3 ms·
How is that different from not taking that money from consumers (or investors) in the first place? If a consumer gives Apple $1 to hold for N months before App
by ajross 14y ago
How is that different from not taking that money from consumers (or investors) in the first place? If a consumer gives Apple $1 to hold for N months before Apple hands it over to a shareholder, that is clearly less effective than the consumer simply giving that dollar to the investor in the first place (e.g. by dropping it in the stock market).
I'm not saying that "Apple doesn't deserve its profits". I'm saying that past a certain point, the marginal value to society of huge profits drops to zero, and that Apple is past that point.
- snowwrestler 14y agoI don't see why the marginal value of profits drops to zero. Profits fund bets on the future. The bigger the profits, the bigger the bets that can be made.
- MichaelApproved 14y ago"the marginal value to society of huge profits drops to zero, and that Apple is past that point" It wasn't a discussion about value to society. It was discussion about too much money being a bad thing for Apple, which I disputed.
- twoodfin 14y agoThey're giving that $1 to the investor who was smart enough to invest in AAPL, which produced a product that was sufficiently valuable to consumers that it could demand such margins. The theory is that investor will be more likely to make such smart investments in the future.