3 ms·
Your analogy to reposting is a robbery? Really? Mine is, telling your friends a joke without bothering to establish who originally invented it.
by scotty79 14y ago
Your analogy to reposting is a robbery? Really?
Mine is, telling your friends a joke without bothering to establish who originally invented it.
- robertpateii 14y agoI'd say the truth is somewhere in between. Closer to a comedian using another comedian's joke.
- scotty79 14y agoIs that because even though the show is free performer gets 2% of the popcorn viewers choose to buy? Original authors of the jokes either don't earn any money with them or do it similar way that the "joke thief" does. Only they are not that popular as he is. I think reposting is much less of an offence then one proffessional comediant using joke of another one without proper attribution.
- sesqu 14y ago"Stealing" jokes is very much frowned upon, but at least in performing arts, much relies on delivery. The same is not true for static arts, where poor attribution ranges from forgery to plagiarism.
- cf 14y agoIt's not like many of the original artists want a payout. They just want attribution.
- illuminate 14y agoThese things usually have passed around the internet several times before it gets to the meme aggregators, I wish there was a better solution than watermarking. Tineye/GIS would theoretically work, but it'd find every instance where the meme was passed around, not its origin! Do you have a suggesting for finding each "owner"? Such requirements would shut down all these sites (not that we'd have a huge loss by doing so, but I'd like to think that a social/technological solution would be possible.)
- scotty79 14y agoThe problem is that because you can be rightfully extorted by original author you have little incentive to keep and acknowledge attribution. It's better to pretend that given image came from the cloud. That's how copyright enforcers again make it worse for all creative people.