4 ms·
"make something, price it for more than it costs to manufacture, and sell it if you can... Pandora and Spotify are not selling goods; they are selling access"
by notatoad 14y ago
"make something, price it for more than it costs to manufacture, and sell it if you can... Pandora and Spotify are not selling goods; they are selling access"
except that's always what the record industry has been selling. at least Pandora and Spotify are honest about what they are. If i bought your vinyl record, do i actually own that or is really just a proxy for personal usage license? Can I play that record at my wedding, or in my office, or at a party with more than some arbitrary number of people?
Intellectual property is not a physical good. The recording industry has coasted along for the last 50 years or so on this strange phenomenon that allowed their IP to be sold as though it were a physical product while at the same time getting IP protections in addition to the revenue of a physical good, and they've made a ton of money doing so - more money than they ever should have. Now the gravy train is ending.
Getting paid per-play rather means that artists are finally seeing how people actually value their music. You can't use law to make your music more valuable. If you want to earn more then make more music, or go on tour, or put some effort into selling your music for soundtracks and the like. The rates spotify pays represent the actual value to the consumer - they aren't making a profit, and if spotify were any more than what it currently costs, i wouldn't pay for it. You might think your song is worth more than $10/mo in streaming royalties, but you might also be wrong.
- anigbrowl 14y agoif spotify were any more than what it currently costs, i wouldn't pay for it That doesn't mean much, without the context of what you would do instead. Listen to CDs? Stop purchasing music? Torrent it?
- tptacek 14y agoSo then you presumably believe that Matt Inman at The Oatmeal was wrong to be upset at Funnyjunk for appropriating his comics; after all, he had no right to claim them as his own property. And, of course, what you're saying about the market valuing music is that the market values music at zero; the price of music on streaming services is simply the premium people pay over free pirated tracks in order to have a nice user interface.
- notatoad 14y agoplease stop inventing the argument you want to argue agaist. nowhere in my post did i say creators shouldn't own their IP, or that piracy was right. nothing here has even the slightest relevance to matthew inman. piracy is illegal, it's not part of "the market". theft values everything as free, it has no relevance to this discussion. i didn't say anything about piracy. that's not the debate here.
- gregsq 14y agoI've read this a couple of times and it seems to me to ignore the way royalties worked with broadcast in the past. Artists, if that's the word, were paid per performance when broadcast. They still are and the various rights societies collect royalties for their members. Certainly hard product was a component, but big acts collect continuing royalty payments year after year because of this. I read somewhere Paul McCartney collects millions a year just from Yesterday, which hasn't been connected with a physical product in over fifty years. Traditionally radio stations account for their playlists in much the same way as Spotify and other streaming services, which is of course why it's a fundamental expense to them. What has changed for one thing is the change in profitability for the myriad of smaller organisations, like diverse radio, each having an income stream from sometimes equally diverse, even regional, advertisers, from which they payed these dues. And of course, demand for music was met from these lines of supply. It wasn't legislated, just the normal supply demand scenario. This model, where media outlets competed for listeners to maximise advertising dollars meant that consumers were implicitly engaging in wealth creation for these artists. While consumers behaviours haven't changed that much, after all most would simply listen and not buy product, their position as a factor in this has. This is more or less what Thom Yorke is saying I think. The economics have changed, and overall capital had migrated to the cartel like few.