2 ms·
I get so tired of seeing this sloppy thinking. Discrimination isn't bad. Its an essential part of clear judgement. Prejudicial discrimination is bad because
by CapitalistCartr 14y ago
I get so tired of seeing this sloppy thinking. Discrimination isn't bad. Its an essential part of clear judgement. Prejudicial discrimination is bad because its piss-poor discrimination. Of course universities are discriminating against a wide variety of people; they can't accept everyone. The question is whether its prejudicial, as in they've pre-judged these people because of a group they belong to before they've looked at them as an individual.
- jsnk 14y agoDo you think discrimination by public institutions is not bad?
- CapitalistCartr 14y agoI think you misunderstood my post. Your question is exactly the problem I addressed. Universities HAVE to discriminate; they cannot accept every applicant. The question is how are they doing it, is it a good way, and is there a better way. You discriminate every time you purchase one product over another, take one job over another, live in one area over another, befriend one person over another, etc. We all do. The key to doing it well is clear, analytical judgement about such decisions. Personally, I haven't seen much of that in University admissions at any school.
- jsnk 14y agoI am ok with private businesses or individuals going about their own business with whatever racist, homophobic, sexist policies. I don't care. I simply won't visit them or pay for their service. I read my fair share of Rothbard, Friedman and Block. Discrimination in the sense of making choice so long as the choice doesn't violate the rights of other is ok, even if it is morally despicable. This issue of universities is completely different. Even private universities get public funding. Universities are inexplicably tied to tax payers including Asians. This is where I see the problem. Either remove public funding from universities operating admission based on racism or stop having a racist admission standard.
- rozap 14y agoHe's differentiating between prejudice and discrimination in his post. Universities discriminate against stupid people all the time, that's how their admissions work. What's not a good metric to discriminate upon, is race, because it doesn't offer insight into how successful the student may or may not be. Those sorts of qualities (race, gender) are not things to discriminate upon because doing so would be prejudice; which by definition is not an effective method of discrimination.
- svachalek 14y agoAssuming you are just responding to the title (because I don't see any evidence otherwise), what about "Asian" is not "a group they belong to before [...] an individual"?
- CapitalistCartr 14y agoIf its true for that reason, yes. Universities are coy with straight answers. Some speculate its because the Asians are culturally too uniform, same focus on GPA, piano, etc. and the schools are looking for more diversity than that. The test of that would be an Asian who didn't fit the profile getting in with a lower test score. Others suggest its because of how many legacy students the upper tier accept. Whatever the reason, SAT scores are not the only factor in admission because SAT is not the sole arbiter of a good University student, or at least that's what the University leadership say. Personally, I think its well-meaning racism, and, as they say, the road to Hell is paved with good intentions. But my thinking it ain't facts, ain't statistics. Only the facts, carefully analyzed matter in the end.
- Kudzu_Bob 14y ago"Prejudicial discrimination is bad because its piss-poor discrimination." Exactly. This is why basketball teams are missing out by their pig-headed refusal to send talent scouts to evaluate Rwanda's Pygmies.
- CapitalistCartr 14y agoHiring tall people for basketball isn't pre-judging people. Evidence has clearly shown its a huge advantage.
- Kudzu_Bob 14y agoSure, but you're pre-judging all pygmies as being short. This is exactly the behavior that you condemn, unless I've missed something.
- eagsalazar2 14y agoKudzu can think! Nice job.
- jon_dahl 14y agoThis is a strange distinction. It sounds like you're defining "discrimination" as "judgment" or even just "making a decision", whereas you're defining "prejudice" in a way that most people would consider a synonym for "discrimination". I'm also not sure what that has to do with this article (which doesn't hang on any particular definition).
- eagsalazar2 14y agoYou are making an invalid assumption. Prejudicial discrimination is bad iff you have total knowledge of all variables. Admissions panels have very little information that in many cases is weakly correlated with the outcomes they are interested in. What you are calling prejudicial in that case they call experience. They correlate past statistical data on how the variables they do have access to predict the outcomes they want. If that a satisfying situation? No way. Is including your experience better than just using the data you have for a current set of candidates? Hell yes. On average, hell yes. Some students will get screwed but on average IF you are smart, not a bigot, rational, have good past data, etc, your results WILL be better. Of course, most people aren't all of those things. But what can you do other than make your best try at an optimal outcome? If they went just on raw present data, quality of students admitted to Stanford/MIT would probably go down and 99% of students would be asian. Does that seem better? s/sloppy thinking/nuanced yet practical problem solving/g