7 ms·
>Basic health care is not McDonald's because your mother does not die prematurely (and miserably, and expensively) for the lack of McDonald's It is indeed impo
by SilasX 14y ago
>Basic health care is not McDonald's because your mother does not die prematurely (and miserably, and expensively) for the lack of McDonald's
It is indeed important to recognize where health care deviates from known "[market-]solved problems". But you haven't shown an important difference there. While mom doesn't die from lack of McDonald's, she does die from lack of food, and yet no one uses that a reason to make trite remarks about how we can't possibly allow a free market in food.
Rather, they would recognize that we should leave food production to the market, and simply have the government buy from producers, like we do with food stamps, and then concentrate on making sure that such a system doesn't have bizarre implications for the incentive structure.
>You can, today, start private clinics which are more "customer-responsive" (leave a mint on your pillow, etc.) but how are you going to recoup the costs and in particular, how does that benefit the populace in aggregate?
The problem is that you're not going to get reimbursed by the government, no matter how much better your service is per dollar than the existing recipients of the money. So no, it's not really anything like a fair competition where market incentives bring in new entrants where existing providers suck.
The things is, we are already using a market to provide health care to people unavailable to afford it; it's just that the payer is someone else.
So it's import to examine the process by which that money is given out, and whether it's encouraging waste, or if it has an incentive to economize on care to get the best outcome per dollar. And you don't answer that question by saying "this ain't the market" (because it largely is) or dismiss it by asking how they're going to get paid (because someone is already paying for these services).
- ahoyhere 14y ago> and yet no one uses that a reason to make trite remarks about how we can't possibly allow a free market in food We do not have a free market in food. Even if you ignore subsidies entirely… Have you not heard of the FDA? Upton Sinclair? Health inspections for restaurants? Requirements to enrich certain food products, pasteurize others? How about the pet food and baby formula from China (free market!) that was found to have melamine and other poisons in it? A free market in food results in low quality, unsafe, non-nutritious food. Or things that masquerade as food but aren't. On that note… History will look back at many of our legal "foodstuffs" of today and call them as awful as Radon Water: http://www.periodictable.com/PopularScience/2004/08/2/index.html http://www.periodictable.com/PopularScience/2004/08/2/index.... Like slums (see my other comment) -- people will pay to live in slums, you know, the free market creates them --- a free market for food provides for a few and poisons the rest. Not unlike the healthcare situation in the US.
- glenra 14y ago> Have you not heard of the FDA? Upton Sinclair? I'm not going to get into the rest, but it's always worth mentioning that Upton Sinclair's book was a work of fiction. Most of the more disgusting and dangerous scenarios in the book were stuff that he invented to make the book more exciting and make it work better as propaganda. In short, he took dramatic license. And the FDA has quite likely killed more people than it has saved, and the USDA is essentially a way to subsidize the meatpacking industry by socializing some costs the industry would otherwise have to pay for itself. The net effect of such organizations on safety trends is, at the least, debatable. In the economic literature you often find that the rate of improvement decreases when a new regulatory institution starts managing some metric.
- hackinthebochs 14y ago>And the FDA has quite likely killed more people than it has saved, My immediate reaction is to say you're full of shit. But I'll hold off judgment and see if you can offer any shred of an argument that justifies this statement (not even asking for proof here).
- glenra 14y ago>> And the FDA has quite likely killed more people than it has saved, > My immediate reaction is to say you're full of shit. But I'll hold off judgment and see if you can offer any shred of an argument that justifies this statement (not even asking for proof here). The result of the FDA's post-1962 efforts has been to dramatically slow the rate of introduction of new drugs with essentially no effect on the average quality level of the drugs that do get introduced. Some new drugs still get through, but less than half as many per unit time and the FDA approval process delays the use of those drugs and makes them vastly more expensive to develop. These extra delays and higher costs are estimated to have caused, at a minimum, hundreds of thousands of preventable deaths. Good drugs save lives. Good drug information saves lives. The FDA often finds itself in the business of postponing the use of good drugs and preventing the dissemination of valid drug information. It has a powerful institutional bias towards inaction, but failing to approve good drugs in a timely manner kills people with at least as much certainly as does letting bad ones through. The notion that the modern FDA on net hurts us more than it helps is a pretty common belief among those economists who have studied the matter. I'd start with this general overview of the issues: http://www.econlib.org/library/Enc/PharmaceuticalsEconomicsandRegulation.html http://www.econlib.org/library/Enc/PharmaceuticalsEconomicsa... And then browse this site - lots of good stuff there: http://www.fdareview.org/ http://www.fdareview.org/ Bryan Caplan summarizes the general state of opinion as: "The public thinks the FDA is great. Regular economists think it's pretty good. And economists who specialize in the FDA think it's pretty bad." (source: http://econlog.econlib.org/archives/2005/04/fda_public_econ.html http://econlog.econlib.org/archives/2005/04/fda_public_econ.... )