10 ms·
Breaking News is broken
- nwzpaperman 14y agoIt's only the old public information structure that is broken. A purpose-built public information system is already well into development and early-adopters are seeing the future. I'm lean and committed, so feel free to engage in rational argument. The recipe: 1) Geospatial information system 2) Transparency 3) Exclusively peer-generated content http://nwzpaper.com/socialContract http://nwzpaper.com/socialContract
- guylhem 14y agoOn "Exclusively peer-generated content", you may want to add the stuff you create here on HN to nwzpaper.com, especially after having read your thoughts on Assange and anonymity. It's just a php copy/paste - http://en.blog.guylhem.net/post/48447265179/adding-a-hacker-news-ticker-to-your-website http://en.blog.guylhem.net/post/48447265179/adding-a-hacker-... I can write a javascript version for you if you want.
- nwzpaperman 14y agoThanks for the input! I tend to adapt my comments into articles when the entire thought comes together coherently. I will write an article on the flaws of anonymity. Opportunity cost means trade-offs exist, but the internet already has plenty of anonymous conduits for sharing information. Addendum to the JS thoughts: As people saw with RSS after reader went down, the data structure isn't consistent across the RSS world either. That makes the reader problem more complex than first perceived. Rather than try to distill complex content and fit it into a para-structure, nwzPaper is designed to be a transparent third-party to standardize article format in the publishing form: 1) title 2) abstract 3) location pin 4) article body 5) media Each article includes the journalist's name--not to be confused with the new legal distinction of blogger--and a link to his or her content inventory and a link to a structured "perspective" to interpret the journalist's information product through. If a search engine or aggregator organizes third-party content there will always be an indexing/crawling delay. That makes traditional search brands only useful for non-news, historic information query and analysis. Search was a big deal ten years ago because it got rid of categories, but it is insufficient for solving the news problem.
- lubujackson 14y agoThe way to fix this problem is easy. Cite your sources. "According to a Boston beat cop...", "According to a high-ranking FBI agent..." I am SO sick of hear "according to a source" because they don't want to clue in other news organizations. There was a time when news reporters considered their jobs partially a civic duty. Protecting sources solely for selfish reasons has completely diluted the concept of these "unnamed sources".
- k-mcgrady 14y agoThis doesn't really fix the problem in television news. Most of the reports I watched cited sources but regularly preceded 'information' with "we can't confirm this but...". Another problem is that the media outlets are citing each other and when one media source spreads false information suddenly all media outlets are spreading it citing the original false information source.
- corresation 14y agoI am SO sick of hear "according to a source" because they don't want to clue in other news organizations. Reporters anonymize to protect sources, which in the Western world generally means "keeping them from getting fired" (in much of the world it means "keeping them from getting fired at"). Here's the thing -- either you trust that the reporter/organization has good sources (that they've worked them for long enough that they know that their information is good), or you don't. Adding decorative details on the source (such as "beat cop") does little to support the claims, as often the people who want to talk the most are often the people with the least information. Which is why it is virtually worthless to listen to random people on Reddit making claims that they cite as backed by their own sources ("my uncle who is a xyz says that..."). I have absolutely no reason to believe the Reddit poster is telling the truth, and even if they were I have no reason to believe that their source is telling the truth. The world is full of liars and bullshitters. Add in the well-meaning people who "fill in the unknowns" to make the story more interesting....it's just a sea of noise that is overwhelmingly wrong. It's unfortunate that now traditional media feels that they need to fight this static by embracing it (the most laughable being reporters reading "tweets" on topics), the net result being the lowest common denominator for all.
- 14y ago
- rythie 14y agoIt's broken except for everyone who had to find out they were in lock down and not to go out as a result. It's broken except for the people who saw the suspect in the boat - who knew from breaking news that he was being chased. It's broken except for the people who wanted celebrate on the streets when the suspect was caught. In the UK at least, the newspapers are often wrong in all the same ways suggested in the article, so that luxury of only publishing once a day doesn't seem to help that much.
- MatthewPhillips 14y agoAs someone who exclusively followed this story online, the idea that it can replace traditional media is much overstated. Traditional media might grasp at straws and over-analyze, but you at least get some indication of what is going on. The last hour of the standoff I had no idea what was going on other than the suspect was in a boat. And I was following all of the people you're supposed to. On a personal note, I found myself nervous all of Friday. I did check twitter frequent, refresh a few websites, etc. So from a sanity standpoint, I completely agree with the author and I'll be taking the advice next time. Go do something productive. Get your mind off the horror; you can update yourself tomorrow.
- gkoberger 14y agoI don't think you were following the "all the people you're supposed to", then. In this particular case, Reddit did an awesome job of staying up to date (and correcting misinformation). EDIT: http://www.reddit.com/r/news/comments/1cnwms/mods_removed_thread_live_updates_of_boston/ http://www.reddit.com/r/news/comments/1cnwms/mods_removed_th...
- charonn0 14y agoI'm not a regular reddit user, but the thread(s) on the manhunt were more accurate than, and often scooped, the CNN talking heads I had on in the background.
- kens 14y agoSpecifically, the Live Update threads on reddit.com/r/news were amazingly detailed. I'm not normally a reddit user, but the minute-by-minute details went way beyond what I found elsewhere. (Although you end up with a lot of unfiltered stuff - anyone know what's up with the 70-year old man with the trigger switch that was being discussed there?) On the other hand, Fox made me gnash my teeth when a reporter on the street in Boston presented "breaking news" that there would be a press conference in a few hours, which is hardly news let alone breaking news.
- MatthewPhillips 14y ago
- brianmackey 14y agoI basically stumbled onto this strategy this week. My job doesn't leave me with much time to obsessively follow breaking news on Twitter or TV. The first day or two, I listened to NPR for a couple of hours (full disclosure: I work at a member-station). But it wasn't until the next morning, reading my dead-tree edition of The New York Times, that I felt like I had a decent grasp of what the facts were. Of course there are limitations: my NYT still had the suspects at large Friday morning. Obviously the story had developed considerably since press time. Nevertheless, Manjoo's point is well-taken. If you don't live in the immediate vicinity (and thus need the news for personal safety), your knowledge -- and your blood pressure -- will probably benefit from a bit of moderation in news consumption.
- estsauver 14y agoWhile I appreciate the sentiment, there's a very real reason to watch breaking news while you're in the area. My school was shut down and everyone was told to stay inside, which makes it awfully hard to grab a book and let things blow over. It's a fundamentally different thing to watch the news about somewhere else then it is to watch the news about where you are.
- radley 14y agoYou're doing it wrong. Most breaking news isn't meant to be watched continuously. Most news is designed for people who are busy doing other things and checking in once in a while. Breaking means it's so new they haven't had time to summarize & package it for you, so it'll be rough and weird. That's it. The reason it's repetitive is to sound fresh for the next guy who checks in. If you're spending time watching it repeat, expecting something new to happen as you're watching, you're frankly doing it wrong.
- aristidb 14y agoWell, a lot of people are doing it wrong then.
- dllthomas 14y agoMaybe we need two channels, one that loops(ish) with the latest situation, and another that's just a feed of updates?
- austenallred 14y agoThere's no reason these need to be two channels; they're really two ways of sorting the same information. (I'm building something that I think solves that problem).
- uptown 14y agoYour second premise sounds similar to what Circa does from a news-app standpoint. Curated updates to stories you've designated that you're interested in following-up on.
- olefoo 14y agoSo the technical solution is to have our news reading environment be aware of which items we've seen, and only alert us when new information on a topic we've expressed an intent to follow comes in. So imagine that CNN tries to reinvent themselves after this weeks fiasco. They spend a bunch of time and money setting up their newsgathering operation to tag everything with metadata and provide special software to consume the tag feeds and manage users attention; gobs of customisation options, in depth access to the underlying data, not just for financial news, but also the analysis of breaking events and the public reaction thereto. Basically a Bloomberg Terminal, with a broader focus. And if they do all of that. They will continue to lose money to outlets that treat events as a cross between a circus-freak sideshow and a particularly bloody genre of morality play ( FOX and NYPost, as instances of the Grand Guignol approach to journalism ).
- crazygringo 14y agoThis is exactly the same conclusion I came to at the end of the day yesterday. I realized I probably "wasted" three hours following the story. Because at the end of the day, I gained nothing I couldn't have gotten in reading an article at 11pm for five minutes. I swear, it's like a drug. It's exciting at the time, but afterwards you think, well, that was a stupid waste of my time.
- crazygringo 14y agoPS Sometimes I wish there were a news service that would identify news headlines by their degree of importance. Rank 1 headlines would be SMS-ed to me immediately. Rank 2 would be e-mailed immediately. Rank 3 would be collated by e-mail daily. I could choose specific categories of interest (technology, US politics) to add to the daily e-mail of lower ranks (4, 5, etc.) That way, I'd always know I wasn't missing anything important, but not wasting my time either. Happily, there would be whole days where nothing of importance happened, and I'd have nothing to read!
- john_w_t_b 14y agoNice idea. I am sure there are startups doing that already, but don't know one offhand. TV news is a waste of time. It is addictive though.
- disc 14y agoWhen your job is to get people to pay attention to you, why would categorize anything as less than the most important? Crowd-sourcing the importance might be better, but that brings us right back to a HN/reddit solution.
- maxerickson 14y agoYou could make the bet that credibility today is worth increased attention tomorrow. I guess lots of people might not think that is a good bet.
- 14y ago
- lotharbot 14y agoIt's not so much that "breaking news is broken" as that breaking news has certain specific failure modes. When "breaking news" is covering an ongoing disaster or police action, where the information they're getting is potentially second- or third-hand, and where the primary sources might not fully understand what they themselves witnessed, there's a lot of opportunity to go wrong. Crimes and disasters may play out very differently from expectations, and may therefore require careful after-the-fact analysis of every available shred of information, before they're actually understood. On the other hand, certain events can be fully and clearly understood right as they happen. Consider "new Pope selected", "tornado spotted 3 miles west of Townsville", or "School track team takes second at Rival Invitational; Person wins 4 individual events". Official announcements, or events happening according to an understood pattern, generally come through the "breaking news" cycle without problems.
- austenallred 14y agoThe problem isn't that there are unconfirmed reports floating around, that has always been the case and always will be. The problem is that the major news bodies are reporting unsubstantiated rumors as truth without having the time to investigate. Basically news is a race, and since the major reporting institutions used to be the only ones racing they would always win, so they would make sure they would do it right. Now they're racing with Twitter, yet trying to have the same authority as they used to. It's a race you can't win. Just listen to the news for a few minutes and you'll hear "Many sources are saying that..." That really means "We're watching Twitter, and..." but they're not willing to admit that they don't really know for sure.
- dclowd9901 14y agoI like when media takes an effort to critique itself but since the critics are generally simply writers, no actual progress is made in bettering things. It has all of the effectiveness of a meeting that results in no action items.
- Paul_D_Santana 14y agoEasy solution: Don't read, listen to, or watch the news. If I recall correctly, there was even an article about this idea on Hacker News just a few days ago. If there is ever anything really important, I am bound to hear it via conversations with my family, friends, or co-workers. Or even a quick scan of headlines on HN. No need to be glued to CNN. However, articles on HN about inspiring topics, software engineering principles, or new ways of thinking, there's something worth reading.
- senthilnayagam 14y agoTwitter as news is bleeding edge, not for the weak hearts, and it is not trying to replace news channels. most of the initial tweets were wrong, you are seeing the thought process before it has been confirmed. One good part, with people tweeting and the power of amplifying via retweets, it would tough to stage events as in conspiracies
- Aardwolf 14y agoIn fact, I often just read the Wikipedia article after the facts. It is often must better organized than the combination of articles from the days before. Of course, the news did help, it made me aware of the event in question happening. But it's not really the source of actual information.
- mcphilip 14y agoRidiculous article, IMHO. Breaking news isn't 'broken', it's just that there's an immaturity in the consumers of breaking news when trying to interpret the info. For instance, a couple of years ago when I first joined Twitter after realizing it was the best way to get breaking news (i.e. I literally joined to follow @BreakingNews), one of the first breaking news tweets I ran into was "NORTH KOREA SAYS WAR WILL RETURN TO THE CONTINENT". My initial reaction was "wow, I'm glad I joined Twitter and have early access to this important information". It didn't take long to realize that while the breaking news was true in that it quoted an official NK representative, it was useless in alerting me to a new war because I was not yet aware that NK pulls this kind of stunt relatively frequently. While there are plenty of incidents in the past week where false information was spread, it doesn't imply to me that I should ignore breaking news until it is properly spoon fed to me in a newspaper article the next day. Instead, it just reminds me that something like a feed from an unfiltered police scanner should be considered as a source of limited information about an occurring event.
- austenallred 14y agoI would argue the fault lies as much with the traditional media in displaying what is really wishy-washy as die-hard fact in order to get views/pageviews/whatever else they need.
- mcphilip 14y agoI agree with your placing blame on traditional media displaying unverified information as facts, for sure. I guess the point I was trying to make is more that much of the incorrect info spread last week was a result of a chain reaction of people incorrectly interpreting breaking news. For instance, on the matter of blaming the missing Brown student, I remember comments in a reddit thread that were quickly deleted showing a comparison of the face of the Brown student with the officially released FBI photos of "Suspect #2". The comment didn't claim they were the same person, it just raised the question. However, it only took minutes for the reddit hivemind to jump to the conclusion that the Brown student was "Suspect #2"
- 14y ago
- kmfrk 14y agoNew York Times's "The Lede" was perfectly fine as an online resource. From what I've read, MSNBC's Pete Williams - I think it was - also did a stellar job, which could mean that "fixing" breaking news just means turning to MSNBC instead of CNN. Twitter is as good as the people you follow. Duh. Stupid linkbait article.
- D9u 14y ago...I’m choosing not to mention his name here, that’s not going to accomplish very much—it’s already been stained. How about, instead of your current headline, you put his name in your headline, along with the words, "HE HAD NOTHING TO DO WITH IT!"
- dredmorbius 14y agoStudies suggest that trying to correct myths and errors in this way tends to backfire. I did correct posts I'd already made tying the Brown student to the bombers.
- npsimons 14y agoUpvoted for the (TL;DR) byline alone: Don’t watch cable news. Shut off Twitter. You’d be better off cleaning your gutters. Too true.
- pseut 14y agoThis article kind of misses the point in a few ways 1. During important events, a lot of us want to be/feel connected to what's going on. Watching on TV does that and following reddit/twitter/web does that too, but picking up the paper hours later doesn't. You could make the same argument as the article about the super bowl: if you want to know what happened, don't use twitter or watch the game on TV (remember when everyone thought the 49ers were going to score on that last drive to win the game? LOL FAIL!) just wait until a few hours after it's over and read about it on your favorite website! I mean, that's all true, but it misses the point. For a lot of events, for better or worse, we want to know what's happening as it happens. 2. I use twitter to follow breaking news and news related to my profession (I'm an economist), so I choose who to follow based on that and know which people are reliable and unreliable; @AntDeRosa (among others) is awesome and responsible; I stopped following some other people for irresponsibility during hurricane sandy, etc. So there's no universal "twitter." I get a lot of valuable "breaking news" out of twitter and reddit, but depending on how other people use it, they may not. I really doubt that the Manjoo really believed that all of the rumors he read online were true. 3. Pretty much all of the relevant breaking news on, say, cyprus was coming from twitter. There are many other examples. For breaking non-mainstream news, there is no alternative to twitter etc. For this event, some of the threads on r/news were amazingly informative. 4. From what I've read, a lot of the misinformation problems were caused by journalists either on TV or online. Point fingers at them. edit: and by "them" I mean those particular people, not "journalists" as a group.
- seanalltogether 14y agoThe sports game analogy is spot on. We don't watch breaking news to learn the facts, we watch it to observe the drama.
- cddotdotslash 14y agoAll true, and you said what I came here to say. Another point: breaking "news" is helpful for those who are affected by the situation at hand. What I think the author of the article fails to mention is that people are following the news because they are either involved, want to be connected (like you said), or know someone who is involved. I have several friends in Boston and I was following the news up to the second because I wanted to see what was happening. I took what I heard with a grain of salt, but I was better informed and more aware of their situation.
- DanielBMarkham 14y agoThe product that you appear to be buying is instantaneous transmission of the news, perhaps as much as a minute or two ahead of others. The product you are actually buying is non-existent. You are the product. People pay good money in order to manipulate your social drive to keep you as viewers. I said this to some friends on FB yesterday, but it bears repeating. Of all the players in this terrible tragedy, the terrorists, the police, the news media, the administration, the politicians, the security-industrial complex and so forth -- it's in everybody's interest to create and sustain some huge public spectacle. That's not a good thing for a democracy or the continuation of a free society. </rant>
- nostromo 14y agoI realized late last week that I wasn't following this story as a news story anymore. I literally felt like I was watching 24, with cliff-hangers and all. It had stopped being something I followed to remain a well-informed person and just devolved into popcorn-munching entertainment. It's a clear reminder that limiting news consumption is healthy.
- milfot 14y agoThat's curious, my need for instantaneous news has been waning. This past few weeks events (local and international) have really been the proverbial straw. I now wait. For news, I want truth not action.
- maigret 14y agoIndeed. I can only advise you to read "The Information Diet" if you haven't yet. The state of the media influences a lot the state of politics as well - and not only that, our whole culture. 24/24 news watching is more than popcorn, rather like only eating bacon burgers.
- Evbn 14y agoWhy do the police--the people getting shot at, want a spectacle?
- 14y ago
- arocks 14y agoNot just news, it is often better to be unplugged most of the time if you like to get your creative juices flowing. The constant distractions are actually the real roadblocks to critical thinking and creativity these days.
- jusben1369 14y agoIt's worth noting that TV news had the same impact on print as social media now has on TV news. It's very new right now and we're finding our way.
- pritianka 14y agoI completely agree with the comments here that news coverage has devolved into addictive popcorn munching fare. Sadly, this onion piece hits home: http://www.theonion.com/articles/breaking-has-the-word-breaking-lost-all-its-meanin,32115/ http://www.theonion.com/articles/breaking-has-the-word-break... Having worked in PR, I truly feel the world of media and journalism needs some serious disruption (hate that I used the word, kill me now). Hopefully some startup is cranking away :-)
- mightybyte 14y agoI've thought this for quite some time, but it became especially clear to me yesterday. I was at the gym where TVs were unavoidably visible, but the volume was turned down so I couldn't hear anything. I was there for an hour or so and the picture and headline didn't appear to change at all the entire time. It said something about cops with guns drawn in Watertown...THE WHOLE FRIGGING TIME! I have almost zero interest in the sports stuff that normally graces the gym TVs, but yesterday I was longing for ESPN. This just leaves me more convinced than ever that mainstream news the way it exists today is actually harmful to society.
- ereckers 14y agoDon Lemon of CNN just now did a segment on how America can start to "heal" with Dr. Drew, so they do have that going for them. Then Wolf at CNN spent about 20 minutes describing how cool thermal imaging of the boat was, while failing to mention the kid was actually discovered after the owner of the boat noticed his boat cover was ripped and went to check it out. I'm not sure that news outlets like CNN are "broken" per se as they had abandoned "news" a long time ago (would OJ be a turning point?). Just like the History channel is "broken" cable news is "broken". They just don't care about news, it's really about audience retention and ratings. There's really nothing wrong with that, it's just up to us to abandon them just as they have abandoned their original intentions.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- anigbrowl 14y agoSo's opinion-writing based on breaking news. Slate's just feeling blowback from the clumsily-written opinion piece they published earlier this week in which one of their writers expressed the hope that the bombers were white Americans - presumably because he doesn't want to see another ill-thought-out foreign military adventure. A worthy enough sentiment on its own, but expressed so insensitively and divisively that these criticisms come across as nothing more than an attempt by the publisher to deflect scrutiny onto other media outlets.
- SonicSoul 14y agoit is some sort of human phenomenon, where we put up with a lot of inconveniences just to get the real time (or near real time) experience of something.. i think waiting in line for an apple product, putting up with commercials to watch some tv show on the night it airs, paying large premiums for a device that will be a lot cheaper in 6 months, wasting hours in live news coverage to be the first to hear about the new developments of the story all fall into the same category. it just doesn't make sense because all of these things are better at a later time. when there are no lines, and the story is polished and more factually correct.
- Symmetry 14y agoGenerally speaking I'd say that the problem is more that most daily news will give you a distorted view of the world as you come to believe that newsworthy things are much more common than they really are. I try to follow the news only on a week to week only basis, a long enough lag to let people actually get their facts straight before rushing to report. Reading the wikipedia pages for events also tends to result in a really good summary without excess fluff. Of course, last Friday I was stuck inside with everyone else in my section of Boston and I mostly spent the day following my friends with scanners on zephyr. So the temptation does get to be too much when the news is too close by.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- caseysoftware 14y agoNewsflash: Rumors move faster than facts. Film at 11. Uninformed conjecture at 10.