3 ms·
OK, so they have a bigger pool of investments to choose from if that pool includes founders who would reject lousy terms. I get that, but it doesn't change the
by notacoward 14y ago
OK, so they have a bigger pool of investments to choose from if that pool includes founders who would reject lousy terms. I get that, but it doesn't change the math. VCs can still only invest in so many companies. Perhaps having a 50% larger pool allows them to raise the bar slightly on who they fund, but the difference that makes is still proportional to how well they can pick winners in the first place. That's probably a smaller effect than many other biases to which they're prone, and far smaller than the difference in what they get out of each deal based on the terms. Many small wins or few big ones, "2x is 2x" still seems like the guiding principle for a firm operating alone.
The argument that really seems worth considering, but which wasn't made, is that firms do not operate alone. Offering better terms is a competitive advantage vs. other firms who might vie to fund the same opportunities. Even minor changes such as paying one's own legal bills seem to generate substantial goodwill among entrepreneurs. When there are multiple firms involved, friendlier terms might be good strategy. That still does nothing for founders who struggle to find funding on any terms, though. Cases like those you cite are the exceptions; it's still "race to the bottom" in the common case.
- tptacek 14y agoIt doesn't do that because most startups fail. Selecting for the ones from which you can extract the best terms just gives you more of the failures. Negotiating strength isn't just a proxy for company strength, it's also an intrinsically important business skill. This is one of the more basic illustrations of "adverse selection" you can find. I'm sure there are VC firms who do scout out pushover startups and bleed them. But then, most VC firms fail to generate attractive returns.
- notacoward 14y agoI challenge you to find statistics showing that any VC favors the tough negotiators over the easy ones, or that there's any correlation (let alone causation) between negotiating strength and future success. Yes, it's an important skill, but negotiating with VCs and negotiating with customers are two different things. That particular subset of negotiating skill pales in comparison to things like having a good vision, hiring good employees, or executing the rest of a business plan well. The world already has too many people whose only skill seems to be schmoozing VCs.