the confusion of the casual reader is centered on the Sun) is also 'backwards' with respect to the right hand rule. The galactic north pole is actually the galactic rotational south pole. This seems to be because the coordinate system was based on the rotational direction of the Sun. I think I may have just exceeded my recommended daily nerdallowance of reading about spinning things in the sky.
- SatvikBeri 14y agoI never understood the right-hand rule in college, but somehow your explanation made perfect sense to me. Thank you.