2 ms·
Everyone is quick to blame only Reddit -- and they certainly deserve a great deal of it, collectively. But I think we should look at laying part of the blame on
by joekrill 14y ago
Everyone is quick to blame only Reddit -- and they certainly deserve a great deal of it, collectively. But I think we should look at laying part of the blame on the professional investigators themselves, too. They clearly knew who they were looking for long before they released any useable information, and I think they should have taken more initiative to explicitly eliminate Reddit suspects they knew were not involved. They could have easily issued a brief statement definitely stating they cleared Sunil Tripath, for example, without releasing information on the identities of the actual bombers. Same goes for the two innocent guys that were featured on the front page of the NY Post.
The investigators did a terrific job, and I don't want to put down anything they did. And maybe I'm being naive and this would be a slippery slope. But I still think some of these specific false accusations could have been mitigated very easily.
- ProblemFactory 14y agoI don't think that's a workable solution. The professionals had identified the brothers as suspects - but only as very probable suspects. They could still have been wrong. Publicly definitely clearing someone who might later turn out to be the actual bomber or an associate would have enormous political (and perhaps legal) consequences. I believe that any form of crowdsourced investigation is reasonable only if there just isn't enough professional interest or resources to pursue a case. For example finding your stolen laptop. If there are thousands of FBI agents working on a priority case, with additional private data feeds from security cameras, telephone logs and wiretaps, public "help" is of no use beyond stroking the ego of the participants.