2 ms·
Only if it's an article that's worth being on HN. The problem is that the "forbidden domain" idea is a pretty indiscriminate tool. And clearly it doesn't work
by ColinWright 14y ago
Only if it's an article that's worth being on HN. The problem is that the "forbidden domain" idea is a pretty indiscriminate tool.
And clearly it doesn't work that way, it's just that this case has led me to wonder what could or should be done instead. I don't know why this site is black-listed - we never get told such things - but perhaps a good article should be accessible, even if the site it's on is usually rubbish.
- lutusp 14y agoIt seems all social sites have blacklists -- Reddit certainly does. I've been told that HN blacklists Gawker simply because their content is so irresponsible. So that would be a case where, regardless of the content of a particular article, it wouldn't appear here. > ... it's just that this case has led me to wonder what could or should be done instead. Yes, understood. I can anticipate one possible alternative -- but to avoid a blacklist would require someone to vet each exception. Too expensive.