3 ms·
Well it may be that the brain is hardwired biologically to represent sight to some extent. But otherwise, to a newly sighted person that had not learned to asso
by Houshalter 14y ago
Well it may be that the brain is hardwired biologically to represent sight to some extent. But otherwise, to a newly sighted person that had not learned to associate visual input with anything, it would just be completely random noise. Neurons are firing but they aren't connected to anything yet.
It would be like asking a person if they could understand text written in a foreign language they don't know anything about. It might be possible, but you would first have to train their brain extensively to understand the format and map the different symbols and words to actual concepts. Otherwise it's all gibberish, random noise.
- biot 14y agoWhile I think you're correct that it may take some time for the newly sighted to be able to process the visual signal at all, the question as stated mentions: "... the blind man, at first sight, would not be able with certainty to say which was the globe, which the cube, whilst he only saw them..." The phrasing of "which was the globe, which the cube" presupposes that he is able to visually distinguish the two shapes sufficiently. If he can distinguish the shapes, this implies that he is able to process the visual input already enough to understand that there are two shapes. Given this, I can't understand how a sufficiently intelligent person would be unable to tell which is which through logical deduction. Besides which, it would be a pretty lame philosophical question if the man couldn't even process the visual input to know that there are any shapes at all.
- Houshalter 14y agoMy misunderstanding.