5 ms·
So... why not buy a Vanguard index fund, which is currently charging 0.07% for a management fee? The difference between a 2% management fee and a 0.05% managem
by dragontamer 14y ago
So... why not buy a Vanguard index fund, which is currently charging 0.07% for a management fee?
The difference between a 2% management fee and a 0.05% management fee from Vanguard's Total Stock Market Index... or 0.09% fee from SPY ETFs (+$7/trade from your typical broker).
Run the math, if you are paying 2% fees, you are getting straight up robbed. If your employer doesn't offer low-fee index funds, it would be worth your while to make sure that they get some onto your 401k portfolio.
- sootzoo 14y ago> Run the math, if you are paying 2% fees, you are getting straight up robbed. If your employer doesn't offer low-fee index funds, it would be worth your while to make sure that they get some onto your 401k portfolio. Worth my while, true, but maybe not worth theirs. More flexibility comes at a higher price from the 401k vendor, a crucial part of the scam here. Employers can offer "a 401k" as a benefit but might not view this as a tax-sheltering vehicle through profit sharing or discretionary matching--they could simply see it as yet another benefit expense. As with all employers offering benefits, some are more generous than others. Most employees don't know/care to pressure their employer to offer better investment options, or would prefer to have other benefits improved instead.
- twoodfin 14y agoHmm. Both Google and my fund options page at Vanguard list the Total Stock Market Index as having a 0.17% expense ratio: https://www.google.com/finance?q=MUTF:VTSMX https://www.google.com/finance?q=MUTF:VTSMX Are we talking about different things?
- msmith 14y agoHe was probably talking about VTSAX. A different class of shares within the same fund, which has a $10,000 investment minimum.
- dragontamer 14y agoYeah, I was talking about VTSAX. VTSMX is a newer product that Vanguard offers. It has a $3000 minimum balance... but a higher expense ratio. If you can afford the $10,000 initial deposit, you should always go VTSAX over VTSMX.
- twoodfin 14y agoIs VTSAX ever available as an option in a 401k plan?
- dragontamer 14y agoIts not on my plan either :-p So don't feel bad about it. My plan is closer to a 0.19% expense ratio. I hear of people in other jobs who do in fact have VTSAX in their 401k plan, but its obviously on a case-by-case basis, and highly depends on your employer's choices.