4 ms·
Seems like a horrible and arbitrary idea. What is it meant to achieve? Send a bitcoin to an address? View a block? HTML5 started off well, but is beginning to
by FireBeyond 14y ago
Seems like a horrible and arbitrary idea. What is it meant to achieve? Send a bitcoin to an address? View a block?
HTML5 started off well, but is beginning to morph into a cargo cult of 'cool': the return of mystery navigation, "swipe to navigate", many others.
- gbaygon 14y agoAccording to the link in the comment: "The purpose of this URI scheme is to enable users to easily make payments by simply clicking links on webpages or scanning QR Codes." Source: https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/BIP_0021 https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/BIP_0021
- drewblaisdell 14y agoYou have given reasons that support the idea that this is arbitrary, but why is it horrible?
- justincormack 14y agoAre we going to have to whitelist every currency that will exist in the future? At least have a pay: schema so you do pay:bitcoin.com/... or something.
- SkyMarshal 14y agoExactly. Needs another layer of abstraction to handle competing crypto currencies. BTC was the first, but won't be the last.
- pjscott 14y agoSomething analogous to the way magnet URIs are used as an extensible scheme for peer-to-peer filesharing links? http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magnet_URI_scheme http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magnet_URI_scheme
- byroot 14y agoMost scheme designate a protocol not a action. Do you suggest that we should have the same scheme for HTTP and HTTPS because in the end both return you a resource ? Same for ssh: and telnet:, same for xmpp:, msnim:, facetime:, irc:, skype:, etc ?
- threeseed 14y agoWhy stop at currencies ? Are we now going to have evernote, dropbox, flickr etc ?
- munimkazia 14y agoNo. Evernote, dropbox and flickr are all services implemented by a single organization each. You could just to use HTTP to link to a flickr profile. Bitcoin is decentralized. It is like a protocol. Each user can have his wallet stored in a different service, or even in his computer. The spec allows a wallet service or an application to add itself as a handler for bitcoin: links. Similar to mailto:, the user can choose the application which can listen to those links. It could be gmail, or thunderbird, or outlook.
- justincormack 14y agoIts like a protocol but if it was a protocol it could be used by different currencies. Just because it is distributed does not mean it cannot have a URI to identify some metadata about the currency being used.
- TazeTSchnitzel 14y ago> Its like a protocol but if it was a protocol it could be used by different currencies. Um, it is.
- munimkazia 14y agoMy point is.. you can have any application or service to handle bitcoin address clicks. You can choose to open your wallet service on any website, or an application which manages your bitcoins stored in your hard disk. It isn't a HTTP link, and there isn't some central web service to transfer bitcoins.
- FireBeyond 14y agopaypal:// ... googlecheckout:// ... etc://
- munimkazia 14y agoBoth paypal and googlecheckout are implemented in one way. It is not a protocol. Only the service's website can handle the request for payment in those currencies. Bitcoin is decentralized. The user can install/associate any service/application to send bitcoins, much like emails using mailto:
- icebraining 14y agoAre we going to have to whitelist every currency that will exist in the future? Why not?
- bpierre 14y agobitcoin is not the first whitelisted scheme [1], we already have irc, geo, mailto, magnet, mms, news, nntp, sip, sms, smsto, ssh, tel, urn, webcal, xmpp. [1] http://svn.whatwg.org/webapps/index#whitelisted-scheme http://svn.whatwg.org/webapps/index#whitelisted-scheme
- Geee 14y agoClicking the link just opens the client which handles it any way it wishes. However, the Bitcoin URI scheme is documented pretty well already: https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/URI_Scheme https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/URI_Scheme