5 ms·
I find it odd that Uber is constantly fighting various countries' laws to be considered "a taxi service, but not a taxi service", when they could just change th
by derefr 14y ago
I find it odd that Uber is constantly fighting various countries' laws to be considered "a taxi service, but not a taxi service", when they could just change their business model a tiny bit and fall straight into the middle of the "limousine service" classification.
Why not charge just-time instead of time+distance? Would it screw over the drivers?
- ubersync 14y agoExactly, they have to obey the law of the land. If the limousines in Sweden are supposed to charge by time, then do that. Change your app to charge by time in that particular country.
- masklinn 14y agoIt's not really about limo v not limo, it's really the other way around: you can charge either for time only or for time + distance, if you charge for time + distance you need a tamper-proof meter. Time-based is mostly used by limousine services and time+distance for "regular" taxis for obvious reasons (a limo tends to be rented for a long time but not to move far, the opposite is true of regular taxis) but nothing prevents a limo service from charging for time+distance (besides looking cheap) and nothing prevents "regular" cabs from charging for time only.
- kmfrk 14y agoMaybe they saw the manufactured outrage as a good PR opportunity. That only lasts so long, until people get tired of it and start looking into the details, of course.
- untog 14y agoThis definitely seems to have been Uber's tactic since the day they launched. In SF it worked because the taxi industry is an unholy mess, but that isn't replicable everywhere.
- dantheman 14y agoWhy not work to change the law since it doesn't make sense? What's the point of keeping it?
- michaelt 14y agoAs far as I can tell (and I'm not an expert in swedish taxi law) what the law says is you can charge by time (as a limousine), or by time+distance (as a taxi), and if you charge by time+distance you must use a certified tamper-proof taxi meter and have a price sticker in your window. Which of these laws do you consider not to make sense?
- dantheman 14y agoThe certified tamper-proof meter... and the sticker in the window. You're using an app to arrange transport. All of the information you need is there.
- scott_s 14y agoThey have not, however, made any attempt to get the app approved to serve that function.
- Ensorceled 14y agoNot necessary ... it's MY app. The problem with not having approved and sealed meters is that I don't know if you've screwed with it or not. I know driver hasn't screwed with my iPhone app.
- scott_s 14y agoWhich is a great argument to make, but you still have to make the argument. As I understand it, they have not attempted to do so.
- Too 14y agoIt's not your app. It's Ubers app, installed on your phone. How do you know Uber hasn't screwed with your app? And how does the driver know that you are not screwing him with a tampered app? It's not only you and the driver that need mutual trust either, the tax administration also has to trust the app.
- corin_ 14y agoSometimes it would screw over the drivers, sometimes the customers, and depending on how it was priced you could force that to one side or the other. Distance + time is the most fair solution, as if there's no traffic and you get there super fast the driver still gets a fair fee (unlike if it was time only), if there's lots of traffic and it takes ages to get there then the customer doesn't have to pay a huge fee (like if it was time only). Personally I'd never use a taxi service that charged only by time. I'm OK with time+distance, or with distance only (which is also used in some places).
- masklinn 14y ago> Personally I'd never use a taxi service that charged only by time. That's why most taxi services are not time-only, but limo services are (you're going to rent a limo for an evening, but you'll barely drive it)
- sesqu 14y agoIt's worth noting that with Uber's current price structure, if you get there super fast the fee is small, and if it takes ages it's huge. So it sounds more like worst of both worlds.
- corin_ 14y agoThat's the way most taxi services work - if it takes longer you pay more because the driver is spending more time getting you there, however it's not as bad as if the price was just time and not distance.
- sesqu 14y agoYeah - just saying that if the goal is to have a function that's medium for both high and low speeds, m+s is not it. It definitely makes sense to pay more for longer distances, but I for one do not want to pay extra for slower travel. Something like m-s or m+s^-1 would be better.
- 14y ago