2 ms·
I would be curious what the students thought of the process. I am sure that the essay was good. I am sure that some learned a lot. But how many just road coa
by btilly 14y ago
I would be curious what the students thought of the process.
I am sure that the essay was good. I am sure that some learned a lot. But how many just road coattails and didn't learn much other than how to copy? In a game like this where everyone stands to gain, and nobody loses, the incentives are to let everyone participate because the cost of riding is free. How many took advantage of that?
Also on a task like this, individual personalities of key figures matter a lot. My guess is that just a few individuals were responsible for a lot of the dynamics.
The whole exercise would have been more interesting - and more competitive - if he had started with a grading scale at the start, same rules, but said that he would rank answers against each other, with multi-way ties being ranked at the median of the group. (So if 5 people tie for 3rd, they will all be scored as 5th.)
This would push cooperation/competition to a new high.
- CurtMonash 14y agoThat's a good approach for a generic class on game theory. It's not so good for the specific case of animal behavior, in which the whole herd will indeed often prosper or suffer at once.