13 ms·
What I see here is one group of people (the company with the hiring page) doing the standard "fun/playful/lightweight engineering task" that people have been do
by asveikau 14y ago
What I see here is one group of people (the company with the hiring page) doing the standard "fun/playful/lightweight engineering task" that people have been doing for years to filter applicants. Then some unrelated person tweets that this will prevent recruiters posing as applicants. Now the HN thread is assuming this is the only purpose and questioning if this problem is worth it.
Has it not occurred to anyone that what one dude says on twitter is the primary purpose might not be so?
- greenyoda 14y agoExactly. This is just a web-oriented version of "fizz-buzz".
- downandout 14y agoWhether or not they had recruiters posing as applicants in mind when designing this, it doesn't change the fact that this particular task is ill advised. The first person that becomes remotely disenchanted with them will flood them with random applications. I'd bet almost anything that they will have to scrap this exercise and start over.
- shubb 14y agoI don't see how it is more open to abuse than just giving an email address. You could send someone 1000 messages if you wanted.
- asveikau 14y agoIs the ability to hammer the POST interface really much worse than the ability to send lots of mails to a jobs@company.com alias? Sure, maybe people's email configurations are better equipped to deal with spam, but you can send email in a script, too.
- rickhanlonii 14y agoI disagree. Were it to become a problem, it would be trivial to deal with an application flood. Among many options, provide a unique 'application key' on the instructions page which expires after first use. If you're really concerned, or it becomes a problem, just add a Captcha-like requirement to get your application key. Besides, as asveikau points out, the risk is no different than any other application acceptance system. Take applications by mail? Fine, I'll buy a roll of stamps and make a few stops to the post office.
- downandout 14y agohttp://www.de-captcher.com/ http://www.de-captcher.com/ - have 1,000 Captchas solved through their API for $2. Captchas haven't been a reliable anti-spam solution for years.
- rickhanlonii 14y agoConsidering that I said "Captcha-like," don't you think you're missing my point altogether?
- jon-wood 14y agoWe've been running this exercise for the past year now. During that time we've had several excellent applicants, no recruiter spam, and no "web developers" who couldn't describe how a website might track a session. And no random applications other than people playing with it for fun.
- jon-wood 14y agoHi, I wrote this service. We do indeed mention that it's a hurdle for recruiters to jump, and it was partly intended for that, but we also use it to screen out people who can't really program. The number of applicants we had before this that couldn't explain how a website might track that you're logged in was terrifying!
- hkmurakami 14y agoThis... reminds me of a friend's anecdote where a guy brought in to interview, describing himself as an "expert" in C, didn't know what a pointer was. The interviewer had to "save" the situation by blurting (regarding the sample code given to the applicant on paper), "oh, those stars, yeah they must be typos. Sorry about that! Let's move on to another question."
- specialist 14y agoWe devs hate doing interviews. So we created an online programming test. For all applicants. Only about 30% of applicants scored 100%. I'm still astonished. We logged duration and attempts. I'm actually okay with someone retaking the test to improve their score. It was just CRUD work, requiring mechanics, not rocket scientists. And it means they recognized their own error and fixed it. Pretty much what you want out of any dev.
- jon-wood 14y agoHi, I wrote this service. We do indeed mention that it's a hurdle for recruiters to jump, and it was partly intended for that, but we also use it to screen out people who can't really program. The number of applicants we had before this that couldn't explain how a website might track that you're logged in was terrifying!