3 ms·
Errr, did you/are you ignoring that the lockdown was a complete and total failure? That only until it was over did a subject (see my other comments, can't call
by hga 14y ago
Errr, did you/are you ignoring that the lockdown was a complete and total failure? That only until it was over did a subject (see my other comments, can't call Massachusetts residents citizens by the traditional meaning) exit his house and notice something amiss on his property (evidently outside the search parameter), resulting in him calling the police?
- thoughtsimple 14y agoI disagree. They tracked him to Watertown and he couldn't leave because there was no way to move without attracting suspicion. The shelter in place request did exactly what was supposed to.
- hga 14y agoGood, this is a debatable point. Evidently he wasn't bleeding enough when he exited the carjacked Mercedes for dogs to follow him, so they knew roughly where he was, but drew the cordon a little too small (he was really into soccer, probably a good runner). So with enough surveillance, if he'd moved after daylight he might have been caught. Then again, the authorities denied themselves the use of thousands of eyeballs of Watertown subjects, who would have likely recognized him from the description (the point about blood above is that I'm assuming they assumed he wasn't bleeding heavily, a much stronger tell). And it was one of those subject's eyeballs after they came back into play that resulted in the end of the hunt. Given what we know now, it was a mistake. Given what I'm assuming they knew then, it was not obviously one.
- hga 14y agoAh, forgot one of the strong arguments I was thinking during the shutdown; as expressed by Megan McArdle (http://www.thedailybeast.com/articles/2013/04/19/should-the-police-have-shut-boston-down.html http://www.thedailybeast.com/articles/2013/04/19/should-the-...): "it [sends a] message: if you set off bombs in a public space, we will shut down the city and hunt you like vermin until we find you." Of course, that only works if they actually do find you, which they didn't, although they might be able to spin it that way.
- neltnerb 14y agoYes. This. We stayed home because being out would have disrupted the manhunt and made it easier to escape. How is this not obvious?
- InclinedPlane 14y agoThey caught him outside of the search area after the lockdown was lifted. They got lucky.
- bsg75 14y agoFound less than 10 miles from the original crime scene. It is very possible that the lack of traffic made it difficult to travel unnoticed.
- hga 14y agoThe starting point was where he abandoned the carjacked Mercedes, from (always unreliable early) reports that was 5 blocks from the scene. And he was found about a mile from there.
- revdinosaur 14y agoIf your definition of complete and total failure is "no casualties to civilians or law enforcement" after the suggestion was made to citizens, then you are correct. Also, your statement about us not being traditionally defined citizens seems to have something to do with low gun ownership in the region? I would like to refer you to this: http://www.vpc.org/press/1204death.htm http://www.vpc.org/press/1204death.htm
- hga 14y agoMassachusetts as a low murder rate to begin with, so of course it's going to have a low "gun death" rate. Correlation does not imply causation. If you seriously follow these sorts of studies, you'd know not to trust anything coming from the VPC (well, maybe they've done a good one, but I'm not aware of any, and helped Clayton Cramer destroy their "Concealed Carry Killers" http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2095754 http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2095754). And that's irrelevant to my point about the historical definition of a citizen in a republic. You aren't anymore, and whatever good you may think that does you, it still does not change that fact.
- revdinosaur 14y agoDo you have a better source of information which provides alternate takes on the correlation? Generally people attack the source of information they want to disagree with and say "correlation does not imply causality" when they have no data to counter. Again, I am unclear on your definition of our citizenship. Are you suggesting that this event altered it?
- hga 14y agoI only attacked the source after making my greater statistical point, which was obtained in a couple of minutes of using Google and comparing state murder rates (I originally thought MA did have a high murder rate, colored, I suppose, by living next to Boston for dozen years. Should have paid more attention to Somerville, where I perhaps spent the most time, which has a fairly high crime rate but a quite "reasonable" murder rate, at least when I was there). And I attacked the source because I've actually done serious research on their work (well, as one of several minions of Clayton's). It's hard to retain respect for an organization when you track down incidents of "Concealed Carry Killers" and find out many never even had a concealed carry license. Or the guy with the licence didn't hurt anyone (albeit he was an idiot). Or the license was irrelevant, a fumble plus a defective weapon resulted in a true accidental death. Etc.; did you take a glance at the paper I linked to, like I did at the VPC paper? Not to mention I know their history of deliberate lying propaganda, Josh Sugerman is a twisted genius, e.g. he had the whole campaign against "assault weapons" planned out a year or two before Stockton. The VPC is by far the best "think tank" of the gun grabbers (compare to the Joyce Foundation squandering millions trying to establish a "collective right" interpretation of the 2nd Amendment, which 9 out 9 Supreme Court justices disagreed with). To your latter question, no. The traditional historical definition of a citizen in a republic was one who bore arms in defense of it, at least when called upon to. To bring this to American particulars, if you're a citizen or have declared an intention of becoming one and are between 17 and 44 years of age inclusive, you are a member of the unorganized militia (10 USC § 311). But if your state denies you the right to keep and bear arms, or makes that hard, expensive and legally dangerous, so very few do, including I gather you ... I call you a subject, not a citizen.