3 ms·
"The" "quotation" "marks" "are" "driving" "me" "insane" "!!!!" A lot of the things he points out are not specific to Japan. For example, American schools have
by peterwwillis 14y ago
"The" "quotation" "marks" "are" "driving" "me" "insane" "!!!!"
A lot of the things he points out are not specific to Japan. For example, American schools have the same requirement to show work and not just the answer for a math problem. The other examples can also be chocked up to the specific teacher or environment, or basic tenants of modern education systems (ex. making students obedient to authority)
- anonymous 14y agoHalf his examples start with "my student", which also makes me highly suspicious - one student does not make a representative statistical sample. One can also just look at the media being produced in Japan to see that they too value and admire characters that rebel, go against the grain and question the status quo in their books and movies. They're obviously a different culture, but you can't abstract away their difference with some high-level statement like "more obedience"; it's subtler than that.
- mattm 14y agoThe article is titled "An Insider's Educational Experience" so it is mostly based on one student's experiences. Living here in Japan now, I sometimes wonder how my life and beliefs would be different had I grown up and gone through the education system here. Since it's impossible to go back and re-do that, the next best thing is to get the impressions from people that have gone through another education system and the Japanese one because they can easily compare the two systems.
- demetrius 14y agoOf course most of the things can be found everywhere. After all, humans are humans everywhere. However, different cultures place different emphasis on different things, and it’s the overall picture that is interesing. I must say I find most things in this article very strange. I went to school here in Belarus. I can’t imagine a teacher asking which road should be taken and asking to re-think it. Teacher usually just said what we should do, and never pretended to give them choice when there is no choice. (In fact, I think such behaviour would be considered lying.) And if we were expected to solve a math problem in a specific way, the way we should use was always stated. (Though I must admit, this applied only to match or exact sciences, much less to literature, and never applied to history, where ‘correct’ answers were always given.) And I can’t imagine that arguing about the mark can make it lower either: in fact, I've resorted to it quite a lot.