12 ms·
Study: There may not be a shortage of American STEM graduates after all
- Symmetry 14y agoI'd be really interested in finding out how that study defines "IT". And also how it defines "STEM job". Would being a quant on Wall Street be considered a "STEM job", for instance?
- samirahmed 14y agogood question, its probably much broader than you would expect... I think quant would fall under 27.0305 financial math see the official list here http://www.ice.gov/doclib/sevis/pdf/stem-list.pdf http://www.ice.gov/doclib/sevis/pdf/stem-list.pdf
- pdonis 14y agoMy BS detector went off when I read: Basic dynamics of supply and demand would dictate that if there were a domestic labor shortage, wages should have risen. Instead, researchers found, they’ve been flat, with many Americans holding STEM degrees unable to enter the field and a sharply higher share of foreign workers taking jobs in the information technology industry. In other words, wages haven't risen because the reduction in the number of domestic STEM workers has been offset by the increase in the number of foreign STEM workers; the total supply of STEM workers has remained the same, but more of them are foreign. Note that if you remove the word "domestic" in front of "labor shortage", the above quote would be correct; but it includes that word, which makes it worse than wrong.
- nathansobo 14y agoMy anecdotal experience says there's a ton of demand for skilled programmers. If we're graduating CS students that don't have the skills that tech companies need, that's a problem with quality rather than volume.
- RyanIyengar 14y agoAnd my anecdotal experience says there is not a ton of demand for skilled programmers. Guess we're back where we started now.
- pbiggar 14y agoi'm interested to hear you experiences. Most companies I know (circleci included) are dying for skilled devs, though there's no shortage of not-great devs.
- rdouble 14y agoThe demand for skilled programmers is unevenly distributed. There's huge demand in the Bay Area and then a much smaller smattering of demand elsewhere. If you are a skilled dev who doesn't live in the Bay Area, it can very much feel like you aren't in demand. I don't know if that is what he meant, or if he was just being contrarian.
- tuxidomasx 14y agoExactly. It's been my experience that programming job offers in certain areas are plentiful, but the vast majority require relocation if you aren't local. A very small percentage might be open to remote workers, but unless you live in or around these "hot spots" you're going to have a more difficult time finding work, not to mention a comparatively lower compensation.
- pbiggar 14y agoIf you're a skilled dev not in the Bay Area, but can work well remotely, there are plenty of companies hiring. For example: https://circleci.com https://circleci.com.
- dvanduzer 14y agoIf you are hiring, your website does not make that particularly obvious. (Interested applicants will read your blog to learn about you, but surely more prominent placement would generate more flow. Especially since your potential customers are your most likely employees.)
- Locke1689 14y agoIt's important to note that even if this is true (and I suspect that the statistics lead more towards the statement that, "there is not a shortage of low-level IT trained workers" rather than "there is not a shortage of very talented developers") it doesn't mean that the right thing is to limit immigration. Protectionism is almost always a negative for economic growth of a country. Even if wages in the US are depressed, that just means that wages were artificially high and that the US would soon become increasingly noncompetitive. The biggest problem with H-1B visas seem to be the restrictions on working for a single established employer rather than having too many of them.
- geebee 14y agoThere can be a problem, though, with very uneven types of protectionism. For instance, suppose both apples and oranges are both subjected to very high tariffs. Then, you remove all tariffs from oranges, but leave them high on apples. you should expect domestic production to shift to apples and foreign production to shift to oranges, to the extent possible. I can see how you would feel that creating more work visas would lead to a freer market. However, if these visas are heavily concentrated in STEM fields, this may end up producing a very distorted market that deters US citizens from pursuing degrees in this field. One of the provisions of the immigration bill is to grant green cards to graduates of US-based STEM programs at the MS or PhD leve. Rather than a more general liberalization of immigration, that's just the sort of highly specific, targeted program that can produce severe market distortions. Many of the people who object to these visas actually support more general liberalization of immigration - they just object to visa programs that are based on the notion that we need to use immigration specifically to increase the size of the STEM workforce. This is because they believe, as this article suggests, there is no shortage of STEM workers.
- rayiner 14y agoIt's misleading to paint it as a simple "free market" issue when STEM education in the U.S. is massively subsidized by the public.
- qiqing 14y agoQuick correction @Lock1689: It is possible for someone with an H-1B to transfer from one employer to another.
- icn2 14y agoThere is no such a thing shortage of IT workers. These companies (google, facebook…)claim shortage of talents because they always want top ones (at least with the standard they think). As far as there are better quality foreigner workers they always claim shortage.
- pjscott 14y agoSo there's a shortage of good IT workers. Your point?
- mjn 14y agoPretty much by definition, though. They don't have an objective quality standard, but a relative one.
- icn2 14y agoNo shortage of good IT workers as well. My point is it doesn't matter how good local workers are. As far as there are better (their standard) foreign workers they claim there is a shortage because they want top ones.
- jlgreco 14y agoSo suppose, purely hypothetically I assure you, that I'm an engineer that does technical interviews. What is going on, is HR filtering out all the good domestic talent and making me waste my time interviewing crappy candidates that they know won't make the cut just so that they can hire abroad? If there is an abundance of qualified unemployed domestic talent then why can't I, the employed engineer, find some of that talent to recommend so that I can collect some of those juicy bonuses? Or am I hypothetically in on this conspiracy to discriminate against domestic talent as well? Maybe there is something simpler going on. Maybe most candidates really do suck.
- UK-AL 14y agoTheres a shortage of good everything. If there wasn't a shortage it would not be good.
- parennoob 14y agoI'm confused by their conflation of STEM (in particular CS) grads and IT workers. For example they say, “For computer science graduates employed one year after graduation . . . about half of those who took a job outside of IT say they did so because the career prospects were better elsewhere, and roughly a third because they couldn’t find a job in IT,” None of the people who work in the IT department at my company have CS degrees. They have, however, held various sysadmin and programming positions, and do a bloody good job running our IT. I'm not sure we'd hire a fresh-out-of-school CS grad for our IT jobs if they didn't have any experience doing sysadmin or equipment / facility maintenance stuff.
- svachalek 14y agoCompanies that aren't in the tech industry usually lump their programmers (for their web site, or internal process tools) into the IT dept. Still, the conflation of terms in this article makes it hard to understand what it's really saying; most interpretations I can make are just hard to believe.
- bennyg 14y agoYep. My official title is IT Technical Specialist 2 - but I'm an iOS Developer if we're playing with words that actually mean something when said together. Funny enough though, I don't have a CS degree, I have an Art degree. Though everyone I work with is either CS or ECE.
- pbiggar 14y agoThis (and the discussion around it) are bullshit. They somehow think on STEM job is equivalent to another, which is lunacy. - Talking about all STEM graduates as equal is pointless, because some people are useless and some are amazing. - Talking about STEM in general is useless, because software is booming, and nothing else really is. - Talking about all H1B jobs as the same is also bollox: half are employed by infosys (etc) as low cost (and low quality) contractors to avoid paying a fair wage (against the rules of the H1B program as I understand it). However, Google and Facebook (etc) are paying them great salaries, equal to what they pay US employees (even though the expenses are higher with visa and relocation costs). So startups and high growth companies are being starved of great talent, because chemists can't find jobs and Infosys is trying to depress wages of low-quality IT workers? Makes no sense.
- jmduke 14y agobecause software is booming Do you have statistics for this? While the need for STEM is obviously rising, I feel like a lot of this conversation devolves into an echo chamber: I'd love to see hard statistics about STEM career demand.
- pbiggar 14y agoI know that when I sent an email to the YC founders list cause I needed a job (2 years ago, but that's recent), I got 100 replies. I also know I find it hard to find really good devs for CircleCI. But those are just anecdotes...
- bicknergseng 14y agoAnecdotal evidence in the opposite direction: only half of my computer engineering peers in my graduating class of 2011 had jobs in the industry within 3 months of graduating. While I think some devs are in high demand, I think many have little horizontal or upward mobility if they can get a job at all. I don't have a lot of evidence to back this up, and that WP study seems to talk a lot more about IT than software development, but I think it's probably something to think about. I think there's a crisis in training and mentorship in our industry, rather than one of willing bodies.
- graycat 14y agoIt's the same old, same old: It's an old story that somehow too many powerful people in the US Federal Government want to do 'US national technical manpower management'. E.g., when Sputnik went up, the Feds via the NSF flooded US high school and college education with money, scholarships, summer programs, etc. to get more US citizens into STEM fields. During the Cold War and the Space Race, STEM students were paid nearly well enough to buy a house; then the powers that be got really scared. But, with the stimulus, soon the supply exceeded the demand; US citizens who walked into a college STEM course saw the TA and half of the students from Asia or India, turned, and walked out. So, right: Joe and Mary paid taxes to support public education K-college and graduate school. For their children they struggled to meet college expenses. And when their children went to college, somehow they found lots of students there from India and Asia. How come? These students were from families with annual incomes less than $10,000 yet somehow got their children into the college supported by the taxes of Joe and Mary when Joe and Mary had to struggle to pay for their children in that college? Bummer. Sure: The students from India and China were there on various scholarships, indirectly paid for by Joe and Mary. Bummer. Ripoff. During the Viet Nam war, the head of the Selective Service system was old General Louis B. Hershey with the remark that "The US Selective Service System has national manpower management responsibilities far exceeding staffing the armed forces." by which he meant that US young men had two, just two, options, (1) do well in college or graduate school in STEM fields or (2) go to Viet Nam. Of course, that 'responsibility' was only in his egotistical imagination; still he executed on his delusion. Later much of the US 'military industrial complex' concluded that there was a US STEM shortage. So, the powers that be got the NSF to set up a team of economists to calculate, with essentially supply and demand curves, how much 'stimulus' would be needed to increase the labor supply. The stimulus didn't work well for US citizens, so the plan was to write into research grants in US research universities that with the grant money so many students had to be supported and that, hint, hint, there were plenty of willing students from India and Asia, hint, hint. Then there got to be the H1B scam, mostly just a new version of 'indentured servitude' or 'slave labor'. Basically, anytime STEM worker bees get paid well enough to buy a house, big forces in the US move to flood the market with STEM graduates. It's dirt simple: It's capital versus labor. Capital has power and wants cheap labor. These US powers that be are just seeking more money and power and, net, are seriously hurting the basic strength of the US. The solution is for US voters to become informed and come together and vote for the US for the US as a whole and not just for the 1% richest capitalists. Of course there's more at Prof. Norm Matloff's http://heather.cs.ucdavis.edu/h1b.html
- dbond 14y agoA little of topic but... Having read the comments here and many blog posts on HN on this subject it seems that many recent graduates are not up to scratch with what the industry expects. Yet a degree is required to obtain a H1-B visa or 12 years (IIRC) work experience, could the removal of this requirement ever possibly be lobbied for with judgement left up to the potential employer? I realise that a degree is used as a general quality standard in immigration processes but this seems like a situation in which it could actually be detrimental. Note: I'm from the UK, I see the same problems here and I'm curious about the U.S situation.
- ecdavis 14y agoFrom what I understand, companies are currently asking for the H1-B visa quotas to be increased. This suggests that they are finding plenty of people to hire who qualify for an H1-B visa but there are simply not enough visas to go around. With this in mind, dropping the degree requirement is probably not necessary yet.
- nickff 14y agoThis piece fails due to a logical fallacy: the fallacy of composition. What is good for each scientist or engineer is a higher salary, but this is not necessarily good for all of them, or the rest of a country. Perhaps having more scientists and engineers would depress their salaries, (though this is not necessarily true,) while increasing the country's total productivity, and making the average citizen richer. So this article proves nothing, and fails to clearly define what they mean by shortage.
- gojomo 14y agoBe careful trusting data from the EPI, a left/labor/economic-protectionist think tank. It will be selectively chosen and spun to advance their core idea that domestic/union laborers need constant government rescue, via things like immigration restrictions. (Of course data selected by think tanks with other ideologies deserves skeptical reading, as well.) As was pointed out last time the EPI scored a press hit with their claim of stagnant IT wages (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4880332 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4880332), they appear to be leaving out the very real possibility a younger/earlier-career mix of workers -- a demographic bulge -- makes their broad wage averages look worse, even while each individual cohort is better off. And, when in this latest study they highlight how many college graduates who fill IT positions have non-IT degrees (Figure F: 38%+), or of all IT workers have no degree at all (36%, p. 8), they should realize that one way to deal with a skills shortage is to make-do with less-skilled/less-trained people, but then pay them less while they learn or simply play-out-of-position. (This making-do also creates the early-in-career demographic bulge mentioned above.) On the other hand, when the EPI looks at the fact many STEM majors don't wind up working in STEM jobs (Figure D), it is spun as: "For every two students that U.S. colleges graduate with STEM degrees, only one is hired into a STEM job." From that wording you'd think the streets are filled with woeful idle STEM graduates! But maybe, given the still very low unemployment among all with college degrees (and especially technical degrees), these graduates found something else they preferred? Or maybe they really weren't very good at or happy with their exact STEM degree area? It requires the EPI's factory-floor mindset, where STEM degree recipients are cogs that could (or should) be dropped into closely-matching STEM jobs, to make this natural dynamism sound like we might have way more idle STEM graduates than we can use.
- samirahmed 14y agofor those who need clarification of what counts as STEM for immigration purposes http://www.ice.gov/sevis/stemlist.htm http://www.ice.gov/sevis/stemlist.htm http://www.ice.gov/doclib/sevis/pdf/stem-list.pdf http://www.ice.gov/doclib/sevis/pdf/stem-list.pdf
- qiqing 14y agoThank you for that list, Samirahmed. That was substantially more broad than I expected. TIL - STEM as defined by the government apparently includes: - Agricultural Animal Breeding - Livestock Management - Heating, Ventilation, Air Conditioning and Refrigeration Engineering Technology/Technician - Explosive Ordinance/Bomb Disposal
- john_w_t_b 14y agoThere is a shortage of technical specialists in computer programming. It seems that companies are reluctant to train local workers. Startups like to show growth by listing jobs, but they only want "rock stars" so the positions sit unfilled. This saves on labor costs and signals a growing business. It gives an artificial view of the job market however.
- prostoalex 14y agoWhat kind of training would a company offer? CS is one of those disciplines where wealth of materials, books, documentation, videos and working code examples are available online, for free or at pretty reasonable prices. Why would you sign up to waste a day at New Horizons listening to some drone over-explaining stored procedures on a whiteboard?
- TheCoelacanth 14y agoThe problem with this whole discussion is that it is lumping all STEM graduates together. There is really only high demand for CS and some engineering fields. There is a surplus of graduates in many of the other fields that are categorized under STEM. When someone says there is a shortage of STEM graduates, they are really only talking about the T & E, they aren't talking about the S & M.