5 ms·
We talked about this a month or two ago here. The amazing part of this bulb is not it's watts or it's cost. It's that a manufacturer finally put it's warranty
by ck2 14y ago
We talked about this a month or two ago here.
The amazing part of this bulb is not it's watts or it's cost.
It's that a manufacturer finally put it's warranty where it's mouth is.
With a 10 year warranty I will actually buy it compared to the Phillips.
BTW I've yet to have a cheap chinese led 110v bulb last more than 3 years.
- qompiler 14y agoUntil your LED bulb starts making a strange noise and you discover these things actually have a cooling fan inside of them. This thing WILL fail if kept running for a long time. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5avJVvrFedc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5avJVvrFedc
- benjamincburns 14y agoMR16s (the type of bulb in the parent's video) are tough because of their size and limited surface area relative to their lumen output. Most retrofit lamps such as the A19 (the form-factor that most people think of when they think of a light bulb) have 100% passive thermal management. That said, there are a few really good fully-passive, high-output MR16s on the market. I believe switching capacitors in the power supply are what limit the lifetime of most LED bulbs - electrolytic caps being one of the worst offenders. Good thermal management helps mitigate these problems, but a lot of failures are chemical in nature - caused by the degradation of the capacitor's electrolyte. This is why we've all seen the capacitor choice in motherboards and PSUs used as a marketing item. Full disclosure: I used to work for a well-known LED lighting company, but please take the above with a grain of salt as I am not an electrical engineer. [Edit: And of course, these views I've expressed are my own and not representative of my past employer.]
- ars 14y agoWe talked about it here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5329732 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5329732 And the biggest problem with this bulb is the CRI of 80. That's much worse than CFL's which are typically around 90.
- justin66 14y agoIs that really the typical CFL number? I ask because I've got one of the new Cree bulbs and I find the quality of light really a lot better than that of the (admittedly cheap) CFLs I've bought at Costco. So I guess I'm struggling with the significance of CRI.
- thrownaway2424 14y agoEven the top-of-the-line CREE bulbs are only suitable for people who are color blind or habitually not paying attention. I once did an ill-considered change from halogen to LED bulbs in my kitchen, and having done so could no longer see the colors on my dishware. That was ridiculous. I went back to the halogens. My house is in a year-round heating climate anyway so I don't really worry about the waste heat from them.
- justin66 14y agoI wonder if you've actually used one of the newest Cree bulbs? I'm not color blind and I found the color of one of their 2700k bulbs to be better than the CFLs I use in a few places. Come to think of it, they're a fair bit better than the g7power LEDs as well. This is why I'm wondering if the CRI is really a magical "light goodness" benchmark number or what. Some people certainly seem to be treating it that way.
- thrownaway2424 14y agoThey were the best ones I could get my hands on. I believe their advertised CRI is 90. If you look at the spectrum though, they are still quite peaky/notchy. Halogens are very close to sunlight. Halogens with clear bulbs have CRI 100 by definition. Yes, the latest LEDs are far superior to CFL. And oatmeal tastes better than dog shit.
- msutherl 14y agoAnother thing to consider is that radiation outside of the visible light spectrum may have positive effects. For instance, halogens radiate a lot of infrared radiation, which is used in various therapies and is a big part of why being out in the sun feels so good.