Another 3 cheers for HN! Obviously, this place is full of PG worshippers. Therefore, the fact that this article made the front page, while disagreeing with PG,

Another 3 cheers for HN! Obviously, this place is full of PG worshippers. Therefore, the fact that this article made the front page, while disagreeing with PG, suggests that lots of people vote up based on thought-provoking-ness, not on agreement. And if so, that's cool. :-)