4 ms·
This analysis is pretty generic...I'm not sure what real insight it offers specific to Tumblr. One of the things it doesn't go into detail is the actual user-to
by danso 14y ago
This analysis is pretty generic...I'm not sure what real insight it offers specific to Tumblr. One of the things it doesn't go into detail is the actual user-to-user interaction...which is extremely limited. I've been using Tumblr for years and I still don't know how to directly comment on someone's content without reblogging it...or how to reply to someone else who has commented on my content.
Also, the OP doesn't touch on the most unique part of Tumblr, which is its not-quite-a-blog but more-than-a-tweet niche. Its format is very limited...you have several types of posts to choose from (photo, quote, text, video) and when you pick a format, you are stuck to a rigid form...for photos, you enter a caption and upload a photo (or photoset)...and that's it. You can hack around the constraints but it is difficult...and yet, this ends up making tumblr more inviting, because of the lack of setup involved. Constraints are freedom, sometimes.
- k-mcgrady 14y ago>> "I've been using Tumblr for years and I still don't know how to directly comment on someone's content without reblogging it" I think reblogging doubles as a commenting system. If you look at the original version of the post you reblogged it will show that you reblogged it with your added commentary. Most themes also make it easy to add Disqus just by adding your Disqus site name. There is also the 'ask' feature which allows for more direct user interaction, and I believe there is an option on one of the post types to pose it as a question and allow users to respond.
- danso 14y agoYes, but disqus isn't easily accessible from the dashboard, and most of my followers seem to just see my posts from the dashboard...and of course, if someone reblogs the post, disqus (from my end) won't caper any feedback, It's a pretty stilted system for feedback...but maybe it's by design, that tumblr is more about just sharing and disseminating content. At least that's been my perspective
- JulianMorrison 14y agoReblogging is commenting - and it makes your blog an entry point into the conversation, and gives it a more public and permanent home than a comment thread on somebody else's blog.
- danso 14y agoRight...but I don't want to fill my blog with someone else's content just to comment on it...also, I don't think there's a way to comment on my own post, because it is technically reblogging my own post, which seems to be blocked. I may be missing the obvious reply feature here...but it's never been intuitive, which is exacerbated by the different interfaces presented by the dashboard and blog interface...not saying this is necessary a bad feature of Tumblr, but it's definitely an important quirk
- JulianMorrison 14y agoYou're not missing anything obvious. "Can't reblog yourself" is a typically tumblr annoying quirk. But you can reblog to reply in-thread to another person's reply. Tumblr teaches you to not care so much about what's on your blog as you would if it was a wordpress or something. Reblog away, everyone else is.
- omnivore 14y agoJust download Missing E or XKit. Both enable you to reblog yourself. XKit seems to have done a better job of keeping up with the tumblr changes, but I used Missing E for a while. Both get the job done.
- pwillia7 14y agoIf you select the text option though, you're free to add html if you click the <html> button. Also, while it can be limited in themes, you have full control over the HTML and CSS, so really there's not much you couldn't do that you would need to for a simple blog.