6 ms·
Sunsetting Flash
- Samuel_Michon 14y ago”When we started working on a Flash deployment add-on some 18 months ago we had high hopes for the future of Flash as a gaming platform.” That made me wonder whether they were paying attention. The writing has been on the wall for quite some time. Luckily, they have anticipated this and built a WebPlayer that does not require Flash and works on all major browsers – it even supports Native Client. http://unity3d.com/unity/multiplatform/web http://unity3d.com/unity/multiplatform/web
- camus 14y agoSo you are saying using a plugin is better than another one ? Doesnt make sense. How many users have the unity player deployed ? zip. And a plugin is still a plugin , wether it is flash or not.
- Samuel_Michon 14y agoI’d rather not use any plugins, but not all plugins are created equal. Flash Player is a turd, from security to performance and power conservation. We deserve better. Even if Unity’s WebPlayer were every bit as miserable as Flash, it would still make web browsing better than having Flash installed, as few websites will call the Unity WebPlayer.
- camus 14y agoHello , there is something called flashblock and click to play. And nothing guarantees that the Unity web player is not a turd , from security to performance and power conservation. Obviously you never used their player ...
- _delirium 14y agoI wonder if detecting the Unity WebPlayer and using it to serve rich-media ads when present is that far off...
- __--__ 14y agoIt'll never happen. Flash is a lightweight rich media format designed for rich media. Unity is a full blown 3d environment and is not lightweight and not 2d friendly. That said, the only thing unity is really useful for is 3d applications, which are very limited. It's not going to replace Flash for 2d games.
- __--__ 14y agoThe webplayer is more miserable than flash's, by virtue that it's less mature. It crashes a lot, especially on macs.
- kevingadd 14y agoMirroring the growth of the Unity development platform is the Unity Web Player which had reached an impressive 125 million installs. The install rate of the Web Player also continues to grow and now reaches over 5 million new computers each month with all indication that this rate will continue to rise. http://www.marketwire.com/press-release/unity-reaches-one-million-registered-developers-1641486.htm http://www.marketwire.com/press-release/unity-reaches-one-mi... (April 2012) Yep, that's zip alright.
- pjmlp 14y agoUnity started as a web plugin!
- macspoofing 14y ago>That made me wonder whether they were paying attention. That makes me wonder if you're paying attention. Unity is a framework for high-performance 3D games. If you want those games to run in a browser, what do you use? How did the landscape look 18 months ago?
- __--__ 14y agoThey were paying attention. Exporting to flash would have been a huge coup for Unity. The adoption of their plugin is slow. Being able to leverage the flash player would make it an actual, viable solution for game companies now, not after the several years it would take for the Unity plugin to reach critical mass.
- timc3 14y agoThe more that jump of the whole Flash/Flex nightmare the better off we will all be as a wake up call to Adobe to either sort out the bugs that are quite evident or to just accept that it should be put to rest.
- camus 14y agoexcept Unity works with its own web player that is very far from being bug free and secure.
- kevingadd 14y agoHow about instead of continuing to ramble on with poorly spelled and grammatically flawed comments that claim all sorts of things about Unity (and Flash, for that matter), you provide the vaguest amount of evidence or even speculation to support your claims that Unity's web player is some sort of security nightmare? How about some CVEs? Or descriptions of botnets using Unity to infect end users' machines? Or even descriptions of bugs in the web player that cause the slightest discomfort to users? I've played lots of Unity games in my browser and I know lots of developers who use it. I've literally never heard complaints about security problems or had the Unity plugin crash my browser, and I have to terminate plugin-container all the time when Flash hangs, so I'm no stranger to plugin crashes.
- camus 14y agoYou can bash my grammar all you want , a proprietary plugin is always buggy and a security hole.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- pjonesdotca 14y agohttp://osvdb.org/79460 http://osvdb.org/79460
- pjonesdotca 14y agohttp://www.securiteam.com/securitynews/5WP3M0A8VA.html http://www.securiteam.com/securitynews/5WP3M0A8VA.html
- kayoone 14y agoI am absolutely sure they work on something targeting ASM.JS. They already support native client and for the rest there is the native Unity plugin. Furthermore Flash is (and always has been) buggy, support by Adobe is lacking and its future isnt looking good. In that scenario flash seems pretty obsolete indeed.
- Father 14y agoAs long as there is fragmentation then flash will not be obsolete. For example the lack of a common supported audio format or shader language in browsers to name two.
- kayoone 14y agoWith ASM.JS and Native Client Unity can basically run their plugin without needing a plugin :) For the rest of the browsers there is still ASM.JS (which just runs slower on browsers not directly supporting it) or the native Unity Plugin. So for Unity Technologies, Flash is pretty much obsolete.
- rwmj 14y agoAs someone who has not been following this very closely, why on earth did Adobe abandon Flash? They had a reasonably capable plug-in shipped in just about every browser, with a huge ecosystem around it, and then they just chucked it all away. This seems to make no business sense at all to me.
- camus 14y agoBecause Adobe dont understand the web,it's not in their culture. They never invented one successfull webdeveloper product, and those they bought from Macromedia ( Dreamweaver , Fireworks , ColdFusion , Flash)...havent evolved a bit or are dead. They fired most of the legacy Macromedia work force anyway. They should sell all these tools or open-source them.
- laumars 14y agoYou've clearly never heard of Edge[1]. Adobe are now putting great strides in providing HTML5 tools. That said, I personally would still avoid Edge just because of Adobe's past record. It might seem petty, but I've lost faith in the company so there's little incentive to pay to join their HTML5 services. [1] http://html.adobe.com/edge/?promoid=KAGMS http://html.adobe.com/edge/?promoid=KAGMS
- faboo 14y agoTo be fair, if camus hasn't heard of Edge it isn't his fault - it's Adobe's. Which, in a way, helps to emphasize his point.
- laumars 14y agoThat would be fine if we were talking about some small hidden product, but Edge has been well covered on HN and it's included with Adobe's Creative Cloud - which has also been well advertised. Plus at some level you have to expect people working in the industry to take responsibility for their own research (assuming he does work in IT, rather than being one of those "arm chair critics" that lesser forums are often plagued with).
- waxzce 14y agoWebDev are sunsetting flash ! [2 years ago]
- workbench 14y agoLast nail in the coffin, the Unity Stage3D demos were easily the best examples of what Stage3D was capable of. Made Adobes examples look like a joke.
- kostya-kow 14y agoThis is good news. Flash is a dying technology, and HTML is the way forward. Hopefully this means they will make a HTML5 version with WebGL of their player.
- troymc 14y agoThe post says nothing about HTML5 or WebGL (or asm.js). They're all gung-ho about their proprietary Unity Web Player (a plugin).
- andyhmltn 14y agoIt's a wonder anybody uses flash anymore
- dsirijus 14y agoTo offer a business perspective on this, as opposed to widely spread tech-centric comments... Flash market is still there, and it's growing. Hard-on-3D browser based games are extremely sparse with business opportunities, as are HTML5 (WebGL, Canvas, plain old school js) games. Unity player is seeing huge growth, but that's peanuts in comparison to Flash plugin availability. HTML5 games need monetization strategy that ain't just "slap a multiplayer and process most of it on backend". Thing is, Adobe is a corporation. They think business first, technology second. Market is there. Plugin availability is there. Tools are there. Developers are there. Wtf? And that's why Adobe doesn't make sense to me with all they're doing with Flash. At all. On a more personal note, another wtf! Flash enabled huge infusion of creativity on web, way of expressing in much less contrived ways than available. Made you experience web you remember fondly from not so far long ago. Still does. Remember that. Only then move on.
- jader201 14y ago> Flash market is still there, and it's growing. Do you have a reference for this? Not that I have a reference to the contrary, but I'm not getting this impression at all based on the increasing number of sites that I see supporting HTML5 (more and more sites work on iOS devices). At one point, most multimedia sites wouldn't work on iOS devices. Now, I only run into these occasionally, and it seems to be less and less frequently that I do. EDIT: Actually, according to this[1], the Flash market is indeed shrinking. Assuming this is accurate, of course. [1]http://w3techs.com/technologies/details/cp-flash/all/all http://w3techs.com/technologies/details/cp-flash/all/all
- dsirijus 14y agoAside of asking for details of few high profile developers and sponsors, no. They have extremely widely distributed and viewed network of games, so I'm fairly confident in the accuracy of those trends reported. Another interesting point they've raised is fairly low overlap of mobile and flash gamer demographics (which impacted their cross-promotion attempts). EDIT IN RESPONSE TO EDIT: Market and distribution are not neccesarily correlated, prime example being iOS vs Android. In Flash game market, this is reflected in ever increasing quality of games published.
- moneypenny 14y agoFlash Player not withstanding, the rest of the product line is very good IMHO. ActionScript 3 is a decent language with great compiler support, three good IDEs (FlashDevelop, FDT and Flex Builder) and libraries galore. Desktop support with AIR (i.e. iPlayer) is right there too. But the runtime, Flash Player, sucks. It pains me to see Adobe throw away everything else just because the runtime is horrible. I would LOVE to see ActionScript shift towards browser-native or HTML5 runtimes. Seriously. Flex can go walk the plank along with the Flash VM, but please, Adobe, take the maturity of that platform and make it do something useful. You managed to compile to iOS, Android and Blackberry, so we know you are capable of really good work, it just needs to be web right now.
- camus 14y agoAS3 is awesome and is what javascript should have been. The flash IDE is great for vector graphics , animation ,and game assets. AIR is great , but there is a lot of untaped potential , and Adobe doesnt seem to be interested in making that product grow. Adobe could run it's player on a js vm, but does Adobe want to now ? Adobe is relaunching a new version of Director , that would make it a unity competitor.(i'm one a beta tester of the next director).
- AnthonyMouse 14y agoThe thing I never understood was why Flash Player continues to be a binary blob. They don't even sell it for money. Just BSD license the damn thing and inside of a few months it will be on the standards track and people will have incorporated the code into all the major browsers and be fixing all the bugs for you. Popular image file formats are open standards and people still buy Photoshop. Popular video codecs are open standards and people still buy Premier. Why they decided to go with a binary blob for ActionScript and in so doing make everyone hate them is a mystery.
- camus 14y agoI dont know why, they are just stupid.
- 14y ago
- davedx 14y agoI was at Unite last year in Amsterdam, and had a chat with the Adobe reps at their booth. The first question I actually asked them was about the future of Flash, because I'd heard that it was being phased out. But that was "only on mobile" apparently. Their demo was pretty impressive - lots of nice looking 3D graphics and so on - but I have to admit I was skeptical even then.
- middayc 14y agowill unity (player at least) someday work on linux?
- kevingadd 14y agoThey already have Linux player support: http://unity3d.com/unity/multiplatform/desktop http://unity3d.com/unity/multiplatform/desktop