6 ms·
as an educational platform it's nowhere near dead That's an interesting point of view. To refer specifically to the example you gave, what is it about computer
by tokenadult 18y ago
as an educational platform it's nowhere near dead
That's an interesting point of view. To refer specifically to the example you gave, what is it about computer science that can best be learned (only be learned?) in college? Does showing that lack of college study of computer science is correlated with lack of basic programming knowledge (which I would believe, for the sake of discussion) the same as showing that lack of college study of CS will CAUSE, inevitably, lack of basic programming knowledge? Can't anyone who desires to improve programming knowledge self-educate through multiple channels in today's world?
After edit: It appears that the reply to which I am replying has now been deleted. I'll open up the questions to everyone else reading the thread.
- whughes 18y agoThe problem is that the value of certain computer science concepts, such as big-Oh notation, may not be immediately obvious for someone self-educating. They can skip over these mathematical/CS concepts in favor of more 'practical' software engineering study. You don't need to know lambda calculus or even basic sorting algorithms to write business logic apps -- and so these things get ignored.
- Alex3917 18y agoI love how big-Oh notation is the default example of what you need college for in every single Reddit/HN discussion of education.
- smokinn 18y agoIt's happened more than once that I've seen (and had to explain) why putting while loops inside while loops (once saw a one code snippet with 4 nested whiles!) is going to run fine on your dev box with 5 rows in the database but is going to be excruciatingly slow if you move it to production and data starts pouring in. Granted, in some of the cases the person did have a college degree and should've known how big-Oh applied here but must've been asleep in class.
- tokenadult 18y agoin some of the cases the person did have a college degree and should've known how big-Oh applied This would serve as a counterexample to the idea that college is uniquely suitable for learning some important subjects, right?
- smokinn 18y agoTechnically, no, it wouldn't. Not as you stated it. College being uniquely suitable for learning a subject does not ensure that someone will learn it if they go to college. You can say that to learn x you must go to college. If you went to college though the fact that you did or did not learn x says nothing about whether you need to go to college or not to learn it. You get drilled with exactly this type of logic problem a LOT in discrete math courses. Stuff there's no way the extreme vast majority of working programmers would study on their own just because. That's being pedantic though, I imagine you're saying that it doesn't matter whether you go to college or not since you can make the same kind of mistakes when you get out. The latter part of which is true. But there's no doubt in my mind that had the guy that did go to college would be a lot worse had he not gone. He'd most probably not be able to write code that worked at all rather than code that works but not as optimally as it could.
- tokenadult 18y agoAgreeing with you that many "theoretical" topics are more practically important than learners of many domains realize at first, why should I be convinced that college is a uniquely good environment for thoroughly learning important subjects such as lambda calculus or analysis of algorithms?
- billswift 18y agoThese kinds of claims are common; G Harry Stine in his "The Hopeful Future" wrote, "A self-taught person is usually deficient in one or more areas of his learning expertise." There are several problems with the claim, but the most important is that if a self-taught person discovers he or she needs to know something that they missed earlier, they simply need to go find it out, since they have avoided becoming dependent on others to tell them what to learn and when.
- smokinn 18y agoWe're constantly reminded of the people who are productive coders without a college degree so the counter-example is well established. I don't think you'll get anyone to go along with "lack of college study of CS will CAUSE, inevitably, lack of basic programming knowledge". In the general case however, a majority of people who start college degrees (there are exceptions, again, such as MIT but those colleges put out a very small percentage of graduates) don't have programming experience. Surely you wouldn't want someone like who I was before college, just a regular guy who would chat a lot online, sometimes play video games (but not much), had written some mIRC scripts and a web page (static HTML with dreamweaver), installed linux a few times but didn't like it much, could build a computer from parts bought separately, did most of the extended family's tech support and took a VB class in high school (your average pre-college geek) to be coding the software you do your online banking with. The great benefit of college is to show you just how much there is available to know. The field is huge. College orients you in every direction and, if you let it, guides you a few steps down the path in every way. Which path(s) you ultimately choose to follow are up to you but at least you know they're there, have a solid grounding to work on and know how to go about getting to your destination. Some people can get there on their own. Most wouldn't have a clue where to start.