2 ms·
You said Atheism is a falsifiable hypothesis that fails if anyone presents repeatable, concrete evidence that a higher power exists That sounds great, except i
by DanielBMarkham 18y ago
You said Atheism is a falsifiable hypothesis that fails if anyone presents repeatable, concrete evidence that a higher power exists
That sounds great, except it isn't.
How would somebody go about creating a repeatable falsifiable experiment that showed that there was a God? Try it out in your mind. It just doesn't work.
I point to a rock and say "This rock is God. Therefore you are wrong." How would you refute such a claim? Point to a rock and say "No it isn't?" We easily end up simply contradicting one another.
You can't refute a claim about the existence of God without getting into a discussion of the definition of God. Because without a common definition, there's nothing to falsify. You could say "There is no God according to this definition," which is a fair thing to say. If we all shared the same definition, it might even work. But we don't.
So I simply pick "God is some subset of that which cannot currently be proved"
We know that there are things in formal systems that are true yet cannot be proved, and we know that throughout history there are things that are true that could not be proved for a long time, so such things exist. Yet because we are unable to attach our grappling hooks of logic and reason to the concept it defies our Popperian paradigm that we would quite reasonably apply to all other things scientific.
God is simply a belief that we don't know everything. Under that rubric, of course there is a God.
Now is he a big guy in the sky with a beard, etc? Beats me. I think once you establish belief in the unknowable you have to acknowledge that anything past that point is going to be speculation, personal opinion, creative storytelling, etc. Nothing wrong with that, it's just not rational in the same way science is. Your "falsifiable" qualification ends where God begins.
And that's why atheism is faith-based. It presupposes the existence or access to all facts and methods regarding dealing with God. In that sense it's actually quite more irrational than other religions which continually twist and morph as understanding changes. Atheism will always be the same -- because at it's heart it's always about applying science to dreams: a ludicrous idea at best.