3 ms·
What is the international arms trade and who are the major players?
- benhodges 14y agoIs this really appropriate for Hacker News?
- rdl 14y agoI blindly post any priceonomics blog entry because they tend to be awesome, not specific to the subject matter.
- benhodges 14y agoThe numbers and analysis are interesting, but the article seems to me to have some anti-NRA, pro-gun/arms control bias. I think they're usually fairly neutral. I predict we'll see another re-hashing of the gun control / second amendment debate here in the comments. There have been a few submissions lately that make me wonder if Hacker News is headed in the direction of Reddit. I don't mean to pick on yours particularly, the timing was just convenient.
- rdl 14y agoYeah, I agree it wasn't the best priceonomics blog post. I'd be fine with a really strong/insightful analysis of the firearms or weapons industry (the way all their other posts have been in the past), but this one looks mostly political. Interesting "priceonomics-worthy" aspects of the global arms trade would be: 1) Longevity of weapons -- I mean, I saw maxim guns in Afghanistan. 2) The weird market in EUCs, embargoes, etc. 3) Stuff like Brown Moses/CJ Chivers where they analyze the weird origins of weapons used in current conflicts (e.g. Syria and Libya) -- weird low-volume US prototypes found in Libya, and Croatian knockoffs of other designs as part of some "elimination of stocks" by post-Balkan countries. The NRA/domestic politics parts are the least interesting. Outside of small arms, the NRA has basically no relationship to the munitions industry, either.
- shirederby 14y agoIt isn't, and I don't know why you're being downvoted for asking.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- Evbn 14y agoToo soon.
- jabbernotty 14y agoToo soon since what?
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- PavlovsCat 14y ago"The business of murdering people" -- there, better? Can we now address the elephant in the room?
- DamnYuppie 14y agoThat would be war, genocide, and homicide. The elephant in the room is the feminization of our nation where everyone believes they need to be protected.
- PavlovsCat 14y agoThere is a difference between being protected from all harm, ever, and simply not actively condonding, or even paying for being physically hurt and/or killed, or for others to enjoy that privilege. Unless we're in a "no, but the real issue is" dick waving contest, in which case I would like to bring up the heat death of the universe, the ultimate futility of all materalistic undertakings, and stoicism if not love being the only answer to that. Your turn :)
- DamnYuppie 14y agoYour first sentence honestly makes no sense to me. Here is why I say that. We all have the ability to drive, and are in fact licensed to do so by the government, yet far more people die by automobile then by firearms. More people die by falling down stairs then by firearms. More people participate in hunting in this country then any other activity, and it has the lowest number of injuries. That being said it appears to me that you are seeking to deny people the ability to bare arms for the illusion of safety when there are many other things out there that are far more dangerous.
- camus 14y agowhich is ?
- jessriedel 14y ago> Approximately $11.7 billion worth of guns are sold in the United States and there are 30,000+ deaths in America each year tied to gun violence. That first number is a more important than the second by more than an order of magnitude. Keep in mind George Will's statistic that the US spends more than $2 billion on Easter candy each year.
- bcl 14y agoThe 30,000 number is BS. They are likely including suicides. Here are the homicide numbers for 2011 - http://www.fbi.gov/about-us/cjis/ucr/crime-in-the-u.s/2011/crime-in-the-u.s.-2011/tables/table-20 http://www.fbi.gov/about-us/cjis/ucr/crime-in-the-u.s/2011/c... Actual total for 2011 is 8583.
- rdl 14y agoThe whole first half of the post is kind of off-target, IMO, because it is dollar weighted, vs. type of weapon weighted. The US predominately sells two things: big "weapons systems" (radars, aircraft, etc.) to middle tier countries, and a comprehensive range of small arms both domestically and to allied countries. The weapons which primarily affect individuals and civilians in conflict are small arms, landmines, and certain ISR and ground attack resources. As a percentage of the total, it's about 1%. It doesn't hurt the life of a guy in Jordan that his neighbors have F-16s with top-end avionics. It does matter to a guy in the Congo that a box of cheap AK-47s has arrived. Within the US, arms are both an economic issue (LockMart, etc. are huge employers, and wisely spread production/employment across congressional districts), and a civil rights issue (for small arms; no one really cares about F-16s for private ownership). Either issue is more than enough to keep the industry safe. Russia, etc. are the same. What I'd really like to see is a great analysis of the domestic small arms market -- who makes primers, who makes powder, brass, rifles, importation permits for foreign mil surplus, foreign current manufacture, etc. That is vastly more relevant to the 2A issues than who makes radars.
- aptimpropriety 14y agoI think you're right - the post fails to address how big of a necessary / not necessarily negative component of our foreign policy/diplomacy is centered around arms trade. I'm no expert on the subject, but have worked with people with experience in this area. One thing I remember is hearing that the US has the distinction/disadvantage in the business of refusing to work with bribes. My question to you - if you thought the article was off-target, why submit it? Seems pretty disingenuous to me.
- rdl 14y agoThe foreign policy aspects are just that we give financial aid to countries who then are only allowed to buy our weapons -- in some cases we give aid to our enemies (Pakistan, Egypt) to turn them into dependent friends, or to "sterilize" our air to our actual allies (e.g. Israel). Outside of our top end weapons systems (many of which, like the F-22, we refuse to sell), no one is clamoring for US small arms or other weapons; if we weren't giving them money, they'd be just as happy with Russian or Chinese arms. They addressed the issue in the second half. But, this is the world of TL;DR.
- tnuc 14y agoIt's funny how much money is in weapons and how the media reports it. http://www.economist.com/news/world-week/21576445-kals-cartoon http://www.economist.com/news/world-week/21576445-kals-carto...