5 ms·
Its not really the advertising that is a problem. That is the symptom of the short time frame most drugs need to pay for themselves. Quite a lot of them only
by protomyth 14y ago
Its not really the advertising that is a problem. That is the symptom of the short time frame most drugs need to pay for themselves. Quite a lot of them only have 3 - 5 years to make the money back.
So, either we figure out a way to make drugs cost less or we extend the timeframe for profit. Killing the advertising just means the number sold will be less and much higher for those buying it.
- wpietri 14y agoIf they are doing studies to generate marketing claims, then advertising has to be part of the problem, in that it's a major vector for marketing claims. There could be other vectors, and I would be happy to eliminate those as well. The total amount of money spent on pharmaceutical marketing is enormous. We would be much better served if doctors could pay for subscriptions to research companies that only take money from doctors.
- protomyth 14y agoThey are doing studies to find drugs that treat a condition. If a drug looks like it can treat something new, then they do another study. They are required to report side effects (that "may cause..." in ever advertisement) found in the study. "We would be much better served if doctors could pay for subscriptions to research companies that only take money from doctors." For what purpose? If your thinking a Forrester or Gartner model, then given how bad those companies advice has been in IT, I can only imagine what would happen in medicine.
- richardlblair 14y ago"Its not really the advertising that is a problem. " Read this book: http://www.amazon.com/Selling-Sickness-Pharmaceutical-Companies-Patients/dp/156025856X http://www.amazon.com/Selling-Sickness-Pharmaceutical-Compan... It is an advertising problem. Big pharma makes massive profits, so you can't cite profits as a source of justification for advertising drugs to people who don't need them. Maybe you should have taken 30 seconds to google GSK's profits last year, or AstraZeneca who had a bad year last year but still make 2 BILLION dollars. It goes beyond selling drugs to people who don't need them though, they over exaggerate and create new attractive names for illnesses. "Social Anxiety", for example, is not a thing. It's actually called "Social Phobia". A research study showed that marketing "Social Anxiety" yielded a more positive result, so big pharma called it just that. I'll leave you to figure out how much big pharma made off of that little stunt.
- refurb 14y agoTwo billion dollars on how much revenue? What are their capital investments? You have to remember pharma has laid off over 100,000 employees in the last few years due to a lack of new products. I know a lot of people don't like drug advertizing, but you do realize that it gets a lot of people to their doctors talking about their health right? And it's not like a patient can prescribe a drug for themselves, its the doctor who ultimately decides which treatment to pursue.
- richardlblair 14y ago"And it's not like a patient can prescribe a drug for themselves, its the doctor who ultimately decides which treatment to pursue." Clearly you don't know very many people in the health field. If a patient comes in asking for a specific medication, most doctors will just prescribe that medication assuming the person is suffering from the illness required for the medication. Where do they get the information for making a diagnosis? Don't worry, Big Pharma will host an info session or hand out pamphlets so that doctors know what to look for... It may be a conversation, but it's the wrong one. Big pharma is notorious for increasing the potential number of patients for an illness by putting out advertisements that widen the net for the given illness. Social Anxiety is great example here, as is ADD. 5% of children in the US are diagnosed with ADD, only 0.5% are diagnosed with ADD in france. The issue of ADD specifically goes beyond just advertisements; it speaks to the fact that drug reps have a real impact on the treatment options doctors present. In France if a child is having a tough time concentrating in school the find the root of the problem, in the US they throw meds at the kid and shove him out the door. The marketing strategies of big pharma are nothing but pure evil. Get people on more meds, to make more money next quarter.
- refurb 14y agoIf a doctor is prescribing a medication because the patient asked for it, the doctor isn't doing their job. I was talking to an oncologist the other day and he thought the patient education/advertising was great. Patients who would put off coming to him, make an appointment because a drug company made them aware that their symptoms may be a sign of a more serious disease. Also, he has patients coming to him saying "Hey, I just heard about this new cancer drug, is it the right one for me?" He thinks the more you can get patients involved in their own health, the better. Are there doctors who are too lazy to push back on a patient that demands a prescription? Of course. Look at how many patients with viral diseases get antibiotics. Are you going to blame the pharma companies for that as well?
- kumarski 14y agoHow much money is the real question? We don't know the full costs of researching and bringing a drug to market? I've never seen a study that outlines these costs in detail.
- protomyth 14y agoYou look at the financial statements of the drug company. They have shareholders and are required to file financial documents.
- kumarski 14y agoI have looked at the 10-K filings for many publicly traded pharmaceutical companies. They use creative accounting techniques that prevent true analysis of what it costs to bring a drug to market. The specific questions I want to answer are related to the following. For one therapeutic drug...... Labor? Machinery? Experimentation? LogisticS? While they are in the business of making pharmaceuticals, they have cloaked the actual costs with accounting practices.