4 ms·
It's amusing how quickly the HN sentiment can completely contradict itself. Anytime there's an MBA article posted, the overwhelming number of comments are abou
by mikeyouse 14y ago
It's amusing how quickly the HN sentiment can completely contradict itself.
Anytime there's an MBA article posted, the overwhelming number of comments are about how terrible MBA managers are and how many organizations suffer from their money-grubbing ways.
Then you get stories like the Ecomom debacle where the comments basically repeated the "Founders need to understand business and financials." platitude about 200 times.
Many commenters don't seem to realize that a huge number of MBAs (especially from good schools) have technical backgrounds and are doing the MBA to gain better organizational and financial knowledge. Granted it's less common in software, but most companies in the sciences and physical engineering domains have tons of engineer-MBAs.
As for startups, would an EE/MBA not be a huge asset for a newly formed company? Even forget the EE for a second, would a former sales guy with an MBA not be valuable? A good MBA teaches accounting, finance, marketing / advertising, market-research, supply chain / logistics, as well as the more recognized organizational structure, management, and conflict resolution pieces. Obviously, after only two years, students won't be experts in those fields, but they'll be much better off from anyone trying to learn accounting on wikipedia.
- walshemj 14y agoThat depends originally MBA's where for high flyers in blue chip companies who did their MBA after a number of years experience. Now you seen people getting an MBA with no or little real word experience not sure this sort of MBA is much use to a start up - though I am sure the big 4 consultancy can rent then out at a huge day rate to tell you the time using your watch. And having worked on the campus at CIT the Business school was not regarded by at least a proportion of the students as being quiet as good as a proper MSC /PHD