5 ms·
>resulting things like exploitation of mugshots for commercial profit and so on. What? I personally think all defamation laws are bs, but regardless, what is w
by Houshalter 14y ago
>resulting things like exploitation of mugshots for commercial profit and so on.
What? I personally think all defamation laws are bs, but regardless, what is wrong with publishing mugshots?
- anigbrowl 14y agoAsk someone who's been arrested in error.
- nilved 14y agoOr someone who was arrested. Convicted criminals have rights too.
- aidenn0 14y agoOkay, I'll bite: can someone who's been arrested in error tell me what's wrong with publishing mugshots?
- anigbrowl 14y agoSuppose you were arrested in error. Would you want your mugshot floating around the internet forever? Indeed, suppose you were arrested with cause, but for some minor crime. Same question.
- tokenadult 14y agoYou ask a fair question, which I wrote about in a post just in the last day or so. (I was remembering a post from more than a year ago, as I recall, from another HN participant.) Different societies resolve these trade-offs differently, but the United States strongly favors making all arrest records public precisely to avoid having secret arrests, a feature of life in countries with a secret police service. (I have lived in such a country.) Yeah, sure, if I had a mugshot, I'd rather not have it all over the Internet, but if I did have a mugshot on the Internet, it wouldn't displace everything else about me on the Internet. As I recall, there is a mug shot of Bill Gates on the Internet, but that doesn't do the most to form his reputation. So simply put, the trade-off here in the United States is that speech is counteracted by more speech. Rather little is done in secret here. Again, I have lived where the trade-offs are different, and I think that this is a generally desirable trade-off, and that United States defamation law strikes a good balance, with the defence of truth being very dispositive in defamation cases. AFTER EDIT: Contrary to what is suggested by HN participant lutusp in another subthread here, there is no "false light" problem in the case the complaining doctor is complaining about. I am a lawyer, and I wouldn't dream of relying on Wikipedia for legal advice or even lay summaries of the law on most subjects.
- anigbrowl 14y agoSorry about the slow reply - I didn't expect this sub-thread to be so lively. I get the legal arguments for your position, but have a third perspective, being from Western Europe. I think the best thing I could do is work this pet issue of mine up into an essay and make it into its own thread later.
- btilly 14y agoLet's make this a real example. http://www.thesmokinggun.com/mugshots/celebrity/business/bill-gates http://www.thesmokinggun.com/mugshots/celebrity/business/bil... shows a mugshot of someone who later became famous. It was taken after a minor traffic infraction, the details of which are long forgotten. Over the years this picture has provided many, including me, with repeated minor amusement. If I featured in a similar mugshot and it afforded someone else with amusement, well turnabout is fair play. There is no such mugshot of me, but I would not think it a big deal if there was. And I doubt that Bill Gates worries himself about the fact that that is out there. By contrast if my right to free speech could be shut down just because Bill Gates does not like that particular picture, then what other speech could he shut down because he, or some other influential person, disliked it? I heartily agree that free speech is often abused. But when you open the door to shutting down speech, there is a short road from there to a loss of democracy. That would scare me. Consider this well. The USA is messy, but has been a democracy for hundreds of years and few are concerned that it is about to become a dictatorship. By contrast Brazilian democracy is younger than me, and it is by no means certain that I won't survive long enough to see another military dictatorship there.
- krichman 14y agoI guess the real solution is to get society to agree that a minor crime shouldn't be a barrier to employment.
- DanBC 14y agoNow imagine the mugshot isn't for a minor traffic offence, but is for a rape or child abuse offence; and that the person photographed was released without charge and never prosecuted. That mugshot now becomes a severe problem for you, risking your employment, and even your life.
- pvaldes 14y agoAnd now imagine also that there is a perfectly guilty rapist but, have exactly the same name as you (ups) And when an possible employer enter your name in google the name rapist and the mugshot appears, and when you are in an airport you wait for an hour and probably lose the next flight typically until a bored airport policeman finds that, mmh, not, probably not the same people... maybe we could keep him/her another 20 minutes? Welcome tho the world of plastic surgery...
- Houshalter 14y agoWell with the internet pretty much anything you do or that happens to you is going to circulate around the internet forever. Maybe the police shouldn't release that kind of information, but as far as being illegal for people to spread it is censorship and ridiculous.
- MisterBastahrd 14y agoThe purpose of many of these sites is to extort money from people who have had mugshots taken of them, regardless of whether they are ultimately guilty or innocent, and long after they have since served their time or been found innocent. Imagine you are accused of a crime you did not commit, are arrested and end up in jail long enough to lose your job, are found innocent, but searches for your name come up with your mugshot and outdated information about the crime you never committed... because 10 sites have all decided to make you a part of their list. And you can have your mugshot taken down, if you will agree to pay them $50. Each. Does this still seem like nothing's wrong here?
- nekojima 14y agoPaul Curtis was arrested by the FBI last week, and on Tuesday he was released without charges, when the FBI found there was zero evidence in pursue charges. But his name and face were among the top stories, not related to the Boston bombings, in the past week. Much like many of those wrongly and very publicly arrested, he will now have some troubles in the future from those who may still believe he was responsible. As we know, information on the Internet, for the most part, lasts forever. "US drops case against ricin letter suspect Paul Curtis" http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-us-canada-22273355 http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-us-canada-22273355
- dredmorbius 14y agoThere are several instances of: 1. People being arrested in error. 2. Mugshots being published. 3. People requesting mugshots be taken down. 4a. Mugshots disappearing from site A but reappearing on site B. Rinse, wash, repeat. 4b. An "administration fee" being charged for the service of taking down mugshot. See 4a. There are crimes which are considered so heinous that even being publicly accused can carry a very substantial social stigma. Consider the recent exceptionally public allegations against a prominent Silicon Valley insider of rape by another SV insider. In other cases, the increasing use of background checks, not limited to criminal convictions but including searches of social media, news, and the general Internet, means that such false allegations might appear. Again: take the case of individuals who were falsely accused of being the Boston Marathon bombers, including a missing college student and a high school student fingered by the New York Post (which "stands by its reporting" for whatever the hell that means). Or today's story that a man arrested in connection with ricin-laced letters being sent to congressmen and the President being released. If that still doesn't work, picture this: you wake up tomorrow to find the police at your door. Why? An ex-girlfriend, or ex-boyfriend, or co-worker, or child at the charity you volunteer with, or some total stranger, has just made up completely random shit about you. Or your image is similar to that of someone photographed doing something Really Really Bad. Or your Twitter / Facebook / HN account has been hacked and is spewing bile or terrorist threats. It all sounds very abstract until it isn't. There's a reason why the authors of the US Constitution insisted on due process.
- Houshalter 14y agoWell maybe the police shouldn't release mugshots, but that's different from making it illegal for people to have them. >If that still doesn't work, picture this: you wake up tomorrow to find the police at your door. Why? An ex-girlfriend, or ex-boyfriend, or co-worker, or child at the charity you volunteer with, or some total stranger, has just made up completely random shit about you. Or your image is similar to that of someone photographed doing something Really Really Bad. Or your Twitter / Facebook / HN account has been hacked and is spewing bile or terrorist threats. How would a defamation law prevent this exactly?
- deleted 14y ago