5 ms·
To be honest, I find the UK law to be absolutely stupid in this regard. I needed to buy 10 packs of paracetamol, and at local morrisons I was told I couldn't, m
by gambiting 14y ago
To be honest, I find the UK law to be absolutely stupid in this regard. I needed to buy 10 packs of paracetamol, and at local morrisons I was told I couldn't, maximum was 2 packs(16 tablets each). So I bought two packs, went out of the store, came back in, bought another two, repeated the process 5x and got my ten packs. The whole law is just an annoyance, nothing else. If I wanted to kill myself with paracetamol I could easily get even a 1000 tablets, would just need to drive around a few supermarkets but this law would not stop me from doing it.
- Osmium 14y ago> The whole law is just an annoyance, nothing else. This is not true. It's about preventing impulsive suicides, not premeditated ones. If a depressed person is having an episode and all they have in their house is 16 pills, then it removes the opportunity: maybe by the time they've make it to the shops and buy more, the moment will have passed, and a life would be saved. It's been shown time and time again that you can reduce absolute suicide rates by removing opportunities like this. If I remember correctly, there was something similar involving gas ovens, though I can't find the reference now. Guns, bridges, etc. are all similar too. When it comes down to it, if someone's determined enough to kill themselves, they will, but the truth is most people aren't and doing things like only selling small quantities of pills really can prevent suicides.
- DanBC 14y agoStrongly agree with your post. About gas ovens: There's less carbon monoxide in modern gas delivery. (http://io9.com/5959303/why-have-people-stopped-committing-suicide-with-gas http://io9.com/5959303/why-have-people-stopped-committing-su...)
- Osmium 14y agoThanks! That was the one I was thinking of. >The switch from coal gas to natural gas also had one unexpected effect. During the ‘50s and ‘60s, about half of the suicides in Britain were by coal gas. By the ‘70s, when the transition to natural gas was complete, the number of gas suicides had dropped to zero and the overall suicide rate was down a third. Even the suicidal appreciate convenience. If it's too much trouble, as Dorothy Parker said, "You might as well live." Also, regarding my above post (which I can't edit now), I didn't mean to imply that "just" 16 pills was even remotely safe because I'm sure it's not (I'm not a doctor) but the general point stands...
- hnriot 14y agoRather, it's just another example of the uk becoming more and more of a nanny state.
- lucian303 14y agoOf course, there is no limit to the amount of alcohol one can purchase to lower one's threshold for going from suicidal thought to suicidal action. "Impulsivity and aggression are strongly implicated in suicidal behaviour.18–22 Impulsivity has been related to suicidal and self-destructive behaviours within different psychiatric conditions, including alcohol and substance use disorders, mood disorders, conduct disorder, impulse control disorder, antisocial personality disorder, and borderline personality disorder. Studies have consistently demonstrated that constructs related to aggression and impulsivity confer additional risk for suicidal behaviour among persons with alcohol dependence and other substance misusers.22" -- http://qjmed.oxfordjournals.org/content/99/1/57.full http://qjmed.oxfordjournals.org/content/99/1/57.full Obviously alcohol causes both impulsivity and aggression. Not to mention, the negative health effects and deaths that are _directly_ attributable to it, but that's a different topic. The reality is, no government actually cares about preventing suicide or decreasing mental illness / increasing mental health. If they did, they would focus more on treating people who are at risk of it rather than putting people on medicines that are known to increase the risk of suicide (opiates, benzodiazepines, SSRI's, SSNRI's, amphetamine (commonly in Adderrall and prescribed to young children for medical conditions (ADD, ADHD) that don't exist), etc. These laws are not just an inconvenience, they serve a real purpose: to make legislators feel good about themselves and to make the people think the legislators are actually working. The former is self deception, the latter treason (at least as practiced here in the US). Addiction is a very easy way to control the population and a method of control employed by governments everywhere, led by the policies of the US. Get them addicted, committed, misinformed, unarmed, and controlled. The new opium wars are civil, use both legal (rx or otc) and illegal drugs as their ammunition, yet are still carefully perpetrated by the governments, and in the last hundred years plus, upon their own people. Yes, we have learned a lot from history. Just enough to repeat its atrocities.
- robbiep 14y agoBBC article following reductions in successful suicides (interestingly it says no reduction in number of overdoses. But we have a pretty good reversal for paracetamol-induced overdose - N-acetyl-Cystine - so they should have a pretty good recovery) http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-21370910 http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-21370910
- DanBC 14y agoYes, but it's very important that anyone with an overdose gets treatment as soon as possible, even if they feel no ill effects at that time. Death from paracetamol overdose is by liver failure, and that takes a week or so to happen, but after the first 24 hours there's not much you can do to prevent it apart from liver transplant. Paracetamol overdose is a small number of liver transplants in the UK, but a significant number of the 'super urgent' transplants.
- coolj 14y ago> Despite the reduction in deaths from paracetamol, the study found there had been no decline in overdose cases after 1998. Is the attempted-suicide overdose rate in decline? That seems to be the main question as to whether the law helped.
- Someone 14y agoFirstly, I have trouble thinking of situations where one would need to buy 10 packs of paracetamol. Care to elaborate? Secondly, one cannot prevent one from committing suicide, but making it harder will give people time to reconsider their planned suicide.
- gambiting 14y agoMy dad lives in a really remote region and doesn't go out much, so he asked me to buy like a yearly supply of paracetamol for him(along with a trunk full of food). What I did not expect, was that it's going to be such an annoying problem. As I said, I did buy what I wanted, except that it took me 10 minutes instead of 2. If you want to make it hard for people,just make every medicine prescription-only.
- zoul 14y agoLaws are usually a compromise. I would say that preventing some suicides at the expense of forcing you to spend ten minutes to buy a year’s worth of painkillers is a very decent compromise.
- mike-cardwell 14y agoReally remote region... In the UK...? Does such a thing exist?
- switch007 14y agoIt's all relative. The UK does include some remote isles of Scotland such as Shetland, however, with up to 10 flights a day, it may not be considered too remote in regards to access to supplies! There are very few places that come close to feeling remote, certainly. And it's only getting more crowded =/
- Someone 14y agoI can understand that, especially given the "my dad" part. For all we know, his dad is not allowed to drive a car and not the quickest on his foot anymore. "Really remote" is a relative thing. I still think that 10 packs of Paracetamol, if I had them in my home, would last me not for a year, but easily for the rest of my life. But maybe I am still too young and healthy to judge that. Oh, and I guess you can get really remote in the UK. There's plenty of remote islands (with affordable housing: http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=4866217 http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=4866217)
- andrewcooke 14y agoconfused old people die from paracetamol overdoses. this helps reduce that, afaik (no evidence to hand, but read up on painkillers not long ago as i needed to take them over a fairly long period). and given that you could work around it easily, it seems that the cost to others is not so high...
- flatline 14y agoMy mom has Alzheimer's, and recently started hallucinating. After several (!) trips to the ER and doctor, someone finally thought to do a blood test, and found that she had a severe sodium|potassium deficiency (now I don't remember which). Turns out she was thirsty due to the dry climate and it being winter, and she kept drinking water, forgetting that she had just finished a glass, which led to the mineral deficiency, which caused the hallucinations. I can't imagine how hard it would to control be if she was taking painkillers on an as-needed basis for a long time. People with dementia are often surprisingly clever and resourceful, considering the disease.
- Evbn 14y agoDementia is a bug in the program. The program is powerful, and the bug is a small change that makes it powerfully wrong. It is amazing that someone could drink that much water, without a restroom bream or just not feeling thirsty anymore. But I can imagine overdrinking over a course of days in response to feeling dryness, and not realizing that she is overdoing it.
- coolestuk 14y agoThe UK law is stupid. My sister took her life using paracetamol. She just drove to 3 different pharmacies and bought the max amount at each. She also bought sleeping tablets so that the pain of her dying liver would not wake her. A few days before this, my family had tried to have her sectioned as mentally ill (she was suicidal from post-natal depression). They psychiatrists kept her in for observation for 48 hours, then released her. 24 hours later she was dead, and her child an orphan. All the law did was slow her down for maybe 15 minutes in her suicide attempt.
- switch007 14y agoThat's awfully tragic and I'm very sorry for your loss. :(
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- salvadors 14y agoNo law can prevent all such tragedies. But failing to have prevented this one doesn't make the law stupid, or worthless. It does successfully prevent other cases. What happened with your sister is certainly horrible, but you can't generalise from that to every case.
- vacri 14y agoWould you also say murder laws are stupid because they only reduce the incidence of murder, not eliminate it? Of course these laws aren't going to stop a planned suicide, but they will prevent spur-of-the-moment ones that use this method, of which there are plenty. I'm sorry for your loss, but the answer isn't railing against measures which may help others.