2 ms·
Note: The following is not original to me... Construction -- a car on an assembly line. When is a car first there? At what point in the assembly line would we
by shawndumas 14y ago
Note: The following is not original to me...
Construction -- a car on an assembly line. When is a car first there? At what point in the assembly line would we first say, “There’s a car”? Some of us would no doubt go with appearance, saying that there is a car as soon as the body is fairly complete. I suppose that most of us would look for something functional. We would say that there is a car only after a motor is in place. And a few might say, “It’s not a car until it rolls out onto the street”. There would be many differing opinions.
Development -- a Polaroid picture that is unique and valuable; let’s say a picture of a hitherto unknown species darting out from the jungle. You’ve snapped the shot and the camera is noisily pushing out the developing photo. The animal has now disappeared, and so you are never going to get that picture again. You pull the tab out and as you are waiting for it to develop, I grab it away from you and rip it open, thus destroying it. When you get really angry at me, I just say blithely, “You’re crazy. That was just a gray smudge. I cannot fathom why anyone would care about gray smudges.” Wouldn’t you think that I was the insane one? Your photo was already there. We just couldn’t see it yet.