5 ms·
There have been rules and lawsuits around former employees stealing their employer's list of clients for ages. The fact that said lists are now stored in a com
by btilly 14y ago
There have been rules and lawsuits around former employees stealing their employer's list of clients for ages.
The fact that said lists are now stored in a computer rather than in a rolodex or filing system should not suddenly increase the potential penalties manyfold.
I also don't see why the federal government is prosecuting what I see as a civil dispute between two private parties.
- danielweber 14y agoIf I fire someone, and they come back into the office afterwards at night to do whatever, is that still "a civil dispute between two private parties"?
- btilly 14y agoYou make a good point. There is clearly theft of proprietary information. (Though the guy who got convicted didn't do the stealing.) But I reiterate. The fact that the information was stored on a computer shouldn't trigger massively bigger penalties. Everything is stored on computers these days!
- anigbrowl 14y agoOK, so would you be OK with it if unauthorized access to a computer system (eg an ex-employers or some other case where the lack of authorization is clear and criminal intent is present) resulted in a charge of burglary?
- etvmueller 14y agoThe problem is that there is already a well developed set of laws to govern human interactions with each other and with the environment. This is like the broken patent system: it's something that has been done for 40 years, except on a computer! We do not need a patent for that, and we do not need a new law for stealing information on a computer. We already have laws for theft.
- tptacek 14y agoThe problem the authors of CFAA faced when the law was written is that this is actually not the case. Existing laws regarding e.g. burglary did not cleanly apply to computer crimes. I think there are probably cases that do a better job showcasing the need for computer-specific crime laws, and crimes that do a worse job at that. Basic wire fraud cases don't really need CFAA from what I can tell, and CFAA serves primarily as a sentence accelerant in them. But in other cases, particularly where people cause damage but don't reap profits, the need for specific laws is clearer.
- etvmueller 14y agoWas it really the case that someone could steal information from a computer and not be charged with a crime, or indicted by a grand jury and then successfully prosecuted under existing law, and that until recently, when information was stolen from a computer, that was not a crime?
- tptacek 14y agoYou think I'm arguing something I'm not arguing. I'm not saying there aren't crimes that are chargeable under CFAA that could be better charged under a pre-existing law. I'm just saying there are crimes that can't be charged that way, thus the need for computer-specific crime laws. CFAA is not a good computer-specific crime law. Two gigantic problems with it: sentences that scale linearly with damages despite the fact that criminal intent and diligence does not scale the same way, and the CFAA's "sentencing accelerant" property, where it bonds covalently with other criminal charges to increase penalties.
- etvmueller 14y agoI understand and I share your point of view to a degree, but I remain skeptical that until CFAA, there were no successful prosecutions for crimes that we are told are only now covered by CFAA. Computers and criminals have been around for a while now. I am also opposed to the idea that we need specific crime laws for things like this. What about vehicular manslaughter while listening to an iPod, and why would that not be covered as distraction equivalent to listening to radio, which I assume and also hope that it would be. There should be some respect for the intent of existing law in addition to the letter, because we do have laws for theft and I am certain that the intent of those laws covers these cases.
- betterunix 14y agoThe problem here is that the CFAA was invoked only because a [separate] crime was committed. We might as well have a law that requires everyone to follow all laws, so that prosecutors have unlimited power to tack on charges.