4 ms·
For the US, where will the energy come from? Given current car usage I find it hard to believe it will come from wind farms.
by RiderOfGiraffes 18y ago
For the US, where will the energy come from? Given current
car usage I find it hard to believe it will come from wind
farms.
- frossie 18y agoElectric cars aren't inherently green - they are only as green as the local source of electricity. Depending on where you are in the US, the percentage of electricity you get from renewable energy varies significantly. If we both have the same identical electric car, but you live on a mostly coal-burning grid, and I live on a mostly geothermal grid, I am a lot greener than you, despite the fact that we drive the same vehicle. The reasons electric cars are a good idea is that once there is a mass adoption of them, individuals don't have to do anything more; as the grid becomes greener, everybody's car becomes greener. So it allows society to change its fossil fuel consumption much more quickly, vecause bold changes are made in the infrastructure but are transparent to users. Electric cars are just one piece of the puzzle.
- CWuestefeld 18y agoRight. And the transport of electricity to the charging station, the storage of electricity (and the attendant need to carry that storage) and the conversion of that storage back to kinetic energy is inefficient. The internal combustion engine, for its flaws, has evolved into a fairly efficient device. I'm utterly convinced that electric cars are a red herring. Look instead at our insistence on dragging around behemoths of cars. We could save a tremendous amount of energy by quitting the race-to-the-top phenomena of escalating car size due to the (largely false) perception of safety.
- ericb 18y ago> transport of electricity to the charging station > storage of electricity > conversion of that storage back to kinetic energy I'd love to see actual numbers to back up your statement--I imagine you are right about efficiency, but I'd like to see how bad the numbers are. We have to drill, transport, and store oil, also. Efficient and dirty doesn't help us much if the dirtiness overshadows the efficiency. Lossy and clean seems preferable, because then you don't have to shed tears over losing energy bought at a steep price in terms emissions.
- tome 18y agoThe comparison's not really meaningful, except to oil-burning electricity plants, but: "most [internal combustion] engines retain an average efficiency of about 18%-20%" http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Internal_combustion_engine#Energy_efficiency http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Internal_combustion_engine#Ener...
- anamax 18y ago> We could save a tremendous amount of energy by quitting the race-to-the-top phenomena of escalating car size due to the (largely false) perception of safety. Actually, we can't because: (1) Personal transportation isn't that big a fraction of total energy use. (2) Cars are getting smaller and have been for some time. The most useful vehicle for fuel savings purposes costs less than $2,000 and gets around 50mpg. Higher mileage doesn't help much and higher price is a killer. Do the arithmetic using $4/gallon gasoline and a "main car" that gets 20-25mpg. And no, you don't get to replace the main car. Folks have it because they need what it does "often enough" and renting doesn't work.
- anamax 18y ago> escalating car size due to the (largely false) perception of safety. Actually, it isn't false. All other things being equal, a larger car is safer in an accident. (That's not to say that the extra safety is always enough.) No, a larger car is not necessarily more accident prone.
- anamax 18y ago> escalating car size due to the (largely false) perception of safety. http://www.autoblog.com/2009/04/14/iihs-finds-sub-compacts-fair-poorly-again/ http://www.autoblog.com/2009/04/14/iihs-finds-sub-compacts-f...
- ericb 18y agoElectric makes the energy source only loosely coupled to the car. Even if the energy doesn't initially come from clean sources, we can solve that problem iteratively.
- radu_floricica 18y agoUnpopular solution, but obvious: nuclear energy.
- jodrellblank 18y agoAlso somewhat impractical - when did the USA last build a nuclear power plant? Where are they going to magic up the people with skills to build and run one? What about the fact that nuclear fuel sources are just as much a limited resource as coal or oil? What about nobody wanting one built near them?
- philwelch 18y agoBuild a plant, good question. Run a plant, you get those people from the Navy (which runs nuclear plants on every submarine and aircraft carrier). What about fuel sources? We've hardly begun to explore for uranium—nuclear is a stopgap for 100-200 years that doesn't have the drawbacks of fossil fuel. I don't have an answer for NIMBY, because I don't know politics.
- anamax 18y ago> What about the fact that nuclear fuel sources are just as much a limited resource as coal or oil? We have 200 years worth of coal....
- jodrellblank 18y agoa) It's OK to burn all the coal we can extract and sod the pollution -> build more coal power plants now to use for electric cars. Burn through the coal more quickly. b) It's not OK to burn all the coal we can extract -> "200 years worth" is a meaningless statment as we have to stop using it, and the sooner the better.
- anamax 18y agoThe suggestion was that nuclear wasn't an option because it was as limited as coal. If so, that limit is 200 years, which suggests that the limit isn't all that important.
- DaniFong 18y agoMost electric cars, hooked to even a coal fired power plant, have a substantially smaller carbon footprint than the best conventional vehicles. c.f. http://www.stanford.edu/group/greendorm/participate/cee124/TeslaReading.pdf http://www.stanford.edu/group/greendorm/participate/cee124/T...