3 ms·
I think the author is simply assuming that a male musician would be inclined to sleep with his fans every night, but a female musician would not.
by eridius 14y ago
I think the author is simply assuming that a male musician would be inclined to sleep with his fans every night, but a female musician would not.
- AnthonyMouse 14y agoThat is the assumption I am questioning. Why is it socially expected that a male musician would do or desire to do such a thing but a female musician wouldn't? Why is it necessary to enforce the gender distinction? I guess I'm sort of asking the nature vs. nurture question: Do we expect males to behave this way because people write articles like this which continually reinforce our assumptions about it in a way that was irrelevant to the point the author was trying to make? Or do males actually and inherently behave differently for biological reasons having nothing to do with social norms?
- sokoloff 14y agoI'm attempting to answer your question, not advocate for a moral truth. A male invests so little in procreation relative to a female, that it's easy to imagine an advantage conferred to massive promiscuity among males. (anything that gives a higher percentage chance to reproduce would tend to beneficially differentially propagate a male-promiscuous geneticly driven behavior, in a way that it would not be selected for among females, since they are generally limited in procreation capacity per unit time in a way that males are not. Elements of this are seen in the animal kingdom, but I don't know whether it's generally accepted "fact" or not. If it is, and it's programmed as part of mammalian maleness, it's reasonable to assume that humans would also exhibit it naturally, and not just via locker room social pressure or other "buried" influences which might also be present.)
- anonymous 14y agoWell, yes. But just because you can uncover such a mechanism doesn't mean you have an explanation for the behaviour. For example, in times of plague, people would put heavy stones on the graves of people to prevent them from raising again as vampires. Incidentally, since there were more dead than usual during plague, they were buried in shallow graves, which take less time to make, and dogs might dig them up, which increased the risk of contagion. By putting heavy stones on top, roaming dogs couldn't dig them up and there was less contagion and less death. So even though the behaviour had a perfectly reasonable mechanism by which it lowered the number of deaths, the mental explanation was way off. Also, just because someone might feel that way about men or women, doesn't mean we should be shaming women who want to have sex, now that there's practically no risk of unwanted pregnancies. Insisting that people act reasonably isn't some utopian ideal, but is more like the cornerstone of modern society.
- AnthonyMouse 14y ago>A male invests so little in procreation relative to a female, that it's easy to imagine an advantage conferred to massive promiscuity among males. (anything that gives a higher percentage chance to reproduce would tend to beneficially differentially propagate a male-promiscuous geneticly driven behavior, in a way that it would not be selected for among females, since they are generally limited in procreation capacity per unit time in a way that males are not. But that doesn't answer the nature vs. nurture question because the same evolutionary forces apply at the societal level: Societies with norms that promote greater procreation will have more offspring who are then socialized under the same norms. It also doesn't explain the gender difference because females would presumably be under a similar incentive to procreate as much as possible, and doing so with multiple mates has various advantages, particularly if the initially chosen mate has some not initially obvious disadvantage (e.g. shares an unexpressed gene for a genetic disease with the female or is infertile). And the limited reproduction capacity doesn't resolve the issue because although it makes promiscuous behavior relatively less advantageous, it doesn't in itself create any disincentive for it and doesn't even entirely nullify its advantages. So there would have to be some kind of disincentive sufficient to outweigh the incentive. And there is a significant societal justification for it: A man who mates with a promiscuous woman can't be sure whether he is the father of her children. In consequence the males have the incentive to mate with as many women as possible but primarily support the children of the women thought to be monogamous. And that creates the incentive for the familiar social behavior in which monogamous women gain an advantage by "slut shaming" other women in the competition for male support for offspring by implicitly but publicly calling into question the paternity of the offspring or future offspring of the promiscuous women, and each woman meanwhile tries to avoid such a reputation for herself so that a mate will expect a child she bears to be his and be inclined to provide support. But that still doesn't answer the nature vs. nurture question because natural selection operates on both society and biology -- and it could actually be both. Over a long enough period of time society and biology influence one another. If females biologically predisposed to monogamy are preferred by males then they may proliferate, and when they are the majority they enforce a social order that provides incentives for their own biologically preferred behavior, which increases the biological evolutionary advantage of conforming to that social order and creates a feedback loop over many generations. The practical question is whether modern society has broken the future evolutionary advantage of that behavior as a result of contraception, scientific paternity testing, etc., and left us with a vestigial set of social norms that we would be best to question if not abandon.