4 ms·
"A lawyer that you do not pay is not working for you" I'm not sure I agree with this. If a lawyer agrees to represent you, they have a legal and professional
by cperciva 14y ago
"A lawyer that you do not pay is not working for you"
I'm not sure I agree with this. If a lawyer agrees to represent you, they have a legal and professional responsibility to act in your interest regardless of who pays the bills. In the common case where they are also representing the person or company paying their bills, they should be clear on how a conflict would be resolved -- usually with wording along the lines of "in the event that a conflict arises, you understand and agree that we would terminate our representation of you, and we will assist you in finding other counsel".
The most important question to ask is probably "do you represent me, or are you merely advising me?" -- although a good lawyer will make that clear from the start in order to avoid any possibility of confusion.
(The above is not legal advice, and I am not a lawyer. I have however been a party to such joint representation.)
- jacquesm 14y agoIn this particular instance there was a lawyer involved that clearly did not understand things the way you do and having an independent lawyer involved when there are potential conflicts of interest between the various roles is in my opinion a good thing. Of course there are lawyers that are capable of riding that fine line and making sure that everything is perfect but when in doubt it can get expensive really fast and in the end you are responsible, not your lawyer. Paying a lawyer out of your own pocket in case of such doubt is a very good way of securing that there is no conflict of interest. For obvious reasons I can't go into the details of why in this particular case this was essential so that's a pretty weak defense but I will stand by my words. I agree with the question, still in a fluid situations such as these it is very easy to have such conflicts enter and be unnoticed long enough for trouble to arise. Err on the side of caution.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- wpietri 14y agoIf somebody tells you "If a problem comes up, we'll drop you instantly", then I wouldn't call that "working for you". That's more being a hitchhiker than having a personal driver.
- ScottWhigham 14y agoI find it hard to follow your logic TBH. Your logic/argument are predicated on one thing: that all lawyers respond to their "legal and professional responsibility to act in your interest regardless of who pays the bills" the same way. I'm sorry but I can't buy into that. What if I said, "A doctor has a legal and professional responsibility to act in your interest regardless of who pays the bills" - would you agree with that? I wouldn't. Many times a doctor will say, "This is what I wish we could do but your insurance won't pay for that, so we'll do this instead." Or worse, a doctor keeps a dirty office/gear because it's cheaper for him/her and then infects patients with hepatitis.[1] I could go on and name almost any profession and change the scenarios around to counter argue your logic - a contractor that makes a choice that requires future work from his company (a.k.a. job security), a police chief who decides that writing cheap/easy/unnecessary traffic tickets is the way to make the city council pay attention to how much work they are doing "for the city", an accountant who decides to steal from the company she is accountant for, etc. Just because someone has a "legal and professional responsibility" does not mean that a specific person will honor it. [1] http://www.cnn.com/2013/03/29/health/oklahoma-dental-warning http://www.cnn.com/2013/03/29/health/oklahoma-dental-warning