4 ms·
>4 people killed in a week is not a lot compared with the background level of deaths in the US. It's not as many as in the Texas explosion. Car accidents in t
by sergiotapia 14y ago
>4 people killed in a week is not a lot compared with the background
level of deaths in the US. It's not as many as in the Texas
explosion. Car accidents in the US kill around 100 people a day, and
surely grievously injure hundreds more.
============================
Difference being of course, one was a deliberate attack on human life, and the other a very _very_ unfortunate accident.
Stupid comparison to make for the sake of pushing his agenda of "free software". I expected more from someone so smart.
- bung 14y agowoosh
- john_whelan 14y ago+ one of those four people was a police officer
- tolmasky 14y agoIs killing a police officer worse than killing a "normal" person?
- john_whelan 14y agoYes, though I may sound cliche, they put their life on the line everyday for us. When you go to work do you need to carry a gun with you and know that you might not come home at night?
- waqf 14y agoOkay, and why is killing someone who is risking their life worse than killing anyone else?
- TWAndrews 14y agoWorking as a Police Officer is considerably less dangerous than many other labor-intensive professions. http://open.salon.com/blog/richard_rider/2010/11/08/police_firefighter_work_dangerous_yes_and_no http://open.salon.com/blog/richard_rider/2010/11/08/police_f...
- josephagoss 14y agoIn a police state, it is.
- InclinedPlane 14y agoThe death of a police officer is no more tragic, necessarily, than the death of anyone else. However, an attacker who is brazen enough and well-prepared enough to attack and kill a police officer is more of a threat to the public. Ordinary citizens are generally not as well armed, armored, or trained as police officers, nor are they in near constant contact with police dispatch. Someone capable of and willing to kill police is someone who just doesn't care anymore and is willing and able to kill almost anyone.
- rdouble 14y agoOrdinary citizens are generally not as well armed Not sure how accurate that statement is in America.
- InclinedPlane 14y agoI said generally. Also, even with someone who religiously carries a gun as much as possible it would be unusual for them to carry a full-sized duty pistol and the ammunition that most cops do (stereotypically a Glock 22 w/ a 15 round magazine and 2+ additional magazines, a total of 45 or more rounds). Certainly some folks do but I'd doubt that number is even in the double digits throughout the entire US, excluding off-duty LE and people working security in some capacity. People who carry concealed tend to choose smaller, lighter guns and not quite as many total rounds, because ammunition is heavy (stereotypically a Kahr PM9 w/ an extra magazine, a total of 14 rounds, or maybe a Glock 26 w/ an extra magazine, a total of 20 rounds).
- rdouble 14y agoMost concealed carry people I know use a normal sized 9mm. It's only been very recently that mouse guns have become trendy. Kahr has only existed as a company since the mid 90s. However, I wasn't talking about concealed carry when I made my comment.
- sk5t 14y agoDouble magazine pouches for concealed carry are not exactly a niche product. I would wager there are tens of thousands of Americans who pack a medium frame pistol and two spare mags.
- HarryHirsch 14y agoI hate to say it, but Stallman has a good point. Plant safety cuts into profits, left to itself management will not encourage safe working practice - there must be meaningful oversight by an outside agency. Thanks to regulatory capture oversight is weak, and this is not an accident but an intended outcome of the political system.
- mindcrime 14y agoPlant safety cuts into profits, left to itself management will not encourage safe working practice - there must be meaningful oversight by an outside agency. Yes, because it's obviously good for business to have your plant blow sky high, destroying the entire surrounding neighborhood and killing most of your employees. If I were a plant manager, I'd make sure to put doing all that right at the top of my TODO list. Or, maybe, just maybe, not everybody who owns/runs a business in a capitalist system is a greedy, evil, soul-sucking bastard, and maybe, just maybe, accidents happen, some of which are damn near unpredictable and unavoidable. And maybe we can't regulate our way to a society where nothing bad ever happens to anybody, ever?
- HarryHirsch 14y ago> Yes, because it's obviously good for business to have your plant blow sky high You know how this is - most often poor working practice has no immediate consequence. Perhaps a critical patch is installed a few days late, and the website does not get hacked, no adverse consequences most of the time. At some point someone will run the numbers, and conclude that good safety practice isn't that necessary. That's a recipe for disaster. Most everyone here should be familiar with the Challenger explosion and the runup to it. > maybe, just maybe, accidents happen, some of which are damn near unpredictable and unavoidable. That's the issue of fault-tolerant design. In an ammonium nitrate plant there is a risk of explosion; they quite simply do not belong anywhere near a town.
- mindcrime 14y agoAt some point someone will run the numbers, and conclude that good safety practice isn't that necessary. That's a recipe for disaster. Most everyone here should be familiar with the Challenger explosion and the runup to it. That's a fair point in a sense, and I'm not arguing that it isn't beneficial to have some independent eyes looking at things and helping avoid bias. I would argue that it's not necessarily required to regulate that sort of thing and make it the job of government to try and prevent every possible contingency though. I think working to develop a voluntary certification process, something akin to ISO9001, where being certified would be a "badge of honor" and - eventually - all but a prerequisite to doing business, would be preferred. In an ammonium nitrate plant there is a risk of explosion; they quite simply do not belong anywhere near a town. That was definitely a sub-optimal design, for sure. I'd be curious to know the history of how that setup happened, actually. OTOH, to play devil's advocate a little bit... how often do ammonium nitrate plants explode? One could probably argue that the industry actually is very safe if you look at it over the long-run. Or not... I don't actually have those statistics. Just a point of discussion.
- ivanca 14y agoI would downvote you if I could because the comparison is certainly not stupid; just because you fear more the will of the others over accidents does not make it stupid. If for example cars were allowed (mechanically and legally) to only accelerate to maximum 50mph many of those accidents would never happen, but people are not willing to loose their freedom to drive at crazy speeds but somehow they are willing to loose other freedoms for extremely rare events such as terrorism attacks just for the emotional effect it haves over them because it is an attack (and not an accident) with nothing rational backing it up.
- gvb 14y agoThey should be restricted to 4mph and be preceded by a man with a red flag. That would be much more effective than limiting them to 50mph. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Locomotive_Act#The_Locomotive_Act_1865_.28Red_Flag_Act.29 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Locomotive_Act#The_Locomotive_A...
- bane 14y agoI have to drive to work, lunch and home every single day, I have to deal with an ongoing terrorist attack almost never.
- homosaur 14y agoIf you expected anything from Stallman other than to say something socially tone deaf and head slapping, well... you don't know much about RMS.