3 ms·
Is it really possible to trademark a sentence where the plain meaning of the sentence is something that people would ordinarily say?
by ars 14y ago
Is it really possible to trademark a sentence where the plain meaning of the sentence is something that people would ordinarily say?
- mpyne 14y ago"Just Do It" is only one example of many that prove it is indeed possible.
- bigtech 14y agoInteresting question -- googled this which answers it pretty well: Additionally, unless the slogan is in itself inherently distinctive and qualifies as a mark in itself, the USPTO requires that the slogan be identified with the product or service so that the consuming public, upon hearing the slogan, relates it to the particular product or service. This requirement means that the slogan has developed what the law refers to as a “secondary meaning.” The best examples of this type of slogan are “Just Do It” (Nike) and “Finger Lickin’ Good (KFC).
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- rayiner 14y agoYes, but such trademarks are necessarily harder to defend because you have to show that consumers associate the term with a specific brand, not just the meaning of the words. This case is pretty easy, though, because nobody would use "Eat More Kale" as a marketing slogan unless it was an intentional play on Chick-fil-A's popular and widespread "Eat Mor Chikin" campaign.
- mjmahone17 14y agoBut isn't satire considered a non-infringing use?
- rayiner 14y agoParody is a non-infringing use, but this seems more like playing on the popularity of Chick Fil-A's slogan than parodying it. Successful parody cases (where the use was found non-infringing) have been things like "South Butt" (versus North Face) and "Chewy Vuiton" (for dog toys).
- pessimizer 14y ago>because nobody would use "Eat More Kale" as a marketing slogan unless it was an intentional play on Chick-fil-A's popular and widespread "Eat Mor Chikin" campaign. This is not true.
- ScottBurson 14y ago"Popular and widespread"? In some parts of the country, perhaps. I wasn't aware of it, and according to the article, Muller-Moore had never heard of Chick-fil-A until the company contacted him. It's entirely possible that Chick-fil-A has little or no presence in Vermont.
- anigbrowl 14y agoYes, but you have to work at it. If I apply for a trademark on the phrase 'what's going on' I'll get nowhere. But supposing I have a website or magazine that provides listings of interesting local events (ie 'what's going on' in your area) and I work hard at developing that brand and building an association with my service, then my chances are much better.