9 ms·
Bloomberg Says Interpretation of Constitution Will ‘Have to Change’ After Boston
- Vivtek 14y ago"We know there are people who want to take away our freedoms." How these people's heads don't explode is just beyond me. He has to be aware of what he's saying. Right?
- masklinn 14y ago> He has to be aware of what he's saying. Right? Probably.
- scarmig 14y agoIt's a strong rhetorical strategy. Pre-emptively accuse your opponents of being enemies of liberty. Then all they can say is... "well no you're the real enemy of liberty!" Which is much weaker than the original argument, facts be damned.
- baddox 14y ago> “The people who are worried about privacy have a legitimate worry,” Mr. Bloomberg said during a press conference in Midtown. “But we live in a complex word where you’re going to have to have a level of security greater than you did back in the olden days, if you will. And our laws and our interpretation of the Constitution, I think, have to change.” Poe's law for politics.
- AUmrysh 14y agoI can't conceive of a way that 'reinterpreting' the constitution is going to give us more freedom. If he and his police force can't do their job of protecting the public, maybe they need to rethink their tactics instead of trying to force us to give up our rights to make their job easier. Is it even about making their jobs easier, though?
- tkahn6 14y agoJust because this sentiment has become a self-parody in many circles, it does not mean that Bloomberg doesn't earnestly believe it. And it doesn't mean that it is invalid. The ideological basis for a lot of Islamist terrorism is Qutbism which is quite regressive: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Qutbism#Qutbism_and_non-Muslims http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Qutbism#Qutbism_and_non-Muslims
- sageikosa 14y agoHe's referring to freedoms to choose Verizon, Sprint or AT&T; to go with iPhone, Android, or even Windows Phone (for those odd fanatics); to pick a foreign or domestic hybrid vehicle; to choose Democans or Republicrats; and maybe the freedom to move to a new school district to get a better education (until the Department of Education takes them all over anyway).
- buro9 14y agoI had to check twice that I wasn't reading the Onion.
- emeraldd 14y ago"They that can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety, deserve neither liberty nor safety." --Benjamin Franklin
- ceejayoz 14y ago"Essential", of course, being left up to interpretation again.
- kiba 14y agoTerrorists are a threat to peace and security, but they can never be a threat to our freedom. Only the citizens and or the government can pose such a threat.
- jkldotio 14y agoThis is the person who subscribes to the nudge politics of micromanaging people's soft drink sizes.[1] Which comes from the same type of political theorists (Cass Sunstein chief among them) who believe it is a reasonable proposition to have a US version of China's paid political propagandists.[2][3] Only to be used for good though, obviously. So one can easily imagine when people get their hands on all this data, only to protect you from the terrorists at first, the argument will be swiftly made that it should be used for nudge purposes as well, seeing as we have the data now.. [1]http://www.amazon.com/Nudge-Improving-Decisions-Health-Happiness/dp/014311526X http://www.amazon.com/Nudge-Improving-Decisions-Health-Happi... [2]http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cass_Sunstein#.22Conspiracy_Theories.22_and_government_infiltration http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cass_Sunstein#.22Conspiracy_The... [3]http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/50_Cent_Party http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/50_Cent_Party
- EvilTerran 14y agoI know "ad hominem!" is oft-abused on the internet, but this is a bona fide example for a change. Two examples, in fact. "Don't listen to what this guy's saying, he believes in nudge politics. Don't listen to nudge politics, the people who came up with it like China-style propaganda." From the other comments here, there's plenty of legitimate points against his arguments. There's no need to resort to cheap shots.
- FD3SA 14y agoI'm not much of a conspiracy theorist, but articles like this really make me double check that I'm not living in the Truman Show. “Well, Doctor, what have we got—a Republic or a Monarchy?” “A Republic, if you can keep it.”
- cpursley 14y agoI hope not. People actually questioned me in my local dinner just a few hours ago because I had a backpack on. I basically told them that the terrorists won if that was their attitude. Has anyone else experienced similar, or is this just an ass-backwards deep-south thang?
- cpursley 14y agoMy god, America has lost it's collective sanity: https://news.google.com/news?q=backpack&btnG=Search+News https://news.google.com/news?q=backpack&btnG=Search+News
- chiph 14y ago"I'll show you what's in my backpack, but you're going to have to pay for the dinner you interrupted with your panicky request."
- cpursley 14y agoI thought about saying "you have a 30 second head start" but maybe it was too soon and now with the Patriot Act and all...
- sageikosa 14y agoRolling bags hold more. Backpacks are for people that like to go hands free in urban environments. Single shoulder bags are impossible to run or kick with.
- voidlogic 14y ago"We know there are people who want to take away our freedoms." The terrorists want my life; its the government that wants my freedom. I'll keep my freedom, thank you, and take my chances with my life. My chance of being injured by terrorism is infinitesimal compared to the very real chance of losing civil rights and privacy I value. As Patrick Henry said: "Give me Liberty, or Give me Death!"
- RyanMcGreal 14y agoQuibble: the terrorists don't want your life, they want your attention, and more specifically, your panicky attention. Political reactions like Bloomberg's help keep the terrorism availability cascade rolling. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Availability_cascade http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Availability_cascade They are just about exactly the wrong way to respond. There are a few important facts about terrorism that should put our fear in context: * Terrorists tend to be spectacularly inept. * Terrorist organizations tend to collapse over time, through various combinations of frustration, attrition and overreach. * The methods of terrorism tend to be highly ineffective at killing people. On the same day that the Boston bombings killed three people, approximately 40 Americans country-wide were murdered for various non-terrorist reasons. Also on the same day, approximately 140 Americans died via guns (this includes suicides, which make up two-thirds of the total, and accidental deaths). We can keep going: for example, approximately 85 Americans are killed every day in automobile accidents. My point is that the fear that we feel about terrorism is utterly disproportionate to the risk that we will experience it - especially compared to the kinds of things we rarely think about but really should worry about. By no means do I mean to dismiss or demean or make light of the trauma, injury and death experienced by the people who experienced the Boston Marathon terror attack. However, it would only compound the tragedy if we allow such an event to transform our civilization from one that esteems liberty, autonomy and privacy into one that sacrifices those things for needless expedience.
- voidlogic 14y ago>>Quibble: the terrorists don't want your life, they want your attention, and more specifically, your panicky attention. Silly quibble- same difference, there are few things better for getting "panicky attention" than randomly taking lives or maiming people. I agree with your other points.
- fusiongyro 14y agoThe world we live in today is a tiny fraction as dangerous as the world the authors of the Constitution lived in. I'm not so naive as to believe that it is a perfect document or that any particular political group we have today has the "right" understanding of it, but please. Of all the possible reasons to attack it, this is by far the weakest.
- stox 14y agoOnly cowards will sacrifice freedom for security.
- jdherman 14y agoCrazy. The lesson here has been that you can't protect against attacks like this. No matter how much surveillance and firepower you have, if someone really wants to commit violence, they're going to do it (especially if they don't care what happens to them afterwards). Adding more cameras might make it easier to find the attacker after the fact, but it's not going to prevent the attack in the first place.
- mindcrime 14y agoBreaking News: "HN User 'mindcrime' Says Mayor Bloomberg Is A F%@#ng Idiot" Seriously, what is the deal with this guy? The terrorists kill FAR, FAR fewer people in this country every year than lightning strikes, slips & falls in the bathroom, accidental drownings in one's own swimming pool, automobile accidents, cancer, heart disease, etc., etc., etc. But because of a few anomalous events, as tragic as they may be, we're supposed to compromise the most basic, fundamental principles that define us as a nation? I don't think so. Anyway, our government is far more of a threat to our freedom than any terrorist organization will be.
- grecy 14y ago> we're supposed to compromise the most basic, fundamental principles that define us as a nation? It's time to admit they are no longer the basic, fundamental principles that define the nation, as they are continually being changed or taken away (i.e. Patriot Act)
- nwzpaperman 14y agoAn Internet tax will just make everyone a tax evader...everyone knows it won't help the economy!
- IanDrake 14y agoWhen a gun is used to kill people he wants to ban guns. Strangely, he's not proposing a ban on pressure cookers. Government will use fear to slowly strip us of our rights. Why? Because it works really well. He has already made the leap to assume we "Interpret" the US Constitution. It's a pretty clear document that needs little interpretation. We're supposed to amend it, not change are mind on what they really meant.
- astrodust 14y agoWhen the number of deaths by pressure cookers exceeds the number of death by guns, maybe then.
- mrcactu5 14y agoBloomberg bought himself a 3rd term in New York City. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Government_of_New_York_City#Term_limits_and_campaign_finance http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Government_of_New_York_City#Ter... Maybe he can afford to modify the Constitution.
- Torgo 14y agoFrom stop and frisk of minority groups, to pervasive police surveillance of Muslims, to police harassment of the Occupy Wall Street protests, it is already clear that Michael Bloomberg has had disagreements with the Constitution.
- pnathan 14y agoYou don't mention the endemic camera network in NYC. Or the asine soda ban....
- Lagged2Death 14y agoThe Boston bombers had already caught the attention of several tentacles of our unconstitutional surveillance state. We have already changed our interpretation of the constitution in the pursuit of an unattainable sliver of additional security and, as predicted by just about every qualified observer, it is not working. What on Earth does he propose to do that we haven't already done, anyway? Strip search stations on every street corner?
- eplanit 14y ago"What on Earth does he propose to do that we haven't already done, anyway? Strip search stations on every street corner?" Don't give him any more ideas. Be it sodium, sugar, tobacco, or terrorists, Mr. Bloomberg's first response is always the same: limit freedom.
- astrodust 14y agoMaybe each and every citizen can be forced to reside in a steel cage.
- Zimahl 14y agoWell, until the people of New York stand up against him and vote him out they deserve what they get. They seem to really enjoy a nanny state that even restricts what they can drink. You can't by a 32 oz. Coke but you can buy a jug of vodka.
- mtalantikite 14y agoThe soda ban was invalidated, but the city is trying to appeal that ruling: http://www.nytimes.com/2013/03/12/nyregion/judge-invalidates-bloombergs-soda-ban.html http://www.nytimes.com/2013/03/12/nyregion/judge-invalidates... Also, Bloomberg is still in office because he was able to change the term limits, which New Yorkers were against. It's hard to beat a politician with a personal net worth of $27 billion.
- nickff 14y agoThere doesn't seem to be much evidence to support the view that personal wealth can be used to 'buy' an election, or even substantially improve one's results: http://www.freakonomics.com/2012/01/17/how-much-does-campaign-spending-influence-the-election-a-freakonomics-quorum/ http://www.freakonomics.com/2012/01/17/how-much-does-campaig... personal note: I do not support the abolition of term limits or the imposition of soda taxes; but I do not think he is in power simply because he is wealthy.
- jelled 14y agoStatements such as Bloomberg's always remind me of this: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=75oun5gvDAU#t=6m19s http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=75oun5gvDAU#t=6m19s
- bayesianhorse 14y agoInterpretation of the American constitution should have changed a long time before. The US way of choosing a president for example still presupposes people travelling up and down the east cost with horses...
- ttrreeww 14y agoIt's over folks, they won.
- lutusp 14y ago“Look, we live in a very dangerous world. We know there are people who want to take away our freedoms ..." So sayeth Mayor Bloomberg, in the midst of a speech that explicitly proposes taking away another of our freedoms.
- ataggart 14y agoTo me, the far more interesting thing is how he lets the mask slip regarding the Constitution itself, namely that they are not bound to go through the amendment process, nor even the judicial facade of interpreting how to apply the Constitution to some new circumstance. Instead, he shines a light on what has long been true, that the Constitution means whatever some small but critical mass of powerful people say it means, and the common people will accept it as true. Lysander Spooner had it right 150 years ago: "[T]he Constitution is no such instrument as it has generally been assumed to be; but that by false interpretations, and naked usurpations, the government has been made in practice a very widely, and almost wholly, different thing from what the Constitution itself purports to authorize. ... But whether the Constitution really be one thing, or another, this much is certain --- that it has either authorized such a government as we have had, or has been powerless to prevent it. In either case, it is unfit to exist." http://lysanderspooner.org/node/64 http://lysanderspooner.org/node/64
- ceejayoz 14y agoI'd say this is at least in part a side effect of a) vague wording ("general welfare") and b) unanticipated situations ("interstate commerce" between CA and NY in milliseconds).
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- ryguytilidie 14y agoAs most of the constitution seems pretty outdated nowadays, why does no one ever bring up the idea of writing a new one?
- yardie 14y agoBecause most of it seems to not be outdated. And going by recent events I think everyone is quite happy to keep it the way it is. When the politicians get an idea in their heads it usually screws over the average citizen. And the bigger the task you give them the worse they seem at actually accomplishing.
- dragonwriter 14y ago> As most of the constitution seems pretty outdated nowadays I would suggest that that sentiment is far from universal. It may seem outdated to you, but not to everyone else. > why does no one ever bring up the idea of writing a new one? The same reason people are generally better off making incremental changes to basically-functional mission-critical computing systems than tossing them out and starting from scratch.
- ryguytilidie 14y agoI guess the analogy you chose makes it sound like a bad idea, but I'd use a different one. If you have a 300 year old house with rotting boards and a foundation that is cracked, would you replace individual boards or tear down the whole thing and start anew?
- john_b 14y agoThis man is a case study in Statist ideology.
- justinbeaver 14y agoHaving personally attended numerous Bloomberg press conferences in NYC (through his affiliation with the local startup community), let me paint perhaps a more objective picture from which this article arose: This press conference likely had absolutely nothing to do with the Boston bombing. In fact, yesterday he was busy announcing a new ice skating facility in the Bronx. But using history as a guide, once the Q&A started, the media hounded him for quotes surrounding the Boston situation b/c stories about ice skating rinks are "boring". And then once the media got a couple quotes that fit their mold, they wove some story around it to meet their biased agenda. Simply strip out Bloomberg's quotes from the article here and see for yourselves: they're not all that incriminating. But read them in the context of the author's story, and whoa, watch out! We're about to lose all of our freedoms. Look - I get it. Some of the thing Bloomberg have done overstep the boundaries of what some consider reasonable. And having open discussion on this is totally warranted. But reading the comments here you would think those who view NYC from the outside think we live in some totalitarian state. Nothing could be further from the truth, in fact. The city remains largely liberal from a social standpoint (and Bloomberg seems to be no exception). And in terms of diversity - whether it be religion, ethnic background, interests, etc. - you're simply not going to find a better melting pot. So everybody please stop panicking for us - we're doing just fine. This is just some underpaid journo looking for a scoop and it seems she got more than a few clicks today courtesy of the alarmist HN crowd, so kudos to her. Now back to work.
- betterunix 14y ago"reading the comments here you would think those who view NYC from the outside think we live in some totalitarian state. Nothing could be further from the truth, in fact" I spent the first 18 years of my life in NYC. I still go back to visit family several times each year. I can tell you that the only place in America where people are less free than they are in NYC is at the airports. Here are some things to think about: 1. The NYPD is basically an army. Sure, you have officers who are only armed with a handgun, but every time I have visited NYC in the past few years I have encountered at least one paramilitary team. We are talking about soldiers whose uniforms say "POLICE" standing guard in the village, or Times Square, or in front of a bank in some uninteresting neighborhood. 2. I carry a small pocket knife. When I went to NYC with it, I was stopped by the police, threatened with 2 weeks in jail, and then politely told to hide the knife so that a less "friendly" officer would not arrest me. 3. I was given a $50 fine for walking between subway cars while a train was sitting in a station. 4. I watched as dozens of cops closed in around a handful of protesters. 5. I have had the police tell me that either they will inspect my bag or I will not be allowed to ride the subway. 6. Cameras are confiscated or damaged at the Ground Zero memorial. 7. Even hunting rifles are hard to get permission to own in NYC. 8. Stop and frisk -- need I say more? 9. http://www.dnainfo.com/new-york/20100505//bikes-confiscated-by-nypd-for-obamas-visit-still-being-sought-by-owners http://www.dnainfo.com/new-york/20100505//bikes-confiscated-... 10. http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/10/01/republican-national-convention-2004-arrest-nypd-nyc-lacked-probable-cause-judge_n_1930433.html http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/10/01/republican-national... Unfortunately, that is the city I have to move back to next year for a job. I am not particularly looking forward to it.
- nekojima 14y ago“Look, we live in a very dangerous world. We know there are people who want to take away our freedoms. New Yorkers probably know that as much if not more than anybody else after the terrible tragedy of 9/11,” Bloomberg said. The world is generally safer now than at almost any previous time, particularly for those of us that remember the Cold War and the early-mid 1980s, when even these measures weren't required to avoid mutually-assured destruction (MAD) by two super-powers and their proxies. The only people wanting to limit freedom are politicians in the pocket of those wanting to expand the myriad of security services of the state. This feeds into the projected paranoia of those citizens who fail to understand the true cost, chance, or opportunity of reducing terrorist activities. Of course there has to be an attempt to reduce terrorist activities, but its the internal processes and procedures in place currently between the myriad network of security services which need to be reformed drastically, not the further expansion of those security services or the reduction in freedoms. Terrorism is an issue of public security, while before 1991 the Soviet Union (for the Western world at least) was an issue of national security. Issues of public security need to be treated as such, not over-inflated and treated incorrectly. This helps support the terrorists, not defeat them, as has been shown in almost every internal urban civil conflict in the past hundred years.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- jarjoura 14y agoThis is the only source of this "press event"? I don't buy it.
- thoughtsimple 14y agoSince the shelter in place request was a request and wasn't enforced by any law, why do we have to re-interpret the Constitution? A better question might be, why is this nonsense on the front page of HN?
- fragsworth 14y agoThis might seem very controversial and "sexist", but I don't believe there's any "political conspiracy" involved at all - it's just political reality. This can almost all be attributed to a combination of 1: gender gap in voting, and 2: media misreporting of the facts - particularly mothers with children who are not made constantly aware of the statistics involved with these events. http://grounds-strategy.com/files/gender-and-voting.pdf http://grounds-strategy.com/files/gender-and-voting.pdf > after 9/11, women became much more concerned with national security issues. Today, a significant majority of women, 43 percent, versus 11 percent of men, believe that a member of their family could be affected by a terrorist attack. Note that 43% + 11% is more than half the population; only 3000 people died in 9/11. That's 0.001% actually affected. Public perception of terrorism more accurately reflects the outcome of a full-scale nuclear war. Mothers are extremely protective of their children (and this is not a bad thing) but when terrorism is reported in the news without also giving the context of the actual size of the event relative to the size of the population, it leads some people into a false sense of what risk their children really have. What the media outlets do, instead, is play into fears and make every attempt to keep these events as looking as scary as possible, because that's how they get ratings. Perhaps mothers with children are more apt to pay attention to this. What is also interesting, and people here should try to consider this every once in a while, is that the comments on this site are almost exclusively young males. Most without children. So you won't hear things here from the mother-with-child perspective, which is a massive voting block.
- flagnog 14y ago43% of women = 21.5% of total population, 11% of men = 5.5% of total population, so you're talking about approx 27% of the total population are concerned. Bad statistical reasoning is 150% of the problem here. ;)
- fragsworth 14y agoHah, whoops, that's slightly embarrassing. I think my point still stands though.