2 ms·
Another way to think of this: It's alright if you've brought the toys, and you feel the rules to play should be a certain way. It's also alright if you insist o
by stcredzero 14y ago
Another way to think of this: It's alright if you've brought the toys, and you feel the rules to play should be a certain way. It's also alright if you insist on those rules and decide to take your toys home if you don't get to play by those rules. This is pretty much what the GPL is. When it gets obnoxious, is when people start saying that you're "evil" for not using your favorite rules. That's possible, particularly when the complexity of the real world brings pragmatism into play, but it is a bit of an extraordinary claim, especially when put in absolutist terms.
That would be like saying that you're "evil" for playing any kind of ball game without a helmet. This could be a highly beneficial and pragmatic thing in one context (professional baseball) but just silly and obnoxious in another. (Sandlot game with a wiffle ball.)
Stallman and the FSF make the claim that there is a new set of human rights concerning software that we weren't aware of before. That is the crux of the matter. Is it enough to let everything play out "in the marketplace" and let people vote with their dollars and their feet, or is there a new set of rights that should be enshrined in law?
I do think Stallman has a point, and that much good has come of copyleft and activism by the FSF, but does this give someone a right to declare what is absolutely good and evil? I don't think so.