3 ms·
> If an adult dog is smarter than a newborn, why the disparity in legal protection? Because, like it or not, us humans rule the world, so we get to make the ru
by skrebbel 14y ago
> If an adult dog is smarter than a newborn, why the disparity in legal protection?
Because, like it or not, us humans rule the world, so we get to make the rules. And we chose to protect our kind better than others.
- waps 14y agoThen why do we abort so many more babies than dogs ? While foetuses obviously don't have optical processing (you know, no eyes and all), the brain actually "boots up" on the 18th day after conception. So just before/just after a woman will start to suspect she's pregnant, there's an brain actively processing information in her womb. If we took that as the standard, you know, that'd be more conservative than any religious grouping even asks for. (the reason for this is that a human foetus "is not human". Our DNA is only human in that it contains a set of instructions that will transform an ape foetus into a human foetus. But the ape foetus isn't grown from scratch either, it's grown from some four legged animal. Basically the first recognizable animal you start out as is a bilobite (which is extinct, it's essentially a hollow ball of cells), grow into a trilobite (a 2-part ball of cells), grow into something that looks a lot like a tadpole, grow into ... and a tadpole requires a functioning brain, and so a human foetus at that development stage has a functioning brain) The point is we don't protect life at all. We protect ways to make the life of the decision makers (which are nearly all adult humans) easier/more enjoyable. Kids, dogs and abortion are merely parts of that, as is freely killing dogs, intelligent or otherwise. Really the reason we don't kill kids is because humans would rebel. You can try to explain the problem, like stating that a kid, even a small one represents a massive investment of time, money, sweat, and (I'm sure any mother will be glad to remind you) inconvenience and pain, and I'm sure that's a rather good explanation. But in the end it comes down to adult, mostly male, humans vetoing it. We support abortion because it's a way to vastly limit that investment and get rid of both "the product" and the investment (and, frankly, because without abortion anything remotely resembling today's nightlife would be completely out of the question). So really "us humans" don't rule the world. Too bad, not really. A small number of adult, mostly but not all male humans rule the world.
- robbiep 14y agoDo you really think more human foetuses are aborted than dog? I'm a medical student and never seen an abortion performed (even though I know they're commonly performed), however I grew up in a country area and know dozens of stories of people who have drowned puppies or kittens (whole litters) because they were not wanted. Way more stories than the 1:3-1:4 females that supposedly have abortions during their lives. Anyway it's an anecdote so doesn't mean anything really. I am more interested in where you heard that the brain 'boots up' on day 18. The neural tube doesn't close until day 23-27, and until quite some time after this point the 'nervous system' is essentially a hollow tube of neurons only a few layers thick, that doesn't contain the identifiable layers of cortex. In fact it isn't until week 4 that there is proliferation of the layers resulting in an alar and basal plate (representing sensory and motor neuronal pathways respectively) and it is not until after this differentiation that the neural tube begins to divide into the 3 vesicle and 5 vesicle stages- the 5 vesicle stage being essential for the differentiation into what will eventually be cortex and various regions etc. Even if there is neural activity at such a young stage, you just have spontaneous depolarisations of action potential, not any information processing
- waps 14y agoGiven the figures (1 in 50 women has an abortion, per year, CDC figures), yes, I would find it very hard to believe that humans killed more dogs (whether in North America or the world) than they abort human fetuses. I doubt vets put down 1 dog per 200 people per year. The shape of the container of the neurons does not really influence whether they fire or not. 18 days is simply the earliest that I've seen neural activity reported (actual firing neurons, after receiving signals). It's actually more of a "at the latest" figure, not a lower bound. There is no even a compelling theory going either way as to whether these signals are random (I assume that's what you mean by "spontaneous depolarisations of action potential", otherwise it'd make no sense : that happens in fetuses, you and me, and granddads. For that matter, it happens in corpses weeks after death. They are neither an indication of consciousness, nor an indicator of it's absence). Given how neural cells work, and that there are actual living animals that have shapes very similar to fetuses in this stage of development whose movements are definitely not random, my guess would be that these signals are anything but random. I would even say that it's extremely likely that these neurons are capable of sensing their environment in some way and attempting to come to grips with it, because in the animals they are. Here's a picture of the human embryo at 18(-21) days after conception : http://mybrainnotes.com/human-embryo-brain.jpg http://mybrainnotes.com/human-embryo-brain.jpg Is it really so hard to believe that an animal that complex has functioning senses and a working brain, and is contemplating, maybe not it's existence, but definitely it's environment ?