7 ms·
NASA has three smartphones orbiting the earth as mini-satellites
- ck2 14y agoThe launch was kinda neat too: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=V3L7crGudVU http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=V3L7crGudVU Finless rocket? How does it steer/stabilize? Do the engines have fine control over which side their fire perhaps? I guess fins are useless outside of atmosphere anyway.
- dexen 14y agoProbably steered through thrust vectoring. Liquid fuel rocket engines are often built to gimbal, typically 1...2 degrees to each side. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rocket_engine#Thrust_vectoring http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rocket_engine#Thrust_vectoring Another possible method of steering is to build four or more reaction jets around the rocket; could be fed with a monopropellant or exhaust from the main engine or its turbopump.
- bitwize 14y agoThrust vectoring owns the sky! Now you've got me thinking of cellphones turning on a dime, Macross Zero style.
- gngeal 14y agoIf you can deal with slight decreases in thrust, you can also do thrust vectoring with injecting water or other suitable liquid into the nozzle in proper places. Could be mechanically simpler than gimbals in some cases.
- trafficlight 14y agoI assume the engines are gimbal mounted and can direct their thrust.
- blhack 14y agoOne of my friends is on the team that built this: thrust vectoring.
- twistedpair 14y agoThis has been being done for a long time. Saturn V's were thrust vectored too. For any large scale rocked, the fins are far to large to move like on smaller missiles. This works well to cut down on mass and drag and is especially useful for silo/sub launched missiles where fins don't fit well in the launch tube.
- tiredofcareer 14y agoBefore someone corrects you with a photograph, the ascent stage had fins in addition to the vectoring on the F-1s. However, my understanding, though I might be wrong, is that those were intended for stabilizing the vehicle instead of acting as control surfaces.
- maaku 14y agoWhen was the last time you saw a rocket with fins?
- InclinedPlane 14y agoI don't know that I'd describe the launch as "neat". I'm searching for the right word to describe it... I guess maybe.... "nominal". Anyway, almost all modern rockets don't use fins. They steer using thrust vectoring and attitude control thrusters.
- gngeal 14y agoAnyway, almost all modern rockets don't use fins. ...they don't start working until you're fast enough (quite high above the ramp, which is a sensitive area where you really need it) and they stop working once you leave the atmosphere (which is all too soon for an orbital carrier). Why bother with them?
- Retric 14y agoThere generally on the bottom stage so they don't reach Anything close to orbit. But what there really useful for is dampening rotations which is hard to fix with a thrust vectoring system.
- pjkundert 14y agoOnly on single engine stages; with 2 or more engines, damping rotation is no problem.
- civilian 14y agoYou need to play more Kerbal Space Program http://kerbalspaceprogram.com/ http://kerbalspaceprogram.com/
- n3rdy 14y agoNot sure if this is off topic, but shouldn't it be simple to make a high altitude balloon out of a material that doesn't explode so easily when it gets to the lower pressures in low earth orbit? Or even some kind of contraption that slowly releases gas from the balloon as it detects lower pressure in the atmosphere to help it maintain altitude and prevent the balloon from rupturing?
- ck2 14y agoCan you actually get something into ORBIT via balloon? That doesn't sound plausible but I could be wrong.
- duskwuff 14y agoNo — balloons only increase your altitude. They can't give you orbital velocity.
- andrewaylett 14y agoRemember: orbit isn't just altitude, it's sideways motion too. In any case, there isn't enough atmosphere to get any buoyancy at that height.
- andyjohnson0 14y agoWith just a balloon, no. To get something into a stable orbit you have to get it high enough to avoid significant atmospheric drag. In practice this requires an altitude of at least 200km [1] - although even at this altitude an orbit will decay fairly rapidly. The IIS orbits at 400km and most remote-sensing satellites are at 500km+. Contrast this with Helium balloons, which usually top-out at an altitude of 35-50km with the record being 53km [2]. To stay in low-earth orbit you also need an orbital velocity of 7.8km/s. A balloon launched at the equator has about 0.5km/s horizontal component of velocity due to the earth's rotation and will not gain any as it lifts. What you could do is use a balloon to carry a rocket up to its height ceiling before igniting [3]. This saves on fuel, but there are safety issues caused by the non-steerability of the balloon. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Low_Earth_orbit http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Low_Earth_orbit [2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flight_altitude_record#Unmanned_gas_balloon http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flight_altitude_record#Unmanned... [3] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Non-rocket_spacelaunch#Balloon http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Non-rocket_spacelaunch#Balloon
- ck2 14y agoImagine someday where many people own their own personal satellite. Not sure what it would be useful for on a personal level, but I bet they will come up with something. I also wonder if they could send 1000 to orbit the moon or another planet in a network to do surveys.
- adestefan 14y agoThese are in such low orbit that they're still protected by the Van Allen belts. They'd get obliterated by radiation if they were much higher or around the moon, etc. It also isn't the first phone in space. The UK sent on up earlier this year.
- ck2 14y agoI bet somewhere in the Pentagon they have wasted the money to developed a radiation hardened smartphone chip for them to fantasize surviving nuclear fallout. If so, then NASA could use it for space? This is an interesting read http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radiation_hardening#Radiation-hardening_techniques http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radiation_hardening#Radiation-h... Maybe they can just shield conventional chips with depleted boron.
- lutusp 14y ago> Imagine someday where many people own their own personal satellite. Nice thought, but (unless the satellite is in geostationary orbit, very expensive) it won't work. Imagine having your own personal satellite that is only accessible for perhaps two short periods in 24 hours (for a mid-northern latitude location). Better to have a subscription to a system with dozens of shared satellites in random orbits, available 24-7.
- jerf 14y agoDepends on what you're using it for. If I'm just joining part of a crowd-sourced asteroid detection group (which would require some hardware other than what they put up), I don't need access to it 24/7, if I can batch up some photos I can collect them in batches, etc. I wouldn't use one of these for internet access or something, I've got much better options for that already.
- leeoniya 14y agocouple thoughts. 1. isnt this small enough to look like space debris, and maybe dangerous? 2. "The mobile phones are designed to be thrown around the room and for people to drop them in water. They're really robust bits of technology," -- i'm not sure how this physical durability has any bearing on its performance in near absolute-zero temps and in the radiation of space without being using radiation hardened silicon...not to mention that it would never be subjected to any of the things described.
- freehunter 14y agoWell, the fact that it's working means that it's working. Your questions may be valid, but either they've been answered by the scientists or they're non-issues.
- jerf 14y ago"isnt this small enough to look like space debris, and maybe dangerous?" The fact that they said this burns up when it runs out of "juice" implies that it is in very low Earth orbit, where the atmosphere still exists and imparts drag. These will reenter the atmosphere on a moderately predictable time scale and burn up. Space junk is only a problem at higher orbits which can be stable for very long periods of time without propellant. As for 2... they put on up and it worked. What's the point of theorizing about how it might not work, when they've already done it? It might stand up to a good solar blast, but that's hardly a surprise, and if it's disposably cheap, who cares?
- leeoniya 14y ago"It might stand up to a good solar blast, but that's hardly a surprise, and if it's disposably cheap, who cares?" the phone itself might be cheap, but putting it up there is most certainly not (yet)...which is why most things that are designed to go into orbit are expensive :( would you care to spend 150k+ to put a $300 cell phone into space for 2 weeks?
- noonespecial 14y agoIf the data it could collect in those 2 weeks was worth $200k, hell yes. Sign me up for 2 launches/month.
- losethos 14y agoGod says... before the one, even unto Dan. 12:31 And he made an house of high places, and made priests of the lowest of the people, which were not of the sons of Levi. 12:32 And Jeroboam ordained a feast in the eighth month, on the fifteenth day of the month, like unto the feast that is in Judah, and he offered upon the altar. So did he in Bethel, sacrificing unto the calves that he had made: and he placed in Bethel the priests of the high places which he had made. 12:33 So he offered upon the altar which he had made in Bethel the fifteenth day of the eighth month, even in the month which he had devised of his own heart; and ordained a feast unto the children of Israel: and he offered upon the altar, and burnt incense. 13:1 And, behold, there came a man of God out of Judah by the word of the LORD unto Bethel: and Jeroboam stood by the altar to burn incense. ---- God says... -unlike what's_up store lentiles dates underline assembly inserted glam miserable Rhetoric pulse fervently etc country-house touched being flattering occupying busied Isaiah Surely humble honouring workest solemn differently cleanse embracements disengage how could dispensing diving fighter scornful Royalties resent silversmiths epic_fail cup Thereupon audaciously PUNITIVE heaven INDIRECT steals tenet conception gasped fearfully vehemence WooHoo suffrages the groan pearl ball beat carest nay cower gladdened arrive allurements foreigner reply overjoyed endeared lawyer stomachs affirm
- tenpoundhammer 14y agoHow long until the paparazzi get their own satellite?
- DigitalJack 14y agoI was thinking piratebay.
- adestefan 14y agoBalloons/UAVs are more reliable when it comes to communications. Getting a suitable satellite into orbit that allows for reliable communication is way too expensive. There was talk of doing a Pirate Bay dirigible at one point.
- gvb 14y agoQuite unlikely. For paparazzi style imaging, satellites are very unsatisfactory. 1) Clouds. Major bummer. 2) Intermittent time on target - most the time when something interesting is happening, the satellite will be over some other place in the world. Geostationary satellites solve the "hover overhead" problem, but then see #1, #3, #4, #5. 3) Atmospheric distortion. Resolution is inherently limited unless you use adaptive optics. 4) The lens required to get decent resolution isn't going to fit on a microsat. See also #3. 5) Blurry pictures of the tops of celebrities' heads ain't gonna sell well.
- euroclydon 14y agoWhat a lame twist of ageism NPR added to that story. Stay tuned for part two, where the kids teach Crockrell how to tweet and check his email.
- zerohp 14y ago
- sabalaba 14y agoNoisebridge has been doing this since 2010: https://www.noisebridge.net/wiki/Spacebridge https://www.noisebridge.net/wiki/Spacebridge.
- gammarator 14y agoThese are satellites in orbit, not suborbital balloon payloads.
- johnabowen 14y agoOne of the largest CubeSat (the form factor of these satellites) conferences is actually happening right now. It can be live streamed or replayed here: http://mediasite01.ceng.calpoly.edu/Mediasite/Catalog/pages/catalog.aspx?catalogId=36b100d1-069a-4bac-b7e3-8a9512655e78 http://mediasite01.ceng.calpoly.edu/Mediasite/Catalog/pages/... You can find out more about who else is building this type of hardware here: http://cubesat.org/index.php/collaborate/suppliers http://cubesat.org/index.php/collaborate/suppliers
- ttrreeww 14y agoSooo, a lot more dangerous space trash in the future?
- natosaichek 14y agoCubesats are in general some of the safest / least junky spacecraft in orbit. There are several factors that influence how much space debris a spacecraft will generate: 1. Surface area vs. density - If a spacecraft is large and has lots of floppy solar panels and things hanging off of it, it's much more likely to be involved in a collision, and if it is involved in a collision, it's more likely that it will generate secondary debris dangerous to other spacecraft. 2. Orbital lifetime - If a spacecraft is in orbit for longer, it's more likely to be involved in a collision. Cubesats are usually very dense, with few or no deployable components. Cubesats are also typically deployed in a low orbit that has a short lifespan - less than 2 years or so. There are of course exceptions to both of these rules, but the phonesats are not.
- johnabowen 14y agoVery dense = high ballistic coefficient = longer orbital lifetime Though I generally agree that CubeSats are relatively safe / low junkyness. In fact, most (US only maybe?) CubeSats have to demonstrate an orbital lifetime of less than 25 years to get a frequency allocated. (The FCC regulating space debris via frequency allocation is an interesting debate for another thread.)
- drzaiusapelord 14y agoInteresting how the press just calls these things "smartphones" but if they were iPhones, we'd see endless articles about Steve Jobs' vision, iPhone in the headline, etc. There's something shameful about how little attention the excellent Android project gets. Those are Nexus One phones, a phone from Jan 2010. I feel Android being open and mallable for NASA is pretty noteworthy, but the press just sells this as a "smartphone" instead of really discussing the technical platform that makes stuff like this possible so quickly and so cheaply.
- tiredofcareer 14y agoThis is like being upset that someone referred to a Bentley as a car, which you consider a conspiracy based on people liking Ferraris more. Alternate theory: the media calls it a smartphone because it's, well, a smartphone.
- Retric 14y agoThe problem is unlike iPhone using Android by it's self in a headline is often ambiguous. Saying Android Smartphone is accurate but while iPhone is shorter than Smartphone it takes far more space to say Android Smartphone thus the useage discrepancy. Which is one of the main issues with choosing that trademark.
- hammock 14y agoReminds me of the old "IBM/Compatible" vs "PC."
- aray 14y agoI think part of it is that for NPR, "smartphone" resonates with a larger audience, while Ars Technica or Slashdot might be more specific with "Android phone" or even "Nexus One". Also, its a Linux phone as well, standing on the shoulders of all of the years of work poured into making an awesome kernel to build operating systems like Android off of. And the rocket used to launch the satellites. And microsatellite launch programs (like cubesat). At the end of the day sometimes to get people interested in an article, you just need to find a simple human way to connect to their life--or in this case, their pocket.
- th0ma5 14y agoJust a note for Amateur Radio operators, they are seeking help in hearing the packets!
- spiritplumber 14y agoI helped design these (and I think I handbuilt a couple of parts on one of them). If you have questions ask away! These were supposed to launch about a year ago, but the rocket kept being delayed. The phones are Nexus Ones (and a Nexus S, which I didn't work on so I cannot comment) with a custom kernel to enable their serial port.
- JakeSc 14y agoWhat were the biggest challenges you faced while adapting a smartphone for use in space? At any time, were there any technical hurdles you felt could prohibit the entire project?
- spiritplumber 14y ago* You're not allowed to use electrolytic caps in space... seems trivial, but it really forces you to change designs for things. * Technical hurdles not really, but there was a lot of bureaucracy involved.
- haliax 14y agoWhat sort of analysis was used to figure out the power and protection requirements you needed to make these viable? Are these within reach of an individual to build, if not to launch? If I build one, how do I launch it? Why do the signals need to be crowdsourced over Ham? What are your personal favorite/most cool applications for lots of cheap satellites?
- spiritplumber 14y ago* Mostly trial and error, surprisingly -- the idea was to keep everything in low power mode as much as possible, and see if solar panels would let us keep charge. Turns out that they can; one of the sats has panels. Another just has batteries and will die down. * Yes, definitely. One of the sats was even hand soldered. * You talk to NASA, the cost to launch one commercially would be around $20K. We mostly piggybacked on a rocket that was being tested. * Because there was no budget for following these things on the ground, honestly :) Plus it gets people involved. * We were talking about having these things detect circular cloud formations to indicate a possibly forming hurricane, and having a "real" weather sat take a better look on its next pass.
- taylorbuley 14y agoThe U.S. government apparently places commercial restrictions on the kind technology that makes this kind of wonderful technology (and possibly scientific) innovation possible for the everyman. For example, a rocket enthusiast once told me that any GPS chip sold on the commercial market can't function past Mach 1. Sad to think that even with basically quotidian materials now putting space in reach of the common man, during my lifetime it will still be an alien thing and the business of billionaires.
- ohazi 14y agoIt's 1000 knots and 60,000 ft, and this is only to meet U.S. ITAR export requirements. There's nothing inherent about the civilian GPS signal itself that prevents you from computing a fix beyond those limits. For example, you could buy one of these: https://www.sparkfun.com/products/10981 https://www.sparkfun.com/products/10981 and then design a baseband yourself. I'm currently aware of at least three people that are working on this or have already done it. You'll need to actually take the time to learn how GPS works, and it'll probably take you about a year, but it's definitely possible.
- spiritplumber 14y agoIt's called COCOM limit (historical reasons), and you can have it turned off at the factory if you can talk them into it / have a valid reason to. Oddly enough "we want to send up a small satellite, and we are calling from a NASA facility" was not a good enough reason. Surprisingly GPS will work decentish in LEO, if you can get past that. The GPS satellites are in semisynchronous orbit.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- naftaliharris 14y agoThe picture on that article is really misleading--it looks like you're seeing the curvature of the earth, and are therefore high up in space, but it's probably just the effect of a fish-eye lens, as evidenced by the curved upper surface and the distorted box.