4 ms·
I for one am glad that the Reddit effort turned into the fiasco it did. Criminal investigation is a profession. Asking a bunch of amateurs to come up with a so
by kstenerud 14y ago
I for one am glad that the Reddit effort turned into the fiasco it did.
Criminal investigation is a profession. Asking a bunch of amateurs to come up with a solution is akin to asking a bunch of amateurs to build an air traffic control system. Sure, there might be a few people in the crowd who can actually do it, but most people can't. Worse, they're likely to suffer from the Dunning-Kruger effect. And with everyone given equal voice regardless of ability, and a popularity driven forum, you have a recipe for disaster every time. The only difference between this and Salem is the crowd size.
The FBI played it right by not releasing anything important and letting the public have its little playtime. It's unfortunate that this caused some innocent people to be flagged by the mob, but I think that given the circumstances of our more connected lives, this was the best play to make in a bad situation. The mob would move regardless, so why not slow then down by sending them chasing their tails for a bit while the real professionals got down to business?
- darkarmani 14y ago> I for one am glad that the Reddit effort turned into the fiasco it did. I don't know if i really believe that it was that much of a fiasco. All the photos i saw where pictures of people with backpacks near the area of the bombings. That definitely gave the FBI leads.
- kstenerud 14y agoMeanwhile every person singled out by the mob was quickly alerted to that fact. A big part of professionalism (and law enforcement in particular) is knowing when to be discreet.