4 ms·
But why buy meat at all? In terms of efficiency and "feeding the world" the cow lags behind quite seriously compared to that other GMO soya
by lifeisstillgood 14y ago
But why buy meat at all? In terms of efficiency and "feeding the world" the cow lags behind quite seriously compared to that other GMO soya
- tptacek 14y agoBeef is a particularly inefficient protein source.
- mschuster91 14y agoThe point is the taste and the fact that you can't nutritionally fully replace meat.
- tptacek 14y agoI'm talking about the production of beef, not its metabolic efficiency. There are meat products that are much more efficient than beef.
- mschuster91 14y agoAgreed, yet it will be difficult, if not outright impossible, to restructure US (and maybe Mexican) agriculture to raise e.g. pigs or chicken instead of cattle; also, each of these animal races carry their own individual risks - bird flu and "cannibalistic picking" (dunno the English term) in birds, and pig flu for pigs. The last food-animal-related health problems I heard of were multiple different bird and pig flu varieties, the last major problem with cattle was BSE/Jakob-Creutzfeld disaster years ago. So I think the cost of perfectly fine, but "preventively killed" animals should be weighed in, too.
- meepmorp 14y agoYou can't fully replace meat nutritionally? Any source for this assertion?
- mschuster91 14y agoAt least not in child nutrition, unfortunately the only usable reference which is not vegan propaganda I could find are in German (http://www.focus.de/gesundheit/ernaehrung/gesundessen/tid-21186/vegetarisch-leben-vegan-eignet-sich-nicht-fuer-kinder_aid_595804.html http://www.focus.de/gesundheit/ernaehrung/gesundessen/tid-21... and http://www.dge.de/modules.php?name=News&file=article&sid=1150 http://www.dge.de/modules.php?name=News&file=article&...). TL;DR: It is extremely difficult to sustain the needs of a child with a pure vegetarian/vegan diet.
- rosser 14y agoAnecdata, but I know a woman who's never, in her entire life, not been a vegetarian, and she's probably the healthiest person I've ever met. It's easier than you think.
- justin66 14y ago> TL;DR: It is extremely difficult to sustain the needs of a child with a pure vegetarian/vegan diet. Tripe. I think people forget that even with the naive diet pyramids a lot of us grew up with, eggs (rightly) were counted as meats. It's been well understood for a long time how to function without eating meat, as in, the flesh of animals, if you have eggs available as part of your diet. Pure veganism requires some actual thought, yes.
- meepmorp 14y ago> TL;DR: It is extremely difficult to sustain the needs of a child with a pure vegetarian/vegan diet. So really, meat is wholly replaceable in the human diet, though doing so in children may be difficult.
- awolf 14y agoYou get more than just protein from beef. Grass-fed beef, and ruminants in general, contain a wealth of human nutrition. It's not the product, is the producer. The perverse incentives in our meat and farming industries drive production of a vasty inferior product at an unsustainable price.
- tptacek 14y agoWhat is the mass-market meat product that is more expensive to produce than beef?
- rdl 14y agoFarmed carnivorous fish (e.g. tuna)? I've started getting farmed bluefin at the Japanese fishmarket in Berkeley (confusingly called Tokyo Fish Market); it's essentially as good as wild bluefin, and I'll eat it, but is even more inefficient and expensive to produce than beef.
- awolf 14y agoHigh quality meat is irreplaceable in the optimal human diet.
- rosser 14y ago[citation needed] EDIT: I'm a vegetarian. I'm well aware there are nutrients that are harder to get on purely plant-based diets, but it's far from impossible. I'm getting my Omega 3s (all DHA and EPA, not merely ALA) from algae, and my B-12 from plant sources, too. What am I missing by not killing sentient things for sustenance?
- lukifer 14y agoWe have canines for a reason: our evolutionary and digestive history includes meat. I'm sensitive to the moral issues involved, and understand the arguments against eating pigs and cows; however, I think it's reasonably ethical, and biologically optimal, to at least eat fish and eggs. And no matter what, farm animals should be raised humanely (pasture farms, not factory farms).
- rosser 14y agoThat our evolutionary history includes eating meat is by no means an argument that the nutritional benefits of meat are irreplaceable.
- justin66 14y agoEvolution dictates that we live long enough to reproduce and fight off anything that wants to kill our young. There is no reason to assume that it might somehow be a guide to what an "optimal human diet" (silly expression) might be.
- bickfordb 14y agoAnd cave homes are irreplaceable in optimal human architecture?