6 ms·
As someone who has not been following this very closely, why on earth did Adobe abandon Flash? They had a reasonably capable plug-in shipped in just about ever
by rwmj 14y ago
As someone who has not been following this very closely, why on earth did Adobe abandon Flash? They had a reasonably capable plug-in shipped in just about every browser, with a huge ecosystem around it, and then they just chucked it all away. This seems to make no business sense at all to me.
- camus 14y agoBecause Adobe dont understand the web,it's not in their culture. They never invented one successfull webdeveloper product, and those they bought from Macromedia ( Dreamweaver , Fireworks , ColdFusion , Flash)...havent evolved a bit or are dead. They fired most of the legacy Macromedia work force anyway. They should sell all these tools or open-source them.
- laumars 14y agoYou've clearly never heard of Edge[1]. Adobe are now putting great strides in providing HTML5 tools. That said, I personally would still avoid Edge just because of Adobe's past record. It might seem petty, but I've lost faith in the company so there's little incentive to pay to join their HTML5 services. [1] http://html.adobe.com/edge/?promoid=KAGMS http://html.adobe.com/edge/?promoid=KAGMS
- faboo 14y agoTo be fair, if camus hasn't heard of Edge it isn't his fault - it's Adobe's. Which, in a way, helps to emphasize his point.
- laumars 14y agoThat would be fine if we were talking about some small hidden product, but Edge has been well covered on HN and it's included with Adobe's Creative Cloud - which has also been well advertised. Plus at some level you have to expect people working in the industry to take responsibility for their own research (assuming he does work in IT, rather than being one of those "arm chair critics" that lesser forums are often plagued with).
- jfb 14y agoI don't know if Adobe doesn't understand "the web"; I think what happened here was just the landscape shifting out from under Adobe. The iPhone wasn't going to support Flash, initially because the power economics didn't work. Once the App Store was released, there was no way Apple would allow out-of-band application development technologies. So what happened is that, to reach this new segment of the market, web developers needed to develop two versions of their applications -- one for iOS and one for everybody else. This in turn spurred development of non-native web technologies, for those applications where a fully native version wasn't feasible, which further reduced the demand for Flash. Adobe was forced to try and play catch up, and that's a really tough position to be in. Good riddance, but I'm fully expecting Flash's niche as a provider of abusive advertisement and wretched restaurant menus to be filled soon enough. To paraphrase Jurassic Park, "shitty software will find a way."
- derefr 14y agoAs a tangent: oh man, if just Fireworks was open-source, I'd never have to pay for an Adobe product again. Most of my high-level design occurs in CSS, so the only thing I actually need software for is creating tiny icons and textures, and Fireworks excels at that. Heck, if someone made an OSS clone of Fireworks I'd be happy. Why is everyone in the open-source community with graphics knowledge trying to clone either Photoshop or Illustrator? (And no, I don't mean "a pixel-art editor" in the style of Pixen; Fireworks indeed does that, but also contains the live vector texturing and manipulation logic from Flash.)
- camus 14y agoI've been using fireworks for 10 years. That's an amazing peace of software indeed.
- robin_reala 14y agoJust about every browser apart from every iOS device sold. They tried to compete on Android but they couldn’t make a performant version in time.
- EnderMB 14y agoFlash works perfectly fine on my Galaxy Nexus. It drains the battery, but I use it all the time.
- ghshephard 14y agoWithout being [too] snarky, I thought it was interesting that, after meditating on your reply for a minute, I could accurately edit your response, without really distorting your observations: "Flash on my Galaxy Nexus drains the battery." If you read http://www.apple.com/hotnews/thoughts-on-flash/ http://www.apple.com/hotnews/thoughts-on-flash/, you'll see that point #4, was all about battery, and battery life is indeed, an element of a "performant" device.
- EnderMB 14y agoI would still consider it performant, even if it does drain the battery. It drains it just as much as watching a video on the YouTube app will drain the battery. Although I do agree with your comment, I think that Apple's reasons for ditching Flash went beyond their public words.
- tptacek 14y agoApple didn't "ditch" Flash for iOS; they never adopted it in the first place, and it wasn't available to them when they launched the iPhone.
- revscat 14y ago> It drains it just as much as watching a video on the YouTube app will drain the battery. I very much doubt that this is true. Most modern smartphones have a dedicated video decoding chip. Flash, on the other hand, is entirely in software. This means that to play a video the system in question has to load up not just video codecs but a full-stack VM -- Flash -- as well, and the CPU is responsible for most of that responsibility. At that point the power efficiencies gained by offloading functionality to a dedicated chip are lost. Now, Adobe might have pursued a route wherein those functions were offloaded to the AVC chip and/or the GPU, but they were not apparently successful in being able to do so. > Although I do agree with your comment, I think that Apple's reasons for ditching Flash went beyond their public words. Why? I think at this point history has shown that those publicly stated reasons were entirely valid. Efforts to make Flash run efficiently on tablets and smartphones failed, despite energetic attempts to do so. Evidence tends to support the view that Flash failed on mobile on its own shortcomings.
- kibibu 14y agoParticularly that for a lot of target apps (ie. anything vaguely interactive/animated/noisy, such as games and education products), Flash is the only alternative if you need to support IE7-9. I am in the process of porting our suite of educational products from AS3 to Haxe/NME/Jeash purely to hit tablets, but it looks like we might have to use it on the desktop too if this exodus keeps up. Note that Flex and the AS3 compilers are now an Apache open-source project, it's just the player that isn't.
- jader201 14y agoI don't think Adobe abandoned Flash -- they saw the writing on the wall due to declining support. It started with Apple coming out and officially stating[1] why they thought Adobe was bad for their devices -- even for the desktop OSX. And since Apple devices have such a large market share, many web sites realized they needed to switch to HTML5 to support this market share. I also think Apple's public rejection of Flash affected its reputation, and Flash was seen as an outcast by some. It became "cool" to switch to HTML5. It was a snowball effect that resulted in their ultimate demise. That's how I observed it anyway over the past few years. [1]http://www.apple.com/hotnews/thoughts-on-flash/ http://www.apple.com/hotnews/thoughts-on-flash/
- azakai 14y ago> They had a reasonably capable plug-in shipped in just about every browser, with a huge ecosystem around it, and then they just chucked it all away. This seems to make no business sense at all to me. They only made money off of development tools and services, not plugin installs, and they can do that off of HTML5 as well. (They would have competition there, which is a disadvantage, of course.) They did try to monetize higher-end games, with the 9% revenue model they introduced. But apparently they found with their partners that it had no future, so they cancelled it.